Yes it should

Nuh uh

An epic journey across the world to destroy a magical ring is much more believable than acting like Maggie Gyllenhaal is attractive

LOLZ. Blue star.

Moe Jzyslak said:

---

An epic journey across the world to destroy a magical ring is much more believable than acting like Maggie Gyllenhaal is attractive

---

I'm a Dark Knight superfan, but damn, that's POTD material right there.

Moe Jzyslak said:

---

An epic journey across the world to destroy a magical ring is much more believable than acting like Maggie Gyllenhaal is attractive

---

Moe Jzyslak said:

---

An epic journey across the world to destroy a magical ring is much more believable than acting like Maggie Gyllenhaal is attractive

---

Ask you parents to take the control locks off the TV and watch her in Secretary some time.

87 votes in - FOTR and ROTK are separated by 1 vote.

Moe Jzyslak said:

---

I'm too busy watching the extended editions of LOTR for the 5th time in the last month

---

Why so few times?

Tanya 93 said:

---

I have never seen The Dark Knight.

---

Homework assigned!

Actually somewhat envious of you. TDK is one of those things that you wish you could rewatch for the first time.

Over the years, FotR has pulled further away from the other two, for me. FotR is a perfect movie and is by far the best adaptation of the material to film, imo.

I love the other two and think each has things in them that are perfect, but FotR is just so good. I think RotK just gets the recognition because it's the finale. Over the last 22 years, I have grown to really dislike the Army of the Dead "I Win" button as well as Gandalf being made out to look like a weakling in front of the Witch King. And the neutering of Faramir is the biggest sin in the entire franchise.

And this is coming from someone who LOVES everything about Rohan from the book and the movies.

The changes made in FotR are all perfectly fine, imo.

only 11 straight votes tonight from our favorite troll. Last night it was 14. You're slipping, buddy.

Elite 8 Results!

Lt Aldo Raine Regional Final

No Country for Old Men def. Inglorious Basterds 53.4%-46.6%


Maximus Decimus Meridius Regional

Gladiator def. Inception, 65.5%-34.5%


Captain Jack Sparrow Regional

The Dark Knight def. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl 78.4%-21.6%

Les Grossman Regional

LOTR: The Fellowship of the Ring def. LOTR: Return of the King 57.8%-42.2%

Final Four with a bonus question or two coming in 1 hour.

The Final Four is Here!

VOTE NOW

Semifinal #1

Gladiator (release date May 5, 2000)



vs.


No Country for Old Men (release date November 9, 2007)




Semifinal #2

The Dark Knight (release date July 18, 2008)



vs.


The Fellowship of the Ring (release date December 19, 2001)

Quote:

---

No, but then I'm going to ***** about it once it starts because you left off some bull**** 8th lead from some movie nobody's ever heard of.

---

Never understood the love for No Country for Old Men. Good movie, but the fact it's in the final 4 shows how high some people regard it, which I don't get. I personally think O Brother Where Art Thou and True Grit are better movies, in this century.

Lathspell said:

---

Never understood the love for No Country for Old Men. Good movie, but the fact it's in the final 4 shows how high some people regard it, which I don't get. I personally think O Brother Where Art Thou and True Grit are better movies, in this century.

---

Waltz in IB > Bardem in NCFOM

Lathspell said:

---

Never understood the love for No Country for Old Men. Good movie, but the fact it's in the final 4 shows how high some people regard it, which I don't get. I personally think O Brother Where Art Thou and True Grit are better movies, in this century.

---

I think Hell or High Water is better than all of them.