Gap said:
Just an Ag said:
Gap said:
Hinch panicked.
Given we have no reliable 4th starter, throwing JV tonight was absolutely the right move! Don't forget we still have Cole in Game 5 . NO PROBLEMS ROLLING OUT JV TONIGHT. NONE!!
It is a Urquidy vs Miley decision.
I think almost all would go with Urquidy. His September was:
1.50 ERA
18 IP
10 H
3 BB
16 K
Pretty damn good.
Definitely Urq. over Miley. Miley seems to be toast for the duration. But Verlander on short rest could pay big dividends, and how much of a delta is there between Urq. on full rest versus JV on short rest (answer: not much). Also, tonight you have JV+Urq, so
assuming JV gives you a decent start and Urq. gives you a few innings in the middle, you still have a strong outing in Game 4 with Urq. being a big part of it. Go with JV+Urq. knowing you have Cole for Game 5.
Maybe you could have run out Urq in Game 4, hoping for something good to happen, then save JV to start Game 5 with Cole in relief to finish, but Cole starting G5 with normal bullpen action would seem equally fine. Again, I have no reservations with JV starting.
It's a good thought exercise.