Wabs said:
RED AG 98 said:
Wabs said:
Whoa! Meyers and Chas in the same lineup!
Semi-hot take that I'm sure you will all agree with: this is maybe our best defensive alignment.
I think the only positions that are really up for debate would be:
C - It's really close and with more experience I think Yanier will eclipse Maldy.
2B - again, pretty close at this point in their careers
Absolutely our best OF alignment. I would say Dubon at 2B is a slight upgrade over Altuve (defensively and at this point in their career). I hope Dubon keeps the bat going. Catcher, I think is a draw at this point, with a slight lean to Maldy. Yes, I know Yanier has a cannon, but that brain fart yesterday shows his youth in decision-making. Maldy definitely has that over him. I hope Maldy can keep recent success at the plate going...
Dubon is a massive upgrade over Altuve defensively. Altuve plays for his bat at this point in his career.
Last season Altuve Baseball Reference had Altuve's dWar at -1.2; zone fielding runs above average at -3; and defensive runs saved at -15.
https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/a/altuvjo01.shtmlSo far this season Baseball Reference has Dubon's dWar at .5 (in 36 games started at 2b, if that played out over a season he'd have well over a 2.0 dWar); 5 zone fielding runs above average; and 4 defensive runs saved.
Projected out for 1200 innings (if Dubon played 135 games) it would be 18 zone fielding runs above average, and 15 defensive runs saved. Dubon is the difference in saving (and giving up in Altuve's case) 30 runs over the course of a season.
https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/d/dubonma01.shtmlNot that it means anything since it's only four games, but Altuve has already dipped into the negative in 2023, and the projected numbers are worse than 2022 defensively.
These numbers don't take into account arm strength either. Altuve is my favorite Astro of all-time, so I don't post this to run him down.