Prosecution closing argument Bill Wirskye
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
On Karmelo’s touch me comment
“Do not let them turn threat into a warning”
“You heard the testimony, you know it was a threat it wasn’t a warning”
On defense testimony that austin could have stabbed himself
“That’s ludicrous”
“What…
Quote:
Prosecution closing argument Bill Wirskye
On Karmelo's touch me comment
"Do not let them turn threat into a warning"
"You heard the testimony, you know it was a threat it wasn't a warning"
On defense testimony that austin could have stabbed himself
"That's ludicrous"
"What should be important is mindset, he took a knife to a track meet"
"He was going to come out on top of any hostile encounter"
"That's mindset"
"This is one of those rare cases where every important fact can be boiled down to one sentence, you do not get to meet a shove with a stab, especially if you provoke the shove"
"It's crystal clear, the facts are simple, you don't get to meet a shove with a stab, especially if you provoke the shove"
"They said he was confused because the twins were coming at him, again trying to turn the threat into a warning"
"There was no fuse on this thing, they went from zero to a hundred like that"
"Thank goodness we have the video, the video tells the story"
"Why didn't he just not walk away?"
"You see had a choice to walk away and abandon the encounter"
Quote:
Remember, Karmelo does not have to prove he was justified in believing deadly force was needed to protect himself from Austin. He just has to convince the jury that there is reasonable doubt as to whether the State proved Karmelo was not justified.
MsDoubleD81 said:
How are all the people posting on X if no cameras/phones?
aggiehawg said:Closing arguments are 35 minutes each.
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye waived right to open so lead defense attorney Mike Howard is starting
“Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent”
“He had no legal right to put his hands on…Quote:
"Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent"
"He had no legal right to put his hands on Karmelo…Karmelo is in a public place"
"We ask you this incredibly tough task which is to follow the law"
"The government wants to make this case about Melo could have just left"
"You heard that a track event is a social event, it was completely common for kids to be milling about and go by and say hi, stop into the tent"
"We know that it was raining, i don't know why we had to have this argument about whether it was raining"
"We know how Texas weather is, so it's easy to think, boy i better get out of this rain"
He says a witness testified "we had no problem with him under the tent while it was raining"
"You have to put yourself in his (Karmelo's) shoes, so you start under that tent, you want to get out of the rain"
"Sure enough one of the people at Memorial says, yea, come on over"
"Then all of the sudden Hunter Metcalf, or Austin say who are you? You need to leave?"
"These guys are much bigger than you, do you turn your back and walk away and take a chance that these teenage boys with their raging hormones"
"Austin and Hunter had the right to tell Melo to leave but they did have the right to use deadly force to make him leave"
"Melo had an absolute right to defend himself against that"
"How do you know in a split second of chaos when it's too late"
"Because if you wait too late to defend yourself self defense is meaningless"
Tony Franklins Other Shoe said:
I must have missed reading anywhere that Austin said if he didn't leave he was going to beat KA's ass. Was that from one of the couple of defense witnesses?
aggiehawg said:Quote:
Remember, Karmelo does not have to prove he was justified in believing deadly force was needed to protect himself from Austin. He just has to convince the jury that there is reasonable doubt as to whether the State proved Karmelo was not justified.
Going to quibble with your phrasing a bit. The jury will be tasked with deciding if Anthony was reasonable in a belief that deadly force against him was imminent and that Metcalf presented such a threat of death or serious bodily harm. Right or wrong, was that a reasonable conclusion on Anthony's part?
aggiehawg said:Closing arguments are 35 minutes each.
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye waived right to open so lead defense attorney Mike Howard is starting
“Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent”
“He had no legal right to put his hands on…Quote:
"Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent"
"He had no legal right to put his hands on Karmelo…Karmelo is in a public place"
"We ask you this incredibly tough task which is to follow the law"
"The government wants to make this case about Melo could have just left"
"You heard that a track event is a social event, it was completely common for kids to be milling about and go by and say hi, stop into the tent"
"We know that it was raining, i don't know why we had to have this argument about whether it was raining"
"We know how Texas weather is, so it's easy to think, boy i better get out of this rain"
He says a witness testified "we had no problem with him under the tent while it was raining"
"You have to put yourself in his (Karmelo's) shoes, so you start under that tent, you want to get out of the rain"
"Sure enough one of the people at Memorial says, yea, come on over"
"Then all of the sudden Hunter Metcalf, or Austin say who are you? You need to leave?"
"These guys are much bigger than you, do you turn your back and walk away and take a chance that these teenage boys with their raging hormones"
"Austin and Hunter had the right to tell Melo to leave but they did have the right to use deadly force to make him leave"
"Melo had an absolute right to defend himself against that"
"How do you know in a split second of chaos when it's too late"
"Because if you wait too late to defend yourself self defense is meaningless"
aggiehawg said:Tony Franklins Other Shoe said:
I must have missed reading anywhere that Austin said if he didn't leave he was going to beat KA's ass. Was that from one of the couple of defense witnesses?
Only thing I saw reported was the opposite that Austin said something to the effect that he wasn't going to get into a fight at a track meet.
A Net Full of Jello said:
With closing arguments presented, what are your predictions?
Verdict: guilty of murder
Sentence: no more than 20 years
More prosecution closing
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
On whether manslaughter would apply in this case instead of murder
“If you think AM impaled himself on Karmelo Anthony’s knife, find him guilty of manslaughter”
On witnesses
“They all said Karmelo Anthony provoked it”
Why self defense doesn’t apply…
Quote:
More prosecution closing
On whether manslaughter would apply in this case instead of murder
"If you think AM impaled himself on Karmelo Anthony's knife, find him guilty of manslaughter"
On witnesses
"They all said Karmelo Anthony provoked it"
Why self defense doesn't apply
"You can meet deadly force with deadly force in Texas, but you can't meet force, a shove, with deadly force, a stab"
"Size differential, it doesn't work in this case, you don't get to kill someone just because they are bigger than you"
"Self defense has to be a reasonable belief, a reasonable belief means a belief that would held by an ordinary and prudent person in the same situation as the defendant"
"It has to be immediately necessary, where was the immediate necessity to plunge a knife into an unarmed, young man"
"It's not self defense folks, it's murder, murder, plain and simple"
"No one's standing up, no one's surrounding Karmelo Anthony"
"The Memorial kids hadn't turned on him, the video was so, so important, you can see with your own eyes, how normal that day was"
"At some point when he reached into the bag he opened it and had it ready to go"
"Did Austin Metcalf have defensive wounds, no. He never saw it coming"
"If this case was really about a young man trying to stay out of the rain, get under the bleachers"
On why he ran for an exit instead of a coach
"It's a guilty, guilty mindset"
"He touched me, he did this, he did that…what would he have said if he was really confronted by both of the twins, his words alone belie the fact that this was one on one, this was not a mob of Memorial kids"
Reciting a witness who testified about Karmelo's behavior
"He had it in his mind what he was going to do"
MsDoubleD81 said:
Wonder who is paying for all the Karmelo Anthony signs?
https://www.youtube.com/live/SWjeJwf_JGc?si=UwLdRvrfZDYUJSF2
MsDoubleD81 said:
Thinking.....what would have happened if he had just pulled the knife out and just showed it to everyone? Everyone scattered.
fc2112 said:“You didn’t hear the words motive in the jury charge, but you can make reasonable deductions as to how that applies to intent”
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
“Karmelo has no motive other than he absolutely felt like he was in danger”
“The evidence is very clear these kids didn’t know each other”
“This case…Quote:
On the "touch me and find out comment from Karmelo
"That is the ultimate warning it is the ultimate backoff"
Quote:
More prosecution closing
"I'm not going to fight you, Austin says multiple times,"
On the one witness who knew about Austin and Karmelo
"It wasn't a hard push it was a small shove"
"Karmelo Anthony was trying to prove that he could do a violent act, well he sure did folks, he sure did"
"All told you the exact same thing, it's not self defense, Austin didn't want to fight"
"It's a tragedy for everyone involved, and there's a lot of truth in that outside this courtroom."
"It's not a tragedy for Karmelo Anthony, it's a tragedy because of the decisions he made"
"It is senseless that AM lost his life on a Wednesday morning at a high school track meet"
"We don't take weapons to school events, but he did"
"Ultimately this case is about accountability, what kind of community do you want to live in?"
"You represent the community today, as unpleasant as it may be it's your duty to follow your oath and hold this young man accountable for this senseless, senseless murder."
"I beg you to make justice swift in this case."
Closing arguments over, judge is giving instructions to alternate jurors
at least they get to cry in their cadillac escalade courtesy of tribalistic morons that donate to defend a murderer 🤣🤣🤣 pic.twitter.com/hZ4MykzQQb
— Yisan (@00yisan) June 9, 2026
Quote:
"These guys are much bigger than you, do you turn your back and walk away and take a chance that these teenage boys with their raging hormones"
deddog said:MsDoubleD81 said:
Wonder who is paying for all the Karmelo Anthony signs?
https://www.youtube.com/live/SWjeJwf_JGc?si=UwLdRvrfZDYUJSF2
Same folks who pay for the trucks to bring in bricks at BLM "peaceful protests"
Backyard Gator said:aggiehawg said:Closing arguments are 35 minutes each.
— J.D. Miles (@jdmiles11) June 9, 2026
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye waived right to open so lead defense attorney Mike Howard is starting
“Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent”
“He had no legal right to put his hands on…Quote:
"Austin Metcalf had no legal right to use force to eject Karmelo Anthony from that tent"
"He had no legal right to put his hands on Karmelo…Karmelo is in a public place"
"We ask you this incredibly tough task which is to follow the law"
"The government wants to make this case about Melo could have just left"
"You heard that a track event is a social event, it was completely common for kids to be milling about and go by and say hi, stop into the tent"
"We know that it was raining, i don't know why we had to have this argument about whether it was raining"
"We know how Texas weather is, so it's easy to think, boy i better get out of this rain"
He says a witness testified "we had no problem with him under the tent while it was raining"
"You have to put yourself in his (Karmelo's) shoes, so you start under that tent, you want to get out of the rain"
"Sure enough one of the people at Memorial says, yea, come on over"
"Then all of the sudden Hunter Metcalf, or Austin say who are you? You need to leave?"
"These guys are much bigger than you, do you turn your back and walk away and take a chance that these teenage boys with their raging hormones"
"Austin and Hunter had the right to tell Melo to leave but they did have the right to use deadly force to make him leave"
"Melo had an absolute right to defend himself against that"
"How do you know in a split second of chaos when it's too late"
"Because if you wait too late to defend yourself self defense is meaningless"
Now they're claiming Austin's shove of Anthony constitutes "deadly force". They think the jury is stupid.
nah. The jury will at least stay through lunch to get a free meal.fc2112 said:
Verdict before lunch?
Cage_Stage said:
11 a.m.
Closing arguments ended.
10:30 a.m.
Prosecutor Bill Wirskye next delivered his closing arguments.
"Do not let them turn a threat into a warning," he urged jurors. "This is not some benign warning."
"This is ludicrous," Wirskye said. What matters isn't motive; it should be "mindset," he said.
Anthony "had a secret -- he had a knife that day. He was always gonna come out on top that day! That is a mindset."
"You dont get to meet a shove with a stab -- especially if you provoke a shove," Wirskye told jurors.
"This is unjustified, provoked, murder," he said, repeating a phrase he used in opening arguments last week.
"Why didn't he just walk away?" Wirskye asked, noting that no witnesses offered any answers to this question.
"You can meet a shove with a shove," the prosecutor said. "It has to be proportional." The stabbing was not proportional, he said.
"You don't get to kill someone just because they are bigger than you," Wirskye told jurors.
"Any ordinary, prudent, reasonable person would not have plunged a knife into the chest of Austin Metcalf, an unarmed young man," Wirskye said.
Wirskye took the replica knife and flicked it open. "It's still murder at the end of the day," he told jurors.
If Anthony wanted to get out of the rain, there were other tents.
Wirskye referred to Anthony's "secret knife" that he had in his backpack. He reminded jurors that some witness described Metcalf giving Anthony "light pushes," that a witness quoted Metcalf telling Anthony, "I'm not going to fight you, bro."
There are two jurors who are shaking their heads in agreement during Wirskye's closing argument.
"Austin didn't deserve it," he said. "It was murder."
He quoted witnesses who said Anthony said under that tent, "Make me move." "Touch me, see what happens."
Self defense argument negated right here according to Texas law.
Wirskye acknowledged there were discrepancies between some of the young witnesses' accounts. He said they're kids, they are simply mistaken.
"It's not self-defense. It's murder," he told jurors. "It is a tragedy for everyone involved."
"This was plain and simple murder," he said. "We don't take weapons to school events. With his mindset, (Anthony) did."
"What kind of county do you want to live in? What kind of society do you want to live in? Hold this young man accountable. And send a message that this won't be tolerated in our community."
9:45 a.m.
The prosecution waived its right to start off the closing arguments, so defense attorney Mike Howard went first.
Austin Metcalf had "no legal right to eject" Karmelo Anthony from the Memorial High School tent at the track meet on April 2, 2025, he said.
"He had no legal right to put his hands on 'Melo,'" Howard told jurors, referring to Anthony by his nickname. "He was in a public place."
Prosecutors contend Anthony "could have just left" when confronted by Metcalf, Howard said. "I am sure he wishes he did."
Howard referred to earlier testimony that track meets are social and open and that athletes can come and go. He said he disagrees with prosecutors that his client "slipped" into Memorial's tent. Rather, Anthony was invited in -- and "dapped up" -- by "a friend."
Howard told jurors that it was reasonable for Anthony to want to be under the tent when it began raining. Anthony's school had not brought a tent to the event.
"'Melo' was seated throughout this," Howard told jurors. "They had a right to tell him to leave, they didn't have a right to use force to eject him."
Howard said his client could have left but he was facing a group of "teenage boys with raging hormones" getting increasingly madder.
Anthony had the right to defend himself when "someone is so much bigger than you."
Proportionally, yes. That's not what Anthony did though.
Howard told jurors that witnesses gave "jumbled" accounts of various aspects of the incident, including the range of intensity of the shove Metcalf gave Anthony, where people were sitting in the Memorial tent, and whether Anthony ran, walked or jogged after the stabbing.
He said Howard could have left the stadium afterwards, but he decided to walk back onto the field. "Everyone who saw 'Melo' said he was crying," Howard said, saying that his client was remorseful and genuinely distraught.
So the f*** what? That's not an excuse.
Howard recalled the testimony of a coach who told Anthony, "If that young man dies, your life will change." Anthony responded, "He's not going to die." Howard said this speaks to Anthony's intent.
Anthony's intent was to stab someone.
Howard conceded Anthony bringing a multitool folding knife to the school track meet was "a violation of policy."
WGAS about policy? It's what he did with the knife that matters.
"The thing about self defense, you cannot wait until it is too late," Howard said. "The thing about a split second of chaos ... you don't know what's going to happen."
Pretty sure you do when you intentionally escalate a confrontation.
Howard told jurors they "must put yourself in his shoes." He said that it did not make sense for Anthony to pick a fight with someone "so much bigger than him" and a twin "so much bigger than him" and twenty other guys.
Perhaps. If you didn't have a knife in your pack that you intentionally brought with you.
"It's not about race," Howard said. "There's no evidence that 'Melo' did anything but think he was defending himself in that split second of chaos."
"Touch me and see what happens."
"Maybe he mouthed off because you're a 17-year-old dumb kid," Howard said of his client. When Anthony said, "don't touch me and find out... That is the ultimate warning, not provocation."
No, it's escalation.
"I don't think we're going to ever know what happened under that tent," Howard said. "We've got 15 different stories."
All we need to know is that Anthony stabbed an unarmed teenager after provoking a confrontation.
"You don't ask the decedent's friends (witnesses) about self defense and provocation," Howard said. He reminded jurors it's now their job to use the law to find Anthony not guilty.
He was asked to leave and refused. Then he stabbed an unarmed teenager. Texas law does not support a verdict of "not guilty" in this instance.