Farmer1906 said:I agree with your general premise. If we are just replacing Diaz's DH appearances for Brantey's DH plate appearances then we're missing an actual opportunity to get better.Proudag06 said:
Would love Brantley to come back and produce but it is only a net positive if Dusty will put Diaz in the field regularly and he's almost certainly not going to. And for as good as a healthy Brantley would look in this lineup (replacing someone like Dubon/Meyers/Singleton) he won't be an upgrade over Diaz.
Diaz has an OPS of .812 (and it's only going up, last 30 games is almost .900). Brantley hasn't had an OPS above .800 since 2020. He has also only hit more HR 2 times in his career than Yainer has already this year (in half the ABs).
So, unfortunately, if a healthy Brantley who hits at his career average (which is extremely optimistic) returns….we get worse unless Diaz is inserted into the field.
However, the comparison of Diaz's & Brantley's OPS highlights the issue with OPS. It overvalues slugging. That is why Brantley has a better wOBA.
From 2022-now
Stat - Diaz / Brantley
OBP - .370 / .289
SLG - .416 / .511
OPS - .776 / .801
wOBA - .334 / .345
Off WAR - 2.3 / 7.7
wRC+ - 127 / 114 (this one is a little unfair since offense is up this year)
Boiling Denim said:
We're gonna have a really interesting off-season replacing an entire pitching staff that all retire in solidarity with Maldy
Proudag06 said:Farmer1906 said:I agree with your general premise. If we are just replacing Diaz's DH appearances for Brantey's DH plate appearances then we're missing an actual opportunity to get better.Proudag06 said:
Would love Brantley to come back and produce but it is only a net positive if Dusty will put Diaz in the field regularly and he's almost certainly not going to. And for as good as a healthy Brantley would look in this lineup (replacing someone like Dubon/Meyers/Singleton) he won't be an upgrade over Diaz.
Diaz has an OPS of .812 (and it's only going up, last 30 games is almost .900). Brantley hasn't had an OPS above .800 since 2020. He has also only hit more HR 2 times in his career than Yainer has already this year (in half the ABs).
So, unfortunately, if a healthy Brantley who hits at his career average (which is extremely optimistic) returns….we get worse unless Diaz is inserted into the field.
However, the comparison of Diaz's & Brantley's OPS highlights the issue with OPS. It overvalues slugging. That is why Brantley has a better wOBA.
From 2022-now
Stat - Diaz / Brantley
OBP - .370 / .289
SLG - .416 / .511
OPS - .776 / .801
wOBA - .334 / .345
Off WAR - 2.3 / 7.7
wRC+ - 127 / 114 (this one is a little unfair since offense is up this year)
Where did you get these numbers? Brantley's 2022 OPS is .786. Plus Yainer's big league OPS is .800 since 2022 and .812 this year.
I still think we mostly agree and you were trying to show the problem with OPS but I am not sure about those numbers.
Farthest-outside strike 3 in an MLB game all season long! https://t.co/XQweBeatue
— Codify (@CodifyBaseball) August 16, 2023
RED AG 98 said:
"Oh my goodness. That is is awful." Even the Nats' announcer knew this was just terrible. And Codify says it's the worst miss of the season.Farthest-outside strike 3 in an MLB game all season long! https://t.co/XQweBeatue
— Codify (@CodifyBaseball) August 16, 2023
Umpire: Bruce Dreckman
— Umpire Scorecards (@UmpScorecards) August 16, 2023
Final: Red Sox 5, Nationals 4#DirtyWater // #NATITUDE#BOSvsWSH // #WSHvsBOS
More stats for this game 👇https://t.co/JWMXtSakDO pic.twitter.com/3TB7cBrt0V
Kudos to Justin Turner for not throwing hands. pic.twitter.com/EGEn0BXWQS
— Rich Eisen (@richeisen) August 16, 2023
"He might be able to play today. It's day-to-day and he told me he feels fine. He was walking out of the stadium just fine as well." - Dana Brown on Jose Altuve's knee contusion.@SportsTalk790 @SeanUnfiltered @moneyonthemic7
— Brian LaLima (@BLima790) August 16, 2023
texasaggie2015 said:"He might be able to play today. It's day-to-day and he told me he feels fine. He was walking out of the stadium just fine as well." - Dana Brown on Jose Altuve's knee contusion.@SportsTalk790 @SeanUnfiltered @moneyonthemic7
— Brian LaLima (@BLima790) August 16, 2023
MLB’s second-half fWAR leaders:
— MLB Deadline News (@MLBDeadlineNews) August 16, 2023
1. Matt Olson 2.2
2. Freddie Freeman 2.1
3. HA-SEONG KIM 2.1
4. BOBBY WITT JR 2.1
5. Cody Bellinger 2.0
6. LARS NOOTBAAR 1.9
7. Marcus Semien 1.8
8. Kyle Tucker 1.8
9. Austin Riley 1.8
10. CHAS MCCORMICK 1.8
11. Ronald Acuna 1.8 pic.twitter.com/3PPhdsMbYI
HBD Maldy 🥳 pic.twitter.com/e2zXonycgt
— Houston Astros (@astros) August 16, 2023
"I think he will be fine. There's no leaking oil. Fatigue is the biggest thing. He's definitely confident but I think fatigue is the biggest." - Astros GM Dana Brown talking with us on @sportstalk790 about Cristian Javier's struggles. @SeanUnfiltered @moneyonthemic7
— Brian LaLima (@BLima790) August 16, 2023
texasaggie2015 said:"He might be able to play today. It's day-to-day and he told me he feels fine. He was walking out of the stadium just fine as well." - Dana Brown on Jose Altuve's knee contusion.@SportsTalk790 @SeanUnfiltered @moneyonthemic7
— Brian LaLima (@BLima790) August 16, 2023
EastCoastAgNc said:"I think he will be fine. There's no leaking oil. Fatigue is the biggest thing. He's definitely confident but I think fatigue is the biggest." - Astros GM Dana Brown talking with us on @sportstalk790 about Cristian Javier's struggles. @SeanUnfiltered @moneyonthemic7
— Brian LaLima (@BLima790) August 16, 2023
I think they're comfortable with Diaz catching them. He has caught all but Framber and JV.tjack16 said:
The pitchers do know that it'll be Diaz next year right? So they might as well get comfortable with him now
Lars just missed his name being an anagram for Tootblan by one "T".EastCoastAgNc said:MLB’s second-half fWAR leaders:
— MLB Deadline News (@MLBDeadlineNews) August 16, 2023
1. Matt Olson 2.2
2. Freddie Freeman 2.1
3. HA-SEONG KIM 2.1
4. BOBBY WITT JR 2.1
5. Cody Bellinger 2.0
6. LARS NOOTBAAR 1.9
7. Marcus Semien 1.8
8. Kyle Tucker 1.8
9. Austin Riley 1.8
10. CHAS MCCORMICK 1.8
11. Ronald Acuna 1.8 pic.twitter.com/3PPhdsMbYI
Ag_07 said:
I don't buy for one second that Javier is confident.
I thought to myself last night that his body language and facial expressions scream lack of confidence.
He looks tentative and unsure.
Faustus said:Lars just missed his name being an anagram for Tootblan by one "T".EastCoastAgNc said:MLB’s second-half fWAR leaders:
— MLB Deadline News (@MLBDeadlineNews) August 16, 2023
1. Matt Olson 2.2
2. Freddie Freeman 2.1
3. HA-SEONG KIM 2.1
4. BOBBY WITT JR 2.1
5. Cody Bellinger 2.0
6. LARS NOOTBAAR 1.9
7. Marcus Semien 1.8
8. Kyle Tucker 1.8
9. Austin Riley 1.8
10. CHAS MCCORMICK 1.8
11. Ronald Acuna 1.8 pic.twitter.com/3PPhdsMbYI
Lars Nootbaar[t] = Raars Tootblan
JohnnyTexAg1995 said:
I think it means the line has flipped which could mean no Altuve
Hector Perez was part of the Astros' trade package used to acquire Roberto Osuna in 2018. https://t.co/nVl99pa16H
— Chandler Rome (@Chandler_Rome) August 16, 2023
It did. Miami is now the favorite today.mAgnoliAg said:JohnnyTexAg1995 said:
I think it means the line has flipped which could mean no Altuve
Didn't shift favorite. Astros still favorite. It literally barely moved. Just normal movement based on incoming bets
Just prepare yourself, no Altuve, no Chas or Diaz (actually I bet Diaz DH's) but it will be similar to the Yankee game...minus the Altuve homer. Hope Verlander has another no no in him.Wabs said:
Surely Chas and Yanier can't both be in the lineup after going yard yesterday.
Prosperdick said:Just prepare yourself, no Altuve, no Chas or Diaz (actually I bet Diaz DH's) but it will be similar to the Yankee game...minus the Altuve homer. Hope Verlander has another no no in him.Wabs said:
Surely Chas and Yanier can't both be in the lineup after going yard yesterday.