bdp514am said:
I think we'll need a bigger sample size to see how it all shakes out. But early returns suggest being the WC is at the least not a huge disadvantage. Certainly not the disadvantage it was when you had the 1 game WC and your rotation was screwed for the next series.
I mean, the Rangers were forced to throw a bullpen game against the Orioles ace and still won. That's an advantage any team in baseball will take. If you can't take advantage of that, then it's on you, not the format.
In Rosenthal's article in
The Athletic today, I was surprised that the whole notion seems to be finding ways to get the top seeds to advance, which kinda defeats the point of the playoffs in sports to begin with. It also appears that most complaints are coming from fans, not players, management, or the MLB.
In a sense, the MLB widening the playoff format feels a bit like how the NHL goes, where teams fighting for playoff spots for weeks on end tend to have an emotional advantage early in the series over teams that cakewalk into a playoff spot.
But the facts are this: the Braves had a losing record at home against Philly this year. The Orioles and the Rangers split their season series, and Texas tattooed Rodriguez multiple times. Despite differences in record, some teams just match up better against others.