Marvin said:
Crap, no way Correa takes 50 cents on the dollar.
I won't beat a dead horse about my feelings on injury concerns with a long-term contract with Carlos, BUT if we're going to gamble anyway by signing him...
If all Carlos wants is a longer contract, I wouldn't have any more of a problem with that than I do with the 6-year offer. $25M per year (assuming that's what he ends up getting) is going to be a lot less 10 years from now than it is today. In 2011 Peak JV winning 24 games, pitching 250 innings and winning a CYA was on the 2nd year of a 5/$80.
No offense to Lance, but I don't think the expectations for his 5/$85 are the same for that salary in 2021 than they were with JV and those $25M aren't going to handicap the organization 9-10 years from now. Carlos is not going to forget how to hit. Best case scenario he ages well and is still a viable 3b or OF at that point. Worst-case he's worth it on the front end (and I do think his typical 110 games per year + postseason is still worth that) and then we have to eat some salary on the back end.