MelvinUdall said:
AggiEE said:
Has Tucker botched anything up in RF?
Y'all act like he's this huge defensive risk...I don't see it
No, however I think most if not all would consider Reddick as superior defender compared to Tucker and if in a playoff series, he has the ability to save a run.
Tucker was a MiLB CF! He loafed on a few balls last year but I'm not sure where everyone gets the idea that he's a limited fielder.
Reddick is a good & clutch fielder but his range is definitely in decline. No one likes to hear this because they want to base it all on his Spiderman catches, but when you factor in the most important aspect of being an outfielder, which is range, Tucker is far superior at this point in his career.