Confusing. We've only given Ukraine one Patriot battery out of the Army's 50 batteries (16 battalions). As for the three Israeli systems you mention, IIRC the US doesn't operate any of them or intend to, except for test items and the USMC buying some short-range Iron Dome systems.fullback44 said:
So I did some deep diving into missile Defense systems and found out some interesting information. The info came from todays Sitrep report. So there are mainly 3 levels of missile defense.
Long Range : Arrow 2 and Arrow 3
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_3
Medium Range: David's Sling is the newest and the Patriot Syatem is older but still used by the US army.
Short Range : Iron Dome (developed by the US and Isreal) together
There are other closer range systems that I didn't read about.
Anyway I post this because I was worried/ concerned we were giving up too many of our missile defense systems by giving Ukraine Patriot missile battery's but we have a bunch of other systems we can. Use. The Patriot is still in use and will be used for along time. However these newer systems like Arrow 3 are on another level of long range missile defense. Arrow 3 can take out satellites in space.
Just fascinating stuff.
im going to say it again...
— david D. (@secretsqrl123) August 18, 2023
russia has to block EVERY thrust from the ukraine army...
the ukraine army only needs to get lucky once to break the line. pic.twitter.com/rpeCJmmeYt
74OA said:Confusing. We've only given Ukraine one Patriot battery out of the Army's 50 batteries (16 battalions). As for the Israeli systems you mention, IIRC the US doesn't operate any of them or intend to, except for the USMC buying a handful of short-range Iron Dome systems.fullback44 said:
So I did some deep diving into missile Defense systems and found out some interesting information. The info came from todays Sitrep report. So there are mainly 3 levels of missile defense.
Long Range : Arrow 2 and Arrow 3
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_3
Medium Range: David's Sling is the newest and the Patriot Syatem is older but still used by the US army.
Short Range : Iron Dome (developed by the US and Isreal) together
There are other closer range systems that I didn't read about.
Anyway I post this because I was worried/ concerned we were giving up too many of our missile defense systems by giving Ukraine Patriot missile battery's but we have a bunch of other systems we can. Use. The Patriot is still in use and will be used for along time. However these newer systems like Arrow 3 are on another level of long range missile defense. Arrow 3 can take out satellites in space.
Just fascinating stuff.
To your concern, both the Army, Marines and Navy are currently well into modernizing their air defense systems to include a mix of modern radars, cannons, missiles, lasers and HPM to defeat aircraft, missiles and drones. Patriot is only one component of the Army's air defense mix and in addition to constantly upgrading its missiles over the years, it will also receive a modern GaN radar in the next year or two, essentially making it a whole new system.
PJYoung said:im going to say it again...
— david D. (@secretsqrl123) August 18, 2023
russia has to block EVERY thrust from the ukraine army...
the ukraine army only needs to get lucky once to break the line. pic.twitter.com/rpeCJmmeYt
The Army experimented with Iron Dome during the IFPC competition but ultimately rejected it in favor of the US-made Enduring Shield system by Dynetics. The Army may use its two Iron Dome test systems somewhere while Enduring Shield is being produced, but Iron Dome is not IFPC and there are no plans to buy more for operational use by the Army.LMCane said:74OA said:Confusing. We've only given Ukraine one Patriot battery out of the Army's 50 batteries (16 battalions). As for the Israeli systems you mention, IIRC the US doesn't operate any of them or intend to, except for the USMC buying a handful of short-range Iron Dome systems.fullback44 said:
So I did some deep diving into missile Defense systems and found out some interesting information. The info came from todays Sitrep report. So there are mainly 3 levels of missile defense.
Long Range : Arrow 2 and Arrow 3
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow_3
Medium Range: David's Sling is the newest and the Patriot Syatem is older but still used by the US army.
Short Range : Iron Dome (developed by the US and Isreal) together
There are other closer range systems that I didn't read about.
Anyway I post this because I was worried/ concerned we were giving up too many of our missile defense systems by giving Ukraine Patriot missile battery's but we have a bunch of other systems we can. Use. The Patriot is still in use and will be used for along time. However these newer systems like Arrow 3 are on another level of long range missile defense. Arrow 3 can take out satellites in space.
Just fascinating stuff.
To your concern, both the Army, Marines and Navy are currently well into modernizing their air defense systems to include a mix of modern radars, cannons, missiles, lasers and HPM to defeat aircraft, missiles and drones. Patriot is only one component of the Army's air defense mix and in addition to constantly upgrading its missiles over the years, it will also receive a modern GaN radar in the next year or two, essentially making it a whole new system.
For Air Defense the US Army currently has two batteries operational of IFPIC (which is the Israeli manufactured Iron Dome)
and a third battery will be a Raytheon/Dianetics system based on the AIM9X.
Ocrs would be forced to put their aviation at severe risk.LMCane said:PJYoung said:im going to say it again...
— david D. (@secretsqrl123) August 18, 2023
russia has to block EVERY thrust from the ukraine army...
the ukraine army only needs to get lucky once to break the line. pic.twitter.com/rpeCJmmeYt
Great map.
This may never happen unfortunately...but what WOULD be the results if the Ukes can break through towards Mariupol or Tokmak?!
Look at how many regiments and brigades would be caught to the western side of that penetration and cut off from Russia.
what would the Russian response be? to rely on ONE BRIDGE from Crimea to supply everyone to the west of the containment zone?
or would they retreat back into Kherson and try to bottleneck the Crimean approaches?
PJYoung said:
Putin is just hoping to hold on until the US elections at this point.
74OA said:
USAFE boss says it could take years for Ukrainian pilots to become combat proficient in the F-16.
REALITY
He's talking about young pilots with little experience, because that's what it takes to train a combat-ready flight lead in our Air Force. Mostly, though, I think he's just tempering expectations.docb said:74OA said:
USAFE boss says it could take years for Ukrainian pilots to become combat proficient in the F-16.
REALITY
I have a hard time believing it would take 4-5 years to learn for someone who is already a pilot. I hope they've already had guys training somewhere.
Quote:
Over the last week the Russian Defense Ministry reported on average 770 Ukrainian frontline casualties per day. The Ukrainian counter-offensive will likely culminate next week. It has reached is maximum potential and will now peter out.
🔥BREAKING🔥
— Cloooud |🇺🇦 (@GloOouD) August 19, 2023
⚡️Soltsi military airfield (Tu-22m3 base location), Novgorod region of the Russian Federation — hit by an unknown UAV.
❗️REPORTED ABOUT 2 BURNING AIRCRAFTS pic.twitter.com/vBMvJDNwc5
/1. Targeting of the Russian Murom-P surveillance system which was placed by Russians on the balcony of a residential building. By the 126th brigade of Ukraine. Nova Kakhovka, Kherson Region. https://t.co/xJhEk2w8Ve pic.twitter.com/fAaStIestP
— Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦 (@bayraktar_1love) August 18, 2023
Russian Murom-P surveillance system https://t.co/pGH9avglgM
— MostlyNew (@NewMostly) August 18, 2023
https://liveuamap.com/en/2023/19-august-at-least-5-people-killed-37-wounded-as-result-ofQuote:
At least 5 people killed, 37 wounded as result of Russian missile strike at the Theater building in Chernihiv
Location: east of Urozhaine (Урожайне), Donetsk Oblast at 47.73231, 36.85382 https://t.co/QpRh5ckGe1 @UAControlMap #geoconfirmed @GeoConfirmed
— blinzka (@blinzka) August 19, 2023
A Ukrainian drone of the Wild Hornets unit drops explosives at a remote mining vehicle stuck in a crater. pic.twitter.com/Yx8poUyggn
This is over 600KM from the front and I hope a dozen of those damn bombers melted into the tarmac.PJYoung said:🔥BREAKING🔥
— Cloooud |🇺🇦 (@GloOouD) August 19, 2023
⚡️Soltsi military airfield (Tu-22m3 base location), Novgorod region of the Russian Federation — hit by an unknown UAV.
❗️REPORTED ABOUT 2 BURNING AIRCRAFTS pic.twitter.com/vBMvJDNwc5
Kakhovka reservoir.. turned into a totally different landscape. pic.twitter.com/fVIP2eE7e1
— NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦 (@NOELreports) August 17, 2023
https://liveuamap.com/en/2023/19-august-defense-minister-oleksiy-reznikov-said-that-theQuote:
Defense Minister Oleksiy Reznikov said that the training of Ukrainian F-16 fighter pilots has already begun
PJYoung said:🔥BREAKING🔥
— Cloooud |🇺🇦 (@GloOouD) August 19, 2023
⚡️Soltsi military airfield (Tu-22m3 base location), Novgorod region of the Russian Federation — hit by an unknown UAV.
❗️REPORTED ABOUT 2 BURNING AIRCRAFTS pic.twitter.com/vBMvJDNwc5
JFABNRGR said:This is over 600KM from the front and I hope a dozen of those damn bombers melted into the tarmac.PJYoung said:🔥BREAKING🔥
— Cloooud |🇺🇦 (@GloOouD) August 19, 2023
⚡️Soltsi military airfield (Tu-22m3 base location), Novgorod region of the Russian Federation — hit by an unknown UAV.
❗️REPORTED ABOUT 2 BURNING AIRCRAFTS pic.twitter.com/vBMvJDNwc5
If the Russians admit an aircraft was damaged, it’s likely multiple aircraft were at least damaged, possibly destroyed.
— ELINT News (@ELINTNews) August 19, 2023
This was the case in Saki Airbase last year in Crimea when over half a dozen or so Su-24’s were destroyed and/or damaged https://t.co/eTz3vtK8Cb