rbtexan said:
I'll answer my own question....no you didn't.
Because if you had read my post, you would've seen the part at the top where I said
Quote:
Here is a list of players currently on the 40 that I don't expect to be with the team/on the roster next season. That may be due to trades, retirement, DFA, whatever
Do you want me to go back and find some of your posts prior to the '22 season when you were telling us all how stuck we were with a crappy roster, completely ignoring the fact that players can be traded or signed as FAs?
Sure, if it pleasures you... we had a crappy roster prior to '22 because we wouldn't trade or improve the roster. JD's idea of signing FAs centered around signing TJ retreads in hopes they'd have a good season (Gibson, Lynn, Lyles) and have trade deadline value. It was the point of tanking.
Sorry if I hurt your feelings. It wasn't my intent.
I did read your post. Which of these players do YOU think get traded?!
Ian Kennedy - FAZak Kent - Serf1
Yerry Rodriguez - Serf1
Jake Odorizzi - FAJosh Sborz (on the fence on this one - personally I'd dump him) - Serf3
Cole Winn - Serf3
Mitch Garver - FAJon Ornelas and/or Josh Smith - Both Serfs
Brad Miller - FADustin Harris - Serf1
JP Martinez - Serf1
Robby Grossman and/or Travis Jankowski <- Both FAI don't think any of those players have trade value. I don't think any retire.
I believe they will all be on the 40 this offseason... and likely during the season 2024.
I think Sborz is worth keeping. If he can stay healthy he is an option in the pen.
I think Winn's time has passed. He might be a candidate to retire, but doubt that will happen. He has been snake bit and will likely serve out the course of the 2024 season. He'll likely make a few million signing as a FA over a few years.
JPM seemed promising. He has little trade value now. I was high on him.
Most of those guys are not going to be contributors of any magnitude. It wouldn't hurt my feeling if they dumped them, but unless there are better options, we'll likely keep them.
Having said that... guys I HAVE suggested could be traded before 2024:
Taveras, Adolis, Duran, and Semien. I could see Dunning, Gray, and Heaney among those talked about in trades. I made those comments around the ASB with the qualifier that we win the World Series. If we win the WS, it might be worth trading Adolis or Taveras and slipping in Carter or JPM into the OF, knowing Langy is also a future option.
If Duran continued to hit well, he might be an option at 2B and give Semien an option to play for another team of his desire.
A rotation of Scherzer, Eovaldi, and one or two of: Heaney, Gray, Dunning would fit nicely with an OWhite or Bradford. Both look promising and could hold until deGrom returns.
I'd pick up Heaney's extra $7M bonus and trade him.
I don't disagree with your premise... I wanted to put team status with your list and window for carpool was approaching, so I cut my comments short. PS... I was still late.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/04037/04037470076e2739f9ae48fd043403aa8840f6b2" alt=""
We could have plenty of roster turnover. Especially if we win the WS.