"Only 6% of detained undoc immigrants convicted of homicide"

6,386 Views | 79 Replies | Last: 7 mo ago by lexofer
Ayto Siks
How long do you want to ignore this user?
David_Puddy said:

Dear liberal idiots,

YOU'RE COMMITTING A CRIME WHEN YOU ENTER THIS COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

Sincerely,
Non radical American citizens


See the George O quotes from yesterday's post: "There is no swifter route to the corruption of thought than through the corruption of language"

This is why the verbiage was changed from illegal alien to undocumented worker to migrant/refugee to asylum seeker.
Ellis Wyatt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Gaslighting.
MagnumLoad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
redcrayon said:

"The new data obtained by NBC News shows that from Oct. 1 to May 31, ICE arrested 752 people convicted of homicide and 1,693 people convicted of sexual assault, meaning that at the absolute most, the Trump administration has detained only 6% of the undocumented immigrants known to ICE to have been convicted of homicide and 11% of those known to ICE to have been convicted of sexual assault."

Yamiche is dumb.
No, he is an enemy of our Republic. Deep port him.
I hate tu. It's in my blood.
nomad2007
How long do you want to ignore this user?
They didn't say 6% are murderers.

They've arrested 752 that have homicide convictions. That's not 6% of arrests; it's 6% of the amount of supposed murderers that ICE claims are here. It's not good to have ANY, but that's vastly different than what the OP claimed.
aezmvp
How long do you want to ignore this user?
David_Puddy said:

Dear liberal idiots,

YOU'RE COMMITTING A CRIME WHEN YOU ENTER THIS COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

Sincerely,
Non radical American citizens
One of my favorite things to do when I'm bored now is find some liberal about deportations that comes through my X feed and quote back their "No one is above the law" tweets. It's fantastic value.
CDUB98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
David_Puddy said:

Dear liberal idiots,

YOU'RE COMMITTING A CRIME WHEN YOU ENTER THIS COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

Sincerely,
Non radical American citizens
Gandalf the Maroon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm really surprised the media hasn't tried to connect ICE to Hitlers Gestapo more. They really seem to be pushing the ICE as a secret police narrative recently. I feel like that would be their next step, but maybe they're realizing nobody thinks Trump is Hitler? Or maybe they have been saying that and I didn't notice. I don't watch any MSM besides Fox.
"I am going fishing" - John 21:3
zag213004
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ayto Siks said:

David_Puddy said:

Dear liberal idiots,

YOU'RE COMMITTING A CRIME WHEN YOU ENTER THIS COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

Sincerely,
Non radical American citizens


See the George O quotes from yesterday's post: "There is no swifter route to the corruption of thought than through the corruption of language"

This is why the verbiage was changed from illegal alien to undocumented worker to migrant/refugee to asylum seeker to farmer or hotel worker.
DVM97
How long do you want to ignore this user?
While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.

TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Emotional Support Cobra said:

The Marksman said:

Doesn't matter if they've committed homicide. They've entered our country illegally. That's a crime. They have to go back.


But, but, they are asylees!!!1!

That'd be documented, no?
CDUB98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do at a salary she is willing to pay.
FIFY
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.




So they aren't paying market value for labor, eh?
CDUB98
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.
No, they are not all terrible and many of them work hard and just want to be left alone.

I am 100% in favor of a guest worker type program where we can provide these folks a way to do a lot of this hard labor so long as we can 100% verify their identity, their lack of criminal history, and their vaccination status BEFORE they ever cross the border.

We would need more resources at the gov't level to do this, but it is a viable, workable solution.......but nobody wants that.
TacosaurusRex
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


That is weird, because when I cant hire employees you know what I have to do? I have to offer more money. This whole no one will work in the sun is bull. Outside of the corporate leeches our entire company is manual labor in the sun, 50 hours or more a week. It is just more expensive.
"If you are reading this, I have passed on from this world — not as big a deal for you as it was for me."
T. Boone Pickens
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.
I've never met anyone who believes that "all illegals are terrible people." Even the most ardent anti-immigration folks recognize that many are here for opportunity.

But overall, illegal immigrants are an economic and social negative and while they may drive down the cost of lawn care or sod loading by working for low wages, they drive up costs elsewhere -- rent, schools, health care, etc. -- and suppress economic opportunities for citizens.
Highway6
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ayto Siks said:

David_Puddy said:

Dear liberal idiots,

YOU'RE COMMITTING A CRIME WHEN YOU ENTER THIS COUNTRY ILLEGALLY.

Sincerely,
Non radical American citizens


See the George O quotes from yesterday's post: "There is no swifter route to the corruption of thought than through the corruption of language"

This is why the verbiage was changed from illegal alien to undocumented worker to migrant/refugee to asylum seeker.
This. Once language becomes meaningless, society is broken. The left has been trying to do this for decades
FrioAg 00
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Damn, 1 in 20 of the illegals being round up to send back has murdered someone and Libs think that's a low number.

Tells you a lot about what's wrong with them
El Gallo Blanco
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Increasingly me when people start talking about the modern left:

akm91
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ragoo said:

Reading is hard.

6% of the KNOWN

752/0.06 =12,533

Or

12533 * 0.06 =752

So the admin has arrested a bunch of illegals but their focus hasn't been on the worst of the worst as what was communicated during the campaign. The media is trying to say that trump is a liar but I say who cares.
You're missing the point that most of the ones that have been captured by ICE have criminal records IN THEIR HOME COUNTRY!!!! WGAF if they haven't been accused or been convicted of a crime here in the US yet.
EclipseAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


One other point ... the idea that illegal workers are a victimless crime is false. Many of them pass E-Verify using stolen identities, which causes real hardship for those citizens. That's how ICE busted the Glen Valley plant in Nebraska.

For example:

Other casualties of the Omaha identity fraud ring include a Californian who has been working for nearly 15 years to restore their identity and repair financial damage caused by the identity theft of one of the illegal immigrants; A disabled person in Texas, who was unable to work, and could not collect Social Security disability payments because an illegal alien was fraudulently using their identity and earning wages at Glenn Valley Foods; A Colorado resident ordered by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to repay over $5,000 after their income was falsely increased by the illegal immigrant's identity theft; A full-time nursing student from Missouri who lost their college tuition assistance because it was fraudulently reported that they earned too much money after an illegal alien used their Social Security number for employment at Glenn Valley Foods.

Source: https://www.judicialwatch.org/stolen-ids-screened-e-verify/
Science Denier
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


Tell her to pay more and she can get all the workers she needs.

It's not that people won't do the work. They won't do it for the same price as an illegal.
CheeseSndwch
How long do you want to ignore this user?
River Oaks has been around for over 100 years, and I bet if we went back far enough we could probably find a business owner that was trying to do things the right/legal way that saw their landscaping business/prices get undercut by competitors that were willing to employ illegal aliens, so it's hard for me to have sympathy for any business owner whose model/livelihood is dependent upon breaking the law/screwing over their fellow countrymen.
torrid
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We can all have a good laugh about the statistics and the poor wording, but clearly the reporter expected 100% of the initial deportation efforts to focus on muderers/violent criminals. That at least acknowledges there are illegals who are murderers and violent criminals.
American Hardwood
How long do you want to ignore this user?
In summary:

  • Nobody is saying all illegals are evil
  • 100% of illegals are in fact, criminals
  • All illegals should be deported
  • If you are one of the good productive illegals, go home and come back the right way
  • If you are not one of the good ones, do not be allowed to come back ever.
It really is not that complicated.
The best way to keep evil men from wielding great power is to not create great power in the first place.
American Hardwood
How long do you want to ignore this user?
unmade bed said:

The OP is about the tweet-er misinterpreting the statistic but most of the responses to this thread are running with the misinterpretation.

The statistic is that only 6% of the illegals that ICE told congress last fall it knows of that are in the country and convicted of murder have been deported.

So last fall, ICE said there were 13,099 illegals in the country that had been convicted of murder. Thus far, ICE has only deported 752 of them (or 6%).
But somehow the true content of the tweet doesn't sound any better than the false information in the tweet.

Deport them all.
The best way to keep evil men from wielding great power is to not create great power in the first place.
AggieMD95
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Not exactly a random cross section of humanity

6% is actually a huge portion
Science Denier
How long do you want to ignore this user?
torrid said:

We can all have a good laugh about the statistics and the poor wording, but clearly the reporter expected 100% of the initial deportation efforts to focus on muderers/violent criminals. That at least acknowledges there are illegals who are murderers and violent criminals.


They are going after those. They also deport illegals that are with them. And note that even they say OVER HALF have been convicted or charged with a crime.
13B
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


Do you see the irony here? She's losing $600 K but can't afford the time or effort to do it right?
one safe place
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


Looks like you have a lot of friends who are going to have to increase what they pay their employees.

They may pay those taxes and they also cost us a lot to be here. The big picture is they are illegal, they broke the law, they do not want to play by the rules. They need to go back and get in line and do it the right way.
agracer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DrEvazanPhD said:

That's a reasonable number of murderers, wouldn't you say?
For Dem run cities it's an improvement.

It's like them saying the budget was lowered because they didn't increase it as much as last time, even though they're still under budget.
American Hardwood
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


Sorry, but emotional plays for sympathy are falling on deaf ears.

However, I do think there is room to make a rule that those that have not broken any other laws and have worked productively in the U.S. for at least 15 years, and have a business with a record of employing that person for at least 3 of the most recent years that is willing to sponsor that person can have an expedited re-entry process. Still gotta go home first.

ETA: Also, they have to work out a payment plan for any back taxes that have not been paid.
The best way to keep evil men from wielding great power is to not create great power in the first place.
agAngeldad
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CDUB98 said:

Quote:

Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.
No, they are not all terrible and many of them work hard and just want to be left alone.

I am 100% in favor of a guest worker type program where we can provide these folks a way to do a lot of this hard labor so long as we can 100% verify their identity, their lack of criminal history, and their vaccination status BEFORE they ever cross the border.

We would need more resources at the gov't level to do this, but it is a viable, workable solution.......but nobody wants that.
The amount of social freebies that illegals get is not sustainable. All hospital care and schools are free, yet illegal immigrants do not contribute to the tax base. You cannot run your house budget on a deficit, yet that is what this country is doing.

I'm all in favor of resetting the bar and accepting a level that has been paying taxes with nothing more than a traffic ticket for 6-8 years on legal visas. However, we are in a losing battle trying to justify this problem while bankrupting our local communitues. No other country allows such behavior or social norms...
dds08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Could you be any more out of touch?

At least be holistic about it.

How many were convicted of homicide? How many were convicted of stealing, of trafficking, larceny, violent crime, etc?

That's equivalent to saying, "Oh I dunno, 6 percent of felines are lions."

These people don't have a brain.
Fireman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
DVM97 said:

While I understand the concept of "illegal immigrants" breaking the law by just being here, we really need to look at things from a big picture.

I have a very good friend (Trump voter/supporter), she runs/owns a very high end landscaping business in the River Oaks, Memorial area of Houston. She normally has 3 FT crews, each generally working on $100k landscaping projects. She is down to 2 crews, she cannot find workers because they are scared to work. She is literally losing over $600k in annual revenue because no one else will work in the Summer heat planting and cleaning flower beds. She is upset because her crews are not criminals, thugs, rapists, they are hard workers who do the work that NO ONE else will do. She is upset with the administration because it was her understanding that only the "worst of the worst" were going to be targeted. Not her work crews.

A good friend in construction can't find framers, hence slowing down his home building business.
Another friend has a grass farm, he sells over $3 million in sod to the Houston market. He can't find help to keep up with demand and has trucks and trailers sitting waiting for grass pallets to be loaded and shipped. No one wants to work in the sun loading sod onto trailers.

I have looked into the H2-B visa for an individual that is currently here "illegally" the process for the employer is tedious. The requirements on the business owner to get H2-B visa workers is cumbersome, with very stringent requirements that small businesses likely can't afford.

I'd just like folks to look at things big picture wise. Not all "illegals" are terrible people. They pay sales tax, gasoline taxes, rents, etc. and do help the economy by keeping small businesses going.


Sounds like your friends need some help with payroll taxes as well.....
schmellba99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I've always liked the M&M (or Skittles) analogy when people try to justify their viewpoint by saying "well, only X% are really bad, so why are you upset?"

I bet if I put 100 M&M's in a bowl and 6 of them were laced with a poison that caused death, 11% of them were laced with a drug that would give you Montezuma's revenge at completely random intervals that cannot be predicted for the next 5 years and however many of them left to make up the balance to get to whatever the over 50% number is were candy covered rat turds that only look like M&M's and told the person trying to justify it to pick out which one they want and then they have to eat it.

Remember though - slightly less than half of them are perfectly good M&M's! So what's the problem here?

We all know what the outcome would be - they would tell me that entire bowl is horrible and no way in hell they would take their chances.
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.