I pondered this issue during my staff induced hiatus from TexAgs... and the answer came to me.
You are despised because you are the college athletics equivelent of law school gunner guy (LSG).
LSG thinks highly of himself, sees himself as one of the top students in the class, asks questions premised on unrealistic hypos to make some asinine point, takes the professor off the lesson plan on some meaningless tangent and generally just likes to hear himself talk. Typically, after first semester grades are posted, LSG is humbled by the fact that all of his "insightful" questions, extra reading, and rushing up to the professor after class earned him a ranking somewhere in the middle of the class (if that).
LSG's humbling experience shuts him up for about 3 weeks(these three weeks were absolute bliss for those of us in the top ten percent of our class). But, after a few weeks, LSG rationalizes to himself that his 50th percentile performance was better than half the class and he's convinced that if only he could gun just a little bit harder, he'll vault up to the top of the class. So LSG doubles down on his behavior...
What's worse is that some professors would affirm LSG's behavior by responding that LSG's random, non-test worthy point was "interesting". (Think of a Clemson fan telling you how awesome Kyle Field was)
Now, I'll concede that this isn't the perfect compairson, after all, Baylor/Tech have historically performed worse than TAMU in the field of athletics, but even people who were below LSG in class rankings hated LSG...
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=law+school+gunner[This message has been edited by Baylor81 (edited 2/25/2010 12:24p).]