AliasMan02 said:
bangobango said:
amercer said:
Solo failed because the general public had zero interest in a young Han Solo movie 30 years late. (Also, it probably would have made money had they not shot the film twice) It had nothing to do with fanboys bitter over TLJ, since all of them saw Solo anyway...
Nope. Sit back and hide when Episode IX is released. Unless Disney makes drastic moves, that move is going to tank like you would not believe.
For the endless noise you talk and for how your major hobby seems to be calling people out on Star Wars threads, I feel like you need to put a number to this claim, for the record. Like, total box office domestic and international
It will be the first star wars third act to not make more than the movie before it.
But I earlier added the caveat "unless Disney makes drastic changes," so remember that. If Kennedy steps down or they appoint a creative director, and if Lucasfilm starts reaching out to the fans they alienated and apologizes/reconciles/just acts like their complaints have some validity and not call them all racists or sexists, then it can still recover. I think they would also have to find a way to work Mark Hammil back into the movie and they have to let everybody know that he will have the type of moment everyone wanted for him in episode VIII.
But if they go in with no Han, no Leia, and no Luke, yeah, it's going to bomb big time - for a star wars movie. You have to judge these things in context. The name alone still puts a lot of people in the theater, though I am afraid that will soon go by the wayside if they don't do something to fix this. Solo is reportedly going to lose 50-80 million dollars. It will be the first star wars movie to lose money. TLJ blu-ray sales were terrible.
Only reason TLJ did anything at all and wasn't a massive failure is
1. there was a lot of good will from TFA awakens and JJ did a good job setting up a lot of intrigue for the next two movies.
2. Reviews were outstanding from critics who are in similar bubbles as Rian Johnson and don't understand that Star Wars movies are popular myths and as such, they should be simple and direct and give the audiences what they want. "Subverting expectations is fine," but it needs to be done in furtherance of telling a good story, not just do it to do it.
TLJ had the biggest weekend one to weekend two drop in the history of American cinema because people got word of mouth from the FANS that it was a crap movie. Excuses were made at the time just like the excuses were made for Solo. When this stuff starts piling up one after another you are whistling past the graveyard if you keep blaming it on things like "it was released too close to Deadpool." Deadpool.... This is Star Wars we are talking about. Star Wars is the one who knocks, and we're talking about releasing too close to Deadpool.
The other thing that is going to kill Episode IX is there will be other big blockbuster releases that will go head to head with it. Jumanji and Greatest Showman showed the champ can bleed and now other studios smell blood in the water. They will not be scared to schedule big budget films to go head to head with Episode IX and that will hurt it even more.