I appreciate the pics. The flexing of the bat at impact as it absorbs the force of the ball is more understandable, but I had not ever seen/noticed the degree of forward flex the bat achieves following impact. It never caught my eye. It is impressive a MLB bats do not break more often!jkag89 said:
This is set. Stick it on your ‘frigerator door. pic.twitter.com/7DiQHNqFNH
— Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) October 5, 2022
I guarantee his bat has a small hollow section where the wires run for the buzzer that Manfred uses to let him know that he is getting a good pitch to swing for the fences.Just an Ag said:
Holy Bat Flex: there could be many good reasons and this may be perfectly normal. But I've never seen a wooden bat show this flex in this way in stills or slo-mo. Maybe it happens every time and I've just never noticed or paid attention....
jkag89 said:
Teddy Perkins said:
So who got the easier path, Yanks or Stros?
i mean, i'll write it down, but i'd rather use it as a bookmark or put it in a picture frameEastCoastAgNc said:This is set. Stick it on your ‘frigerator door. pic.twitter.com/7DiQHNqFNH
— Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) October 5, 2022
I've been digging through pictures trying to find a similar post impact bat flex and haven't found one. The other pictures posted on here are at impact (not post impact) and ball off the end of the bat, which should create more flex relative to squaring one up (as Judge presumably did here).Just an Ag said:
Holy Bat Flex: there could be many good reasons and this may be perfectly normal. But I've never seen a wooden bat show this flex in this way in stills or slo-mo. Maybe it happens every time and I've just never noticed or paid attention....
Too late!Ag_07 said:
The magic he found was a contract year and possibly some juiced balls thanks to MLB once 62 was in reach.
I wouldn't fret over it too much.
I think we see the Rays in the ALCSEastCoastAgNc said:Teddy Perkins said:
So who got the easier path, Yanks or Stros?
Yankees. Guardians played a schedule softer than Charmin.
Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
Interesting how a normal wooden bat recoils after squaring one upCFTXAG10 said:
Please get your fact-based logic out of here. We're not interested in it!jkag89 said:Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
On Thursday, Oct. 6 from 8 AM to 2 PM outside Union Station at Minute Maid Park, the Astros Foundation will be collecting cases of water, nonperishable food items, toiletries and diapers. Fans can also donate at https://t.co/I5rFcuAmy0! pic.twitter.com/HVym3tYGZP
— Houston Astros (@astros) October 5, 2022
Tired argument. Brady Anderson hit 50 in 1996 and never hit more than 24 otherwise. Luis Gonzalez hit 57 in 2001 and never hit more than 31 otherwise. Were they cheating?jkag89 said:Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
Yes sir.The Porkchop Express said:Please get your fact-based logic out of here. We're not interested in it!jkag89 said:Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
Fan StuffBregxit said:And probably pinch hit him to make sure he drops to .299.EastCoastAgNc said:Dusty Baker said he’ll sit Jose Altuve and his .300 average in tomorrow’s finale.
— Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) October 5, 2022
Based on historical precedent and common sense, I assume anyone who does something like this is cheating, so I'm with you there...but calling 52 HR and a 1.049 OPS over 155 games his rookie season a "hot stretch"?Deluxe said:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
Yes. Yes he was.Deluxe said:Tired argument. Brady Anderson hit 50 in 1996 and never hit more than 24 otherwise. Luis Gonzalez hit 57 in 2001 and never hit more than 31 otherwise. Were they cheating?jkag89 said:Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
You're right that statistical anomalies don't definitively prove funny business. I'm not saying Judge's anomaly season definitively proves funny business. But it's perfectly reasonable to be suspicious.
The hot stretch I'm referring to is 1.139 OPS and 30 HR in the first half of 2017. The second half was much more in line with his career numbers (.939 / 22 HR... with quite a bit of that damage done late in Sept against teams that were out of contention).Harry Dunne said:Based on historical precedent and common sense, I assume anyone who does something like this is cheating, so I'm with you there...but calling 52 HR and a 1.049 OPS over 155 games his rookie season a "hot stretch"?Deluxe said:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
He also hasn't had a full healthy season since his rookie year, and he has averaged nearly 50 HR per 162 games, so it's not that much of a stretch to think that having a career year over a full season would result in 62.
Agreed! That's my point.Buck Compton said:Yes. Yes he was.Deluxe said:Tired argument. Brady Anderson hit 50 in 1996 and never hit more than 24 otherwise. Luis Gonzalez hit 57 in 2001 and never hit more than 31 otherwise. Were they cheating?jkag89 said:Roger Maris hit 39 HRs the year before he hit 61 and 33 the season after. He never had another season in which he hit 30+ home runs.Quote:
But the main reason I'm suspicious is because he's just not this good. Nothing about his track record shows that he's capable of this (other than a hot stretch as a rookie in 2017... when the Yankees were literally caught cheating). He's good, but he's not this good.
You're right that statistical anomalies don't definitively prove funny business. I'm not saying Judge's anomaly season definitively proves funny business. But it's perfectly reasonable to be suspicious.
Harry Dunne said:
Yes of course he was juiced to the gills. Were our stars cheating in that era? 100%
That's the thing about pointing fingers at Judge. We know most of the successful franchises were doing some form of the sign-stealing and it sucked being the scapegoat, but flip that around and whatever Judge is doing (whether that's juicing, or magic bat or whatever), I'm sure that we (and the Dodgers and Braves and so on) are attempting to do the same.
Dodgers have a really tough path. Potentially back-to-back series with teams with 100+ wins.EastCoastAgNc said:This is set. Stick it on your ‘frigerator door. pic.twitter.com/7DiQHNqFNH
— Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) October 5, 2022