30 years ago, the FBI killed...[Waco, TX Branch Davidians]

10,459 Views | 144 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by Urban Ag
TxTarpon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You are
schmellba99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TxTarpon said:

fc2112 said:

... 76 men, women and children at the Branch Division compound outside of Waco.
And this child molester ran their cult.

FAFO
PSGWSP

Randy Weaver is a better hero.


Quote:

And no one was punished.
This (censored) enacted some punishment on federal workers in OKC because he thought the govt needed some payback for Waco.


Both Koresh and McVeigh are in hell.
If you choose to make them heroes them....oh well.
Not a single person here has done that, intimated that or even remotely hinted at that.

It is possible - and just bear with me here - to recognize that Koresh was a lunatic and likely somebody that needed to be legally taken out of society AND recognize that the feds took a literal sht on the constitution while staring into the TV cameras with the manner that they handled everything from the surveillance of Koresh up to the raid and through the eventual burning to death of those still in side.

I know...it takes a couple of brain cells rubbing together in your noggin to understand that, but I bet if you try hard you can.
combat wombat™
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You can want retribution for bad acts regardless of who those bad acts were perpetrated against.
2040huck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fc2112 said:

... 76 men, women and children at the Branch Division compound outside of Waco.

And no one was punished.
Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Ellis Wyatt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
fk said:

But the idea that nothing would have happened if not for the raid is simply not accurate.
We'll never know because the feds murdered all of those people.
Ellis Wyatt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Some may have. Most absolutely did not.
2040huck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ellis Wyatt said:

Quote:

Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Some may have. Most absolutely did not.
True. Most were killed by the fire set by the Davidians
TxTarpon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You are correct!!!

schmellba99
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
fka ftc said:

schmellba99 said:

fka ftc said:

Unfortunately I could see a false flag op this week.

Blaming the FBI and ATF on those deaths is not correct, though they contributed to an environment of chaos, stress, pressure, etc knowing they had a powder keg of crazy man / people, anti-gov fanatics, weapons, explosives, etc.

They deserve all of the blame for escalating the situation and setting the circumstances up. But the decision to light those fires remains with Koresh.
The only people that make this claim....are the FBI and ATF.

They are 100% responsible for all of the deaths because they chose to handle what should have been - and could have been - a very simple detainment of Koresh in the absolute worst possible manner and then proceeded to effectively siege the place for nearly 60 days for no other reason than "because we can".

Including getting a freaking M1 Abrams from Ft. Hood and deciding to play demolition derby to a building that they KNEW housed nearly 100 people, many of whom were women and children.

This was absolutely without a doubt 100% the fault of the feds, any argument otherwise is dumb.
When you stockpile fully automatic weapons and grenades along with credible allegations of child abuse does not make David Koresh a martyr.

BTW - Koresh had an absolute death wish and was waiting for a moment to take his flock with him to paradise. He was of such sound mind that he preached on this regularly, and even drilled for a raid.

Yes, ATF, FBI, media, Reno, Clinton all deserve heavy blame. But the idea that nothing would have happened if not for the raid is simply not accurate.
Again - nobody knows if the weapons he had (we know he had weapons) were illegal or not, that was an allegation that was used as a pretense for the feds to play soldier and do a raid. Maybe he did, maybe he didn't....nobody really knows.

Again - not arguing that Koresh was a POS that brainwashed people that were easily swayed. We know this to be true.

And again - had the feds not acted in the absolute dumbest possible manner, the argument that none of this would have happened is every bit as valid (probably moreso) than your assertion that no matter what the Davidians were going to die in a massive fire while everybody watched.

100% on the shoulders of the ATF and FBI from start to finish, there simply is no argument against that fact. Anything other is pure supposition as to what might have happened. Might have.
TxTarpon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
combat wombat said:

You can want retribution for bad acts regardless of who those bad acts were perpetrated against.
To avenge a false prophet pedo who held children as hostages?
Pick a better leader.

What a difference a decade makes.
If in 2003, had a compound inhabited by muslims lead by Mohommed Bin Koresh been raided by the Feds (for the same reasons as Mt Carmel in 1993) in similar aggressive govt fashion, most Americans would have been cheering for the FBI HRT.
Rip*91
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG

You might want to put down the shovel. You are embarrassing yourself.
whatthehey78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
2040huck said:

fc2112 said:

... 76 men, women and children at the Branch Division compound outside of Waco.

And no one was punished.
Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Soooooooooooo wrong! To approach the correct assessment...they were murdered, just to satisfy a number of idiot's egos.
Alexander, Caesar, Charlemagne, and myself founded empires; but upon what foundation did we rest the creations of our genius? Upon force! But Jesus Christ founded His upon love; and at this hour millions of men would die for Him. - Napoleon Bonaparte
2040huck
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whatthehey78 said:

2040huck said:

fc2112 said:

... 76 men, women and children at the Branch Division compound outside of Waco.

And no one was punished.
Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Soooooooooooo wrong! To approach the correct assessment...they were murdered, just to satisfy a number of idiot's egos.
bs, They set the fire. That's not even in dispute. Listen to the audio recoreded at the time. If you deny that, you are not very credible.
TxTarpon
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Rip*91 said:

You might want to put down the shovel. You are embarrassing yourself.
Nah
fka ftc
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ellis Wyatt said:

fk said:

But the idea that nothing would have happened if not for the raid is simply not accurate.
We'll never know because the feds murdered all of those people.
That's sort of and endless argument that could be had but no one knows if nothing would have happened, or if a simple knock by a social worker would have caused him to initiate his apocalypse and take his flock on to their great reward.

That is sort of the problem when dealing with guys like Koresh.

Again, not defending FBI and ATF, but to absolve Koresh is equally asinine (I don't think that is what you are trying to do, but others seem to lean that way).
TxTarpon
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Quote:

Not a single person here has done that, intimated that or even remotely hinted at that.
David Koresh was their leader.
His leadership started the chain of events that lead to the raid.
His leadership kept children in the compound as hostages.
He wanted death by cop and he wanted to take as many with him as he could.
FBI HRT obliged him.
Quote:

I know...it takes a couple of brain cells rubbing together in your noggin to understand that, but I bet if you try hard you can.
Rub your eyes (not like Koresh rubbed those toddlers), shake your brain cells loose and reread my 1:36 post.

Gigem_94
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I still remember standing in the lobby of Blocker watching the compound burn on the TVs they had in there.
AggieVictor10
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The fbi and atf
IIIHorn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TxTarpon said:

Rip*91 said:

You might want to put down the shovel. You are embarrassing yourself.
Nah



Is that a Carvin?



MROD92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IIIHorn said:

TxTarpon said:

Rip*91 said:

You might want to put down the shovel. You are embarrassing yourself.
Nah



Is that a Carvin?





M F Barnes
IIIHorn
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MROD92 said:

IIIHorn said:

TxTarpon said:

Rip*91 said:

You might want to put down the shovel. You are embarrassing yourself.
Nah



Is that a Carvin?





M F Barnes


The hardest working man in oil is a luthier?

combat wombat™
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TxTarpon said:

combat wombat said:

You can want retribution for bad acts regardless of who those bad acts were perpetrated against.
To avenge a false prophet pedo who held children as hostages?
Pick a better leader.

What a difference a decade makes.
If in 2003, had a compound inhabited by muslims lead by Mohommed Bin Koresh been raided by the Feds (for the same reasons as Mt Carmel in 1993) in similar aggressive govt fashion, most Americans would have been cheering for the FBI HRT.


McVeigh was a POS. Koresh was a POS. Opposing government overreach when it happens isn't the same as supporting the Davidians. Mkay? Im going to stop this back and forth because it's evident you can't be reasoned with. It seems that you are an "ends justify the means" kind of guy. Rights be damned.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ellis Wyatt said:

Quote:

Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Some may have. Most absolutely did not.
I understand that the evidence that they started the fire themselves is quite strong. If that is the case, then the ones who should be punished for it died in the very fire they set.
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
whatthehey78 said:

2040huck said:

fc2112 said:

... 76 men, women and children at the Branch Division compound outside of Waco.

And no one was punished.
Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Soooooooooooo wrong! To approach the correct assessment...they were murdered, just to satisfy a number of idiot's egos.
They were murdered by others in their cult. There is no rational way to blame the FBI for that.
Martin Cash
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ellis Wyatt said:

Quote:

Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Some may have. Most absolutely did not.
That's right. Koresh murdered them.

It's incredible that there are educated people who still think the FBi/ATF started the fire. But then, I'm basing that on a presumption.
The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left. Ecclesiastes 10:2
eric76
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
TxTarpon said:


Quote:

Not a single person here has done that, intimated that or even remotely hinted at that.
David Koresh was their leader.
His leadership started the chain of events that lead to the raid.
His leadership kept children in the compound as hostages.
He wanted death by cop and he wanted to take as many with him as he could.
FBI HRT obliged him.
Quote:

I know...it takes a couple of brain cells rubbing together in your noggin to understand that, but I bet if you try hard you can.
Rub your eyes (not like Koresh rubbed those toddlers), shake your brain cells loose and reread my 1:36 post.
And instead of death by cop, didn't he kill himself rather than die in his own fire?

In essence, he killed his cult but committed suicide to avoid the fate that he selected for them.
lb3
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Rapier108 said:

All the feds had to do was wait them out, but Clinton and Reno wanted to score a victory.

Heck, the initial raid was all about setting the narrative about the nation being flooded with illegal guns and we need to rid ourselves of them by outlawing guns completely.
Agree. I believe that the Democrats were preparing to go all in on a much broader weapons ban but after Waco all they could get was a 10 year ban on 'assault' weapons.

In the end, their overreach in Waco and Ruby Ridge convinced millions of Americans that the 2A wasn't just for hunting or self defense, but to protect us from the tyranny of evil men serving in public office. In that regard, those victims are martyrs to a cause they may not have known they were serving.
tiggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MouthBQ98 said:

I agree. The feds set up the circumstances under which a ln apocalyptic cult killed themselves after an unnecessary and horribly botched raid got ATF agents killed.
It's Wakko, I mean Waco. This also led to another cataclysmic situation when 2 men 2 years later on the same day committed an unspeakable act in OKC. There is plenty of blame on both sides.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Slicer97 said:

Could've been avoided by just waiting it out and arresting Koresh sometime when he was away from the compound.

Never trust a 3-letter agency. And the ATF should've been disbanded long ago.
the opposite actually

they were literal idiots and wanted to flex by raiding the compound

when if they had a scintilla of intelligence or empathy for the cultists and kids-

they would have ambushed David Koresh when he drove into town by himself or with a few other folks.

before any raid.
Slyfox07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ts5641 said:

After watching the recent Netflix doc on this, it truly is frightening how the feds operate. Made a terrible decision to raid, got 4 agents killed, uped the ante and ended with multiple men, women, and children dead.
And an FBI SWAT dude took a selfie in front of the burned ruins...
The depth and extent of the rot and corruption that exists up and down the federal law enforcement and intelligence structure is SHOCKING when you start to peel back the onion.
Tumble Weed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Watched a few episodes of the Waco series on Paramount+ last night.

This 1993 version of the FBI feels tame compared to what we are experiencing now.


AggiePetro07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Imagine if Lon Horiuchi had saved the round that found Vicki Weaver's forehead for Koresh as he was strolling into town….

The Clinton/Reno death squad should burn in hell.
rwtxag83
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Martin Cash said:

Ellis Wyatt said:

Quote:

Actually, they committed suicide. But, whatever
Some may have. Most absolutely did not.
That's right. Koresh murdered them.

It's incredible that there are educated people who still think the FBi/ATF started the fire. But then, I'm basing that on a presumption.


It's probably likely that the fire would never been started if the feds had not raided the compound. Starting the fire was a reaction to the raid. The idea that Koresh and his flock were likely to react violently should have been the most important and salient thing to consider.

Before the standoff, Koresh regularly left the compound. It would have been easy to arrest him on multiple occasions off site. The feds screwed up the situation to an exponential degree because they wanted to make a show of it. I blame the feds, Reno, and Clinton.

Blaming the deaths on Koresh because he started the fire completely misses the much bigger issue. Ok, so they have multiple weapons they're not supposed to have. It's a felony. I get it. They had not done anything violent up to that point. A violent raid is going to be a tragedy when you have that many children there. Handle it differently and the outcome is very different.

The feds screwed this up worse than Ruby Ridge.
rwtxag83
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
LMCane said:

Slicer97 said:

Could've been avoided by just waiting it out and arresting Koresh sometime when he was away from the compound.

Never trust a 3-letter agency. And the ATF should've been disbanded long ago.
the opposite actually

they were literal idiots and wanted to flex by raiding the compound

when if they had a scintilla of intelligence or empathy for the cultists and kids-

they would have ambushed David Koresh when he drove into town by himself or with a few other folks.

before any raid.


Exactly. There's more than one way to skin a cat. If you're picking the method to benefit your public image, you're probably making a big mistake. The least violent method with the least potential for harm is almost always the best way.
Urban Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Pretty good summary IMO.

I watched the latest documentary on Netflix, or maybe it was Paramount, and came away from it with a couple of new takes even after all these years of following this complete goat screw of a tragedy.

First, how quickly and easily heavy weapons were moved from Fort Hood to Mt Carmel. Bradleys, Abrams, etc. I find it amazing how quickly the FBI could commandeer front line heavy weapons from the Army to support a purely domestic operation yet we seemingly are completely paralyzed to use similar resources to defend our southern border.

Second, that HRT sniper, who was extensively interviewed in the documentary. It was kind of shocking to me how much he clearly saw himself as a soldier, at best, even a mercenary, in the employ of the US federal govt against it's own citizens. That's not law enforcement. That's war. Those guys were there to kill and they wanted the outcome they received.

Third, prior to and post congressional investigation/testimony, the level of bipartisan condemnation of the BATFE and FBI was compelling. I don't think we will ever see an America like that again. Chuck Schumer was literally ripping the ATF and FBI to shreds, alongside fellow dems and scores of R's. Think about that. Both parties were incensed by the stupidity of the raid that should never have happened.

Anybody that still thinks this country hasn't changed radically in the last three decades really has their head up their ass.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.