YouBet said:
M.C. Swag said:
lol well it bums me out that TA consensus is they're not worth it when in my mind it's the best sci fi story I've read since Dune. I thought 3-6 were genuinely near masterpieces of storytelling. But reading is subjective.
Out of curiosity, when you say Dune do you mean Dune the novel, or are you including the subsequent books? Because I think that's where I'm getting bogged down. Dune, the novel, is obviously incredible. An all-timer. However, Messiah, Children, and God Emperor were average, IMO. Just a lot of talking and philosophizing (especially God Emperor) like Suneater but also explains all the comparisons between the two. I have not read past God Emperor yet which I think I've read picks back up and is closer to Dune than the other three.
My opinion on Dune, the series, has changed from when I first read
Dune Messiah. Honestly, when I was a teen, I didn't understand Herbert's intent, and I hated that book so much that I declined to read any further. With these new movies, I re-read
Dune for probably the fifth or sixth time - still my all-time favorite science fiction novel. When we learned the third movie would be based on the second book, I picked it up again. This time I fully understood Herbert's intent. Is it as good as the first? Not at all. But I did actually enjoy the entirety of that story, and that prodded me to continue the series.
Over the next 3-4 months, early this year, I read in succession
Children of Dune, God Emperor of Dune, Heretics of Dune, and
Chapterhouse: Dune. I loved every one of them, even the fourth one that features a character transforming into a sandworm. Yes, they are heavy on the philosophy, but it's more than that. Herbert weaves his stories in such a way to leave the reader considering events from multiple angles, and he does not tell you what to think; he leaves it to you to come to your own conclusions. I'll contrast this with the two books that were written by his son and another writer and were supposedly based on notes Herbert left behind after his passing that outlined what he intended to do to finish the trilogy that began with
Heretics of Dune. The son/friend split the third story into two separate books -
Hunters of Dune and
Sandworms of Dune. I have read the first and am currently reading the second. These will be the last books I ever read for a first time from this universe. And compared to Frank Herbert's work, these suck. The writing style is much more juvenile. They spend time telling you rather than just describing a room or environment and letting the reader picture it himself. I guess I also am not terribly enthusiastic about how the story has unfolded, but it is what it is.