I don't view hamels as an ace based on his tenure with us.DallasAg 94 said:Hamels is a #2?Grapesoda2525 said:This has been the thing eating me up all season. We've looked for that elusive ace for over 20 years. Roger Clemens spurned us several times, Randy Johnson turned us down, Zach Greinke picked another team over us. We had a real ace for 1/2 a season, then cliff lee left us for the national league.Ranger #007 said:gigem1223 said:
Yea. I was in the sellers boat (along with most) going into this season. This team has shocked the **** out of me and now I'm just enjoying the ride and hoping JD can find some controllable help..
Think that's a lot of us. II was hoping Minor would be good enough to grab some prospects and had the same thoughts when Pence came out hot. Now I'd like them to hold on to both.
WE FINALLY HAVE AN ACE. He is old yes, but he doesn't have a ton of mileage on his arm and he's the kind of pitcher whose stuff ages well. He loves it here. He loves this team. We should extend minor........not trade him. We already traded 2 #2 quality pitchers in hamels and Darvish for prospects. The Darvish trade has appeared to work out, while the hamels trade was a disaster. Let the guys we have in the minor leagues develop. I just don't think some team is going to give us adequate compensation for minor, the guy is just too good right now.
Ummm... he has finished 5th, 6th twice and 8th in Cy Young voting. He is currently 4th in NL ERA, at 2.92.
Career 3.38 ERA in 410 GS over 14 seasons... averaging 8.5 SO/9IP
8 Seasons with over 200 IP. Hamels is 35. And has 16 GS in the post-season.
Now, let's contrast that to Mike Minor, who has yet to receive a single Cy Young vote. Career 3.80 ERA, with one season over 200 IP. 155 GS. He is 31. And 6.1 IP in Post season.
LOVE what Minor is doing this season, but let's tap the breaks on anointing him anything, just yet.