I always thought it was pretty obvious how badly the Jedi failed during that time.
Star Wars Discussion Thread
6,744,378 Views |
45804 Replies |
Last: 1 hr ago by powerbelly
I see that years later. Back when I saw Sith, for whatever reason, I saw it more as a personal failure of Anakin.
both the jedi and the prequels were failures
quote:
both the jedi and the prequels were failures
Give someone like Filoni a shoestring budget, and let him retell the fall of Anakin Skywalker. Guarantee it is 100x better than what we got. They wouldn't have to erase all of the canon created by the prequels - just tell from another perspective...similar to the Bible having 4 gospels.
Who the **** voted for IG-88?
quote:
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/star-wars-spin-off-movies-what-should-they-be-921584
Lost Stars would be a d*mn fine movie. If they ever do a "from the empire's perspective" I hope they look at Lost Stars for a script.
From that article:
quote:No. No, no, no. WTF is wrong with George Lucas?
Mace Windu: George Lucas recently gave his blessing to Samuel L. Jackson's assertions that Mace Windu somehow survived getting blown off a skyscraper with Force lightning in Revenge of the Sith.
Obi Wan winning handily.
quote:
From that article:quote:No. No, no, no. WTF is wrong with George Lucas?
Mace Windu: George Lucas recently gave his blessing to Samuel L. Jackson's assertions that Mace Windu somehow survived getting blown off a skyscraper with Force lightning in Revenge of the Sith.
I actually found it likely that Windu survived. We see Jedi jump great distances all the time so it would be more likely that a Jedi Master like Mace recovers and is able land safely on a flying car or building or something. If Maul can survive being cut in half then Mace can survive losing his arm.
But then the question becomes, what the hell was Mace doing the rest of his life? Why didn't he ever make a move?
With the element of surprise he could've easily taken out Vader and then Palps.
With the element of surprise he could've easily taken out Vader and then Palps.
man, if stupid ass Clone Wars decision to bring back Maul is an argument in favor of Mace surviving, I want nothing to do with it.
quote:Neither should have survived.
man, if stupid ass Clone Wars decision to bring back Maul is an argument in favor of Mace surviving, I want nothing to do with it.
quote:Canon is canon bro,
man, if stupid ass Clone Wars decision to bring back Maul is an argument in favor of Mace surviving, I want nothing to do with it.
quote:quote:Canon is canon bro,
man, if stupid ass Clone Wars decision to bring back Maul is an argument in favor of Mace surviving, I want nothing to do with it.space magicthe Forcefan boy with creative power allowed Maul to survive from worse odds so why not Mace?
fify
quote:
But then the question becomes, what the hell was Mace doing the rest of his life? Why didn't he ever make a move.
Walking the earth like Caine in Kung Fu?
Brian Earl Spilner
Joined:
Aug 6, 2013
Posts:
64,971
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Voted for Wedge and disappointed to see how low his vote total is.
Also don't understand the people voting Yoda/Boba Fett. Didn't the prequels teach people anything about delving into the history of characters for whom mystery is part of their appeal?
Also don't understand the people voting Yoda/Boba Fett. Didn't the prequels teach people anything about delving into the history of characters for whom mystery is part of their appeal?
I am fine with Maul surviving. Greatest character in the animated universe. His French brother, however, is trash.
I voted for a Knights of the Old Republic film. Because it would be a completely clean slate.
quote:
I am fine with Maul surviving. Greatest character in the animated universe. His French brother, however, is trash.
Jean Maul?
quote:
Voted for Wedge and disappointed to see how low his vote total is.
Also don't understand the people voting Yoda/Boba Fett. Didn't the prequels teach people anything about delving into the history of characters for whom mystery is part of their appeal?
I bet some people are still mad at the actor that played him for saying he'd be bored resuming the role for TFA.
Question of the day:
Assuming Mace had lived, could he have killed the Emperor? If so, how would he have done it?
Assuming Mace had lived, could he have killed the Emperor? If so, how would he have done it?
quote:he tried once and died
Question of the day:
Assuming Mace had lived, could he have killed the Emperor? If so, how would he have done it?
I think palps started playing the victim when Anakin came in to force him to make a choice and led him down the dark side.Yoda couldn't kill him and neither could Mace alone.
quote:
Question of the day:
Assuming Mace had lived, could he have killed the Emperor? If so, how would he have done it?
No
(Not a difficult question)
quote:Jean Savage Opress Maulquote:
I am fine with Maul surviving. Greatest character in the animated universe. His French brother, however, is trash.
Jean Maul?
quote:Indeedquote:
Question of the day:
Assuming Mace had lived, could he have killed the Emperor? If so, how would he have done it?
No
(Not a difficult question)
quote:
I am fine with Maul surviving. Greatest character in the animated universe. His French brother, however, is trash.
But he should never have been given the chance to be a great character in the animated universe
Interesting. The ring theory stuff is actually fascinating once you start looking into it.
This looks like exactly the type of documentary I really enjoy watching.
This looks like exactly the type of documentary I really enjoy watching.
Yeah, same here. Looks like it comes out digitally on September 14, so we shouldn't have to wait too long.
quote:F-cking brilliant
If you don't like them, there's always star trek.
two things that sucked about the prequels in my mind were episode 1 and whinyankin
If you don't like them, there's always star trek.
I can't like both?
Featured Stories
See All
A&M at risk of undercut when undertaking trip to underrated Auburn
by Olin Buchanan
48:02
1d ago
4.1k
5:59
22h ago
2.2k
16:53
1d ago
3.1k