BigRobSA said:Womackster said:C@LAg said:it is mostly a self-identifying ethnicity with some geographical component if you want to tr to make it fit, but cannot definitively prove for most.DrEvazanPhD said:
So what is an ethnic Jew?
I'm as tired of the STM schtick as the next guy, but trying to argue that Jew is not an ethnicity is pretty baffling.
I don't think anyone is arguing that. But, to pull out "my grandmother's grandmother was a Jew so I'm a Jew, too" as some form of supposed cudgel against pointing out obvious historical similarities is, at best, weak. At worst, IT is the affront to the aforementioned ethnicity. Very Warren-ish.
i was gonna say elizabeth warren is more native american than stm is jewish