In that EW piece I originally linked to, there was a quote from Michael Shannon about Zod that I thought was slightly peculiar when I read it...
quote:
"He actually has some affection for anybody who's a Kryptonian, including Superman," Shannon says. "He doesn't really have any malignant feelings toward him; he just wants him to be patriotic."
Based on that quote, and I few other bits of info out there, we know that Zod is hunting down Kal-El not to kill him, but to A) "arrest" him - in a sense - for being a pure birth (i.e. not genetically manipulated, as everyone else on Krypton is), and B) to hold Kal-El to some kind of allegiance to Krypton. Point being, if there was no Krypton, Zod's motivation for going after Kal-El wouldn't make much sense. It'd be like the last cop alive trying to arrest a criminal, only with no police department, no jail to take him to, and no more laws. If Krypton is gone, there would be nothing for Kal-El to be patriotic to. And Zod wanting to apprehend Kal-El for being a pure birth, when no other Kryptonian citizens or laws exist anymore, would feel a bit lacking. In other words, if what we know is true, Krypton has to exist for Zod's motivation to exist. Otherwise, he's just hunting down Kal-El for revenge, and we know that's not the case. So, in that sense, I'm fine with Krypton still existing as long it's what's helping provide the proper motivation for the villain.
Besides, can't Krypton still be destroyed in the sequel? Would that not still have the same effect? Or is the whole point that Kal-El- has to be "alone" as he grows up on Earth? And isn't he already? I mean, all through his adolescence, he doesn't even know what Krypton is. In this version, I don't think he finds out about Krypton 'til he makes it to the Fortress of Solitude, so what's the difference? Growing up in Smallville, he knows he's a freak. Then his dad tells him he's actually an alien, but he doesn't know much more than that. To me, that's alienating enough (no pun intended), whether Krypton exists or not. Plus, I kind of sort of am starting warm to this idea of Clark losing one father (Pa Kent), only to find out he has another (Jor-El, who's still alive, but not yet reachable). That's kind of cool.
Further, the more I think about this, the more it lines up with the theme of "choice" that's so prevalent in the marketing. Like Aggies76 mentioned, I think he's going to have to
choose Earth. It's not just this planet he's stuck with. He's going to have to choose to stay here and help us, which is almost more powerful and meaningful in a way.
Either way, I'll echo the sentiment that Nolan/Goyer (at least as a team), have never let us down. I trust whatever decisions they've made, and am going into this one with a completely open mind.
[This message has been edited by TCTTS (edited 5/3/2013 11:34a).]