If this can keep anything near the tone/approach of Andor I am sooooooo in.
Star Wars Discussion Thread
6,947,663 Views |
46145 Replies |
Last: 2 days ago by jokershady
Someone please tell me that Tony Gilroy is secretly in charge of The Acolyte.
My dream scenario is that all projects SW projects going forward go through a group consisting of Tony Gilroy, Jon Favreau, Dave Filoni, and a consulting George Lucas.
Then, one of the 3 guys showruns or produces a particular project and they trade off like MCartney and Lennon used to do on songwriting duties.
Then, one of the 3 guys showruns or produces a particular project and they trade off like MCartney and Lennon used to do on songwriting duties.
Quote:
Someone please tell me that Tony Gilroy is secretly in charge of The Acolyte.
I wish. It's Leslye Headland, the showrunner of Netflix's Russian Doll. So it's at least someone who's done something unique and well-received, and is an incredible writer in general. That said, Headland is very, shall we say... outspoken... and may very well end up rubbing a certain crowd the way. I could be way off, and hope I am, but based on interviews Headland has given, I'm bracing for something very feminist in nature, and thus the reactions to it. Hopefully it's all done in an interesting, non-preachy way, though.
‘THE MANDALORIAN’ Season 3 premieres on March 1 on Disney+ #CCXP22 pic.twitter.com/JgGDdtMMDI
— DiscussingFilm (@DiscussingFilm) December 1, 2022
Is this a new announcement? Don't know why I thought they'd confirmed a February date earlier.
Brian Earl Spilner said:
My dream scenario is that all projects SW projects going forward go through a group consisting of Tony Gilroy, Jon Favreau, Dave Filoni, and a consulting George Lucas.
Then, one of the 3 guys showruns or produces a particular project and they trade off like MCartney and Lennon used to do on songwriting duties.
I'm afraid Gilory will be one-and-done, unfortunately. On one hand, in interviews, he's sounded like he absolutely loves the showrunner process (which he had never done before), along with the control it allows him. He's said numerous times how refreshing it is to be writing stuff he *knows* will be made, and how much he loves the collaborative process with the particular team he has on Andor.
That said, he's also sounded like someone who will be ready to move on a year and a half from now, take a long break, and then direct a film smaller in scale in again. Granted, Lucasfilm could always deliver a semi truck full of cash to his house, so nothing is out of the question. But my gut says he goes back to doing his own, smaller stuff again come 2024.
Brian Earl Spilner said:
Is this a new announcement? Don't know why I thought they'd confirmed a February date earlier.
Yeah, they had previous said February, but not an exact date. March 1st is now official, though.
It was just one website throwing out February 22 and also that a new trailer would arrive on Christmas.Brian Earl Spilner said:
Is this a new announcement? Don't know why I thought they'd confirmed a February date earlier.
Jon Favreau has a writing credit for every episode of Mando Season 3.
What Favreau had to say in Brazil this weekend
We like to keep surprises so that each week as we tune in, we get to discover things. Hopefully, unexpected things occur. I think it was really wonderful that everybody that worked on the show was able to keep Grogu a secret until he was revealed in the first episode. Also with Mark Hamill as Luke Skywalker appearing in season 2. Not everything is gonna be a big surprise like that, but each week it should be something unexpected happening. And that's the idea of having a serialized television show where, what's nice about it compared to a film, is that every week everybody gets to see a chapter and discusses it and guesses what's gonna happen next.
I will say, though, that the scope of it is getting bigger. We have really cool space battles, we have lots of Mandalorians, we have the planet of Mandalore, which we've been talking about for a long time. We learn more about the Mandalorian culture, and of course, all the great actors that you've seen from seasons previous, many of them returned, and we get to see them all work together on this show. So it's been a very ambitious season, a lot of our directors have returned, a very experienced team that has been working on The Mandalorian for a long time. And I think that people are gonna be really excited when they see what we have in store. Hopefully, each week it will be like opening a Christmas present for everybody with surprises and something that delights them."
There was new footage shown at this event. Not sure about the validity of it, but among the reports we see
a very populated planet, possibly Coruscant, Grogu using the Force to battle a "monster in a cave", Mando's new ship evading TIE fighters, and possibly a return of Boba Fett.
- Season 3 Episode 1: Jon Favreau
- Season 3 Episode 2: Jon Favreau
- Season 3 Episode 3: Noah Kloor and Jon Favreau
- Season 3 Episode 4: Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni
- Season 3 Episode 5: Jon Favreau
- Season 3 Episode 6: Jon Favreau
- Season 3 Episode 7: Jon Favreau and Dave Filoni
- Season 3 Episode 8: Jon Favreau
What Favreau had to say in Brazil this weekend
We like to keep surprises so that each week as we tune in, we get to discover things. Hopefully, unexpected things occur. I think it was really wonderful that everybody that worked on the show was able to keep Grogu a secret until he was revealed in the first episode. Also with Mark Hamill as Luke Skywalker appearing in season 2. Not everything is gonna be a big surprise like that, but each week it should be something unexpected happening. And that's the idea of having a serialized television show where, what's nice about it compared to a film, is that every week everybody gets to see a chapter and discusses it and guesses what's gonna happen next.
I will say, though, that the scope of it is getting bigger. We have really cool space battles, we have lots of Mandalorians, we have the planet of Mandalore, which we've been talking about for a long time. We learn more about the Mandalorian culture, and of course, all the great actors that you've seen from seasons previous, many of them returned, and we get to see them all work together on this show. So it's been a very ambitious season, a lot of our directors have returned, a very experienced team that has been working on The Mandalorian for a long time. And I think that people are gonna be really excited when they see what we have in store. Hopefully, each week it will be like opening a Christmas present for everybody with surprises and something that delights them."
There was new footage shown at this event. Not sure about the validity of it, but among the reports we see
a very populated planet, possibly Coruscant, Grogu using the Force to battle a "monster in a cave", Mando's new ship evading TIE fighters, and possibly a return of Boba Fett.
Timestamped. You gotta love Keanu.
TCTTS said:Quote:
Someone please tell me that Tony Gilroy is secretly in charge of The Acolyte.
I wish. It's Leslye Headland, the showrunner of Netflix's Russian Doll. So it's at least someone who's done something unique and well-received, and is an incredible writer in general. That said, Headland is very, shall we say... outspoken... and may very well end up rubbing a certain crowd the way. I could be way off, and hope I am, but based on interviews Headland has given, I'm bracing for something very feminist in nature, and thus the reactions to it. Hopefully it's all done in an interesting, non-preachy way, though.
A lot of people like to blame poor reception or criticism of woke or political charged franchise releases on "toxic" fandom, but the issue is that someone decided to take a franchise that existing fans were much more emotionally invested in and use it as a medium for their own personal diatribe, which usually sucks. If you want to make a statement piece on the virtues of diversity of feminism or whatever, then do it with your own ideas. About the worst thing you can do with an established franchise with a fanbase as big as SW is take something they're emotionally invested in and use it to talk down to them. The fandom isn't toxic, it's insulted.
I have a bad feeling about this...
I agree to an extent, but I don't think it's as black and white as you're making it out to be. The fandom can certainly be justified at times, but it can *also* be objectively toxic as hell at times, too.
As for the messaging, it all depends on the execution. So many girls, moms, dads, etc absolutely LOVE Rey, because she gave young girls a lead/hero they could better-identify with, which is great. So I don't begrudge the filmmakers for making the lead of the sequel trilogy a female, if only because it opened the franchise up to a whole new audience. The problem is, while Daisy Ridley knocked the performance out of the park, most adults saw the character for what she was, somewhat of a Mary Sue who could, say, inexplicably challenge someone as skilled as Kylo Ren in her first-ever lightsaber battle. That aspect of the execution was of course dumb as hell, but I see it as a misstep in an otherwise good, well-intentioned, core idea. They just didn't know how to execute it properly.
Who knows where The Acolyte lands in that regard, all we can do is hope that they've learned from their past mistakes.
As for the messaging, it all depends on the execution. So many girls, moms, dads, etc absolutely LOVE Rey, because she gave young girls a lead/hero they could better-identify with, which is great. So I don't begrudge the filmmakers for making the lead of the sequel trilogy a female, if only because it opened the franchise up to a whole new audience. The problem is, while Daisy Ridley knocked the performance out of the park, most adults saw the character for what she was, somewhat of a Mary Sue who could, say, inexplicably challenge someone as skilled as Kylo Ren in her first-ever lightsaber battle. That aspect of the execution was of course dumb as hell, but I see it as a misstep in an otherwise good, well-intentioned, core idea. They just didn't know how to execute it properly.
Who knows where The Acolyte lands in that regard, all we can do is hope that they've learned from their past mistakes.
An advantage The Acolyte will have, as do the other shows, is a written story with beginning, middle, and end from the jump. The protagonist (or antagonist maybe, depending on how you see it) will have a complete arc through the season already written for her.
Had that simple thing existed for the sequel trilogy, even in broad strokes, 80% of the issues would have been eliminated. That's one reason the series have been so much better than what we got in the sequels.
Had that simple thing existed for the sequel trilogy, even in broad strokes, 80% of the issues would have been eliminated. That's one reason the series have been so much better than what we got in the sequels.
Did anyone seriously have issues with a female lead in the sequel trilogy?
This is a series that has a classic "damsel-in-distress" who turns out to be much more a fighter than one might expect. This is a series that has a strong leader in galactic politics. The Disney-era SW even gave us a strong female rebel in Rogue One. Anyone who boohoos on Rey is likely a knuckle-dragging caveman.
We can argue about the execution of the sequel trilogy, which largely was a mess.
As for woke crap, I had only one issue with the quick shot of a gal kissing another gal at the end of The Rise of Skywalker. Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
This is a series that has a classic "damsel-in-distress" who turns out to be much more a fighter than one might expect. This is a series that has a strong leader in galactic politics. The Disney-era SW even gave us a strong female rebel in Rogue One. Anyone who boohoos on Rey is likely a knuckle-dragging caveman.
We can argue about the execution of the sequel trilogy, which largely was a mess.
As for woke crap, I had only one issue with the quick shot of a gal kissing another gal at the end of The Rise of Skywalker. Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
Maybe on their planet you kiss each other on the lips when you're happy. Way to be a planet-ist.Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Did anyone seriously have issues with a female lead in the sequel trilogy?
This is a series that has a classic "damsel-in-distress" who turns out to be much more a fighter than one might expect. This is a series that has a strong leader in galactic politics. The Disney-era SW even gave us a strong female rebel in Rogue One. Anyone who boohoos on Rey is likely a knuckle-dragging caveman.
We can argue about the execution of the sequel trilogy, which largely was a mess.
As for woke crap, I had only one issue with the quick shot of a gal kissing another gal at the end of The Rise of Skywalker. Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
maroon barchetta
Joined:
Sep 28, 2021
Posts:
36,475
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Release date announced for the sequel to Fallen Order. Should have a trailer during the Game Awards later this week (if it doesn't leak sooner)
bluefire579 said:
Release date announced for the sequel to Fallen Order. Should have a trailer during the Game Awards later this week (if it doesn't leak sooner)
Was just coming here to post this. Can't wait. Also, BD-1 is my all time favorite droid.
I think there's a real chance of an appearance for Cal and co. in a future anthology (Tales of the Jedi, etc.) or possibly a series. That story is uniquely fitted between some others, ranging from 13 to 9 BBY (so far). They cast a legit actor to the video game role and the survivor theme is compelling.
That said, it's often tough to translate video game characters to other media because their powers are so defined.
There's a sweet BD-1 lego set I'm hoping to snag for Xmas.
jeffk said:
There's a sweet BD-1 lego set I'm hoping to snag for Xmas.
I haven't built a Lego set in decades but it's on my list as well
Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
What are your thoughts on this?
Quote:
The bond-twins Terec and Ceret in Marvel's Star Wars: The High Republic comics are the first trans non-binary Jedi in modern galactic lore. Using the pronouns they, them, and their as individuals, the Kotabi Jedi also share a linked mind, finishing each other's sentences and sensing each other's pain.
I'll answer for him.
That's stupid
That's stupid
Plenty of not good but so as to not be accused of some hogwash F16 crap I'll keep them to myself.The Collective said:Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
What are your thoughts on this?Quote:
The bond-twins Terec and Ceret in Marvel's Star Wars: The High Republic comics are the first trans non-binary Jedi in modern galactic lore. Using the pronouns they, them, and their as individuals, the Kotabi Jedi also share a linked mind, finishing each other's sentences and sensing each other's pain.
I think blaming fandom has become a bit of a crutch and armor for bad writing/casting/etc. It can certainly be bad and there will always be a fringe minority of loud ***holes, but I think that is built up as a bit of a strawman to deflect from valid criticisms.
I don't think SW fans have a problem with a female lead or the concept of Rey. Leia is one of the most popular female leads/characters in cinema, and she's OG SW. Padme was another strong female lead, albeit her character got kind of jobbed in AotC and RotS. I feel like she should have gotten more screentime and development. Ahsoka has always been well received and a fan favorite. She's one of, if not the, the strongest characters in the SW universe. Jyn Erso was well received, and Mon Mothma has been as well. The SW fandom has always welcomed and appreciated strong female characters and leads. As you said, the problem was in execution, and the lazy, "Anything you can do, I can do better because GIRL POWER!" plot was what people hated. The "toxic" fandom was blamed for the poor reception though.
I hope they don't screw this up, but I also think it's very hard for a writer/director/producer who is "outspoken" to dial it back. They're the type that puts their thoughts and feelings front and center in their work because that's why they work and what tends to make their work good. Working with an established IP and franchise is the opposite though. You have to understand that your thoughts and ideas come second and it's not your own personal soapbox.
I don't think SW fans have a problem with a female lead or the concept of Rey. Leia is one of the most popular female leads/characters in cinema, and she's OG SW. Padme was another strong female lead, albeit her character got kind of jobbed in AotC and RotS. I feel like she should have gotten more screentime and development. Ahsoka has always been well received and a fan favorite. She's one of, if not the, the strongest characters in the SW universe. Jyn Erso was well received, and Mon Mothma has been as well. The SW fandom has always welcomed and appreciated strong female characters and leads. As you said, the problem was in execution, and the lazy, "Anything you can do, I can do better because GIRL POWER!" plot was what people hated. The "toxic" fandom was blamed for the poor reception though.
I hope they don't screw this up, but I also think it's very hard for a writer/director/producer who is "outspoken" to dial it back. They're the type that puts their thoughts and feelings front and center in their work because that's why they work and what tends to make their work good. Working with an established IP and franchise is the opposite though. You have to understand that your thoughts and ideas come second and it's not your own personal soapbox.
I personally thought rey started out as a great character and well cast.
Then it became apparent that there was no actual character or plot, they just wanted a homeless girl luke skywalker to repeat the ep iv plot with worse everything except special effects, and then in the later movies, the only 'plot' was just random woke scenes in a steaming pile of nonsense.
Then it became apparent that there was no actual character or plot, they just wanted a homeless girl luke skywalker to repeat the ep iv plot with worse everything except special effects, and then in the later movies, the only 'plot' was just random woke scenes in a steaming pile of nonsense.
Costco has em for $80.
Pitch Meeting: It's the first Start Wars, but Luke is a girl and Darth Vader is an angsty emo who wants to bang her over to the dark side. Also, the Death Star is back and it's bigger and badder than ever.
ABATTBQ11 said:
Pitch Meeting: It's the first Start Wars, but Luke is a girl and Darth Vader is an angsty emo who wants to bang her over to the dark side. Also, the Death Star is back and it's bigger and badder than ever.
But there is always a way to blow it up.
Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Did anyone seriously have issues with a female lead in the sequel trilogy?
This is a series that has a classic "damsel-in-distress" who turns out to be much more a fighter than one might expect. This is a series that has a strong leader in galactic politics. The Disney-era SW even gave us a strong female rebel in Rogue One. Anyone who boohoos on Rey is likely a knuckle-dragging caveman.
We can argue about the execution of the sequel trilogy, which largely was a mess.
As for woke crap, I had only one issue with the quick shot of a gal kissing another gal at the end of The Rise of Skywalker. Injecting earth lifestyles into a galaxy far, far away reeks of political garbage, given that there were no gay characters in the previous trilogies. If you want to tell a story of gay folks in space, do it in your own damn story, not an established story with such a huge fanbase.
I can't believe you wrote earth lifestyles with a straight face. You know what else is an earth lifestyle? Leia and Han kissing
Maybe I should have used terms like "modern" or "modern deviant" or something?
Han and Leia kissing has never been a problem.
Han and Leia kissing has never been a problem.
Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Maybe I should have used terms like "modern" or "modern deviant" or something?
Han and Leia kissing has never been a problem.
Now discuss Luke and Leia.
Leia and Luke were separated at birth and had no idea they were siblings. Leia had no romantic feelings towards Luke, she kissed him to make Han jealous.maroon barchetta said:Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Maybe I should have used terms like "modern" or "modern deviant" or something?
Han and Leia kissing has never been a problem.
Now discuss Luke and Leia.
In some states, this is perfectly normal.maroon barchetta said:Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Maybe I should have used terms like "modern" or "modern deviant" or something?
Han and Leia kissing has never been a problem.
Now discuss Luke and Leia.
AggieCrew44
Indiana Head Coaching Search (Buzz mentioned as one of top)
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
102
KillerAg21
Indiana Head Coaching Search (Buzz mentioned as one of top)
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
35
aginlakeway
Indiana Head Coaching Search (Buzz mentioned as one of top)
in Billy Liucci's TexAgs Premium
34