Farmer1906 said:
Pahdz said:
Unpopular opinion here, but I'd put Adam Everett in at 20...only because the comments Roy Oswalt constantly made about his defense. His brilliance with the glove was overlooked in an era before advanced metrics really became a thing.
His glove wasn't overlooked. He made it and stuck around because of it. He's far from the top 20. Maybe top 50. Probably not.
Maybe the best fielding Astro SS ever, but I'm going with not definitely not top 50 - somewhere between 50-100.
SS is probably the 2nd weakest position in team history ahead of only C, but he's still far behind Correa & Thon and if he's ahead of Menke, Lugo & Tejada its only because of longevity. I'm probably forgetting some other old-school guys.
I also think if the front office hadn't jumped to conclusions and let the Lugo thing play out until he was vindicated, our playoff results might have looked a little different in the mid and late 2000s while Everett struggled to hit .200 in the postseason & hit .067 in the '05 WS & Lugo was the starting shortstop and hit .385 in the WS for the world champ 2007 Red Sox.