Russian Orthodox Relics Used To Inspire Russky Troops

9,739 Views | 191 Replies | Last: 3 days ago by Vox Clamantis
CrackerJackAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The case involved a Greek Pentecostal man who targeted an intellectually impaired, vulnerable adult living in institutional care.

Greek courts consistently throw out standard proselytism charges due to ECHR precedence, but they will step in when someone exercises psychological coercion or takes financial advantage of mentally disabled or distressed individuals.

There is no attack on standard every day proselytizing.

Why do you need that law repealed? Why can't you just follow the reasonable law? It's not even enforced, except for the most extreme and perverted cases.

Paying the clergy is not a handout. During the 19th and early 20th centuries, the newly formed Greek state nationalized roughly 7580% of all church-owned agricultural land and monastic properties to resettle refugees and build national infrastructure. In legal compensation for expropriating Church wealth, the state signed agreements contractually obligated to pay clergy salaries. It was an eminent-domain settlement, not a favoritism subsidy.

They pay imams underneath a treaty with Turkey as part of an agreement to protect religious minorities in both countries.

Why in the world should Greece who outright rejects the incorrect theology of wacky American evangelicals or the worldwide evangelical alliance (whatever that is) that think they can proselytize to Greece better than Paul himself did.

Stop being a spoiled brat just because your broken version of Christianity isn't being accepted in one of the ancestral homelands of Christianity.

Ignorant and misguided post again on your part.

I guess keep slinging **** at the wall…




UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
So basically, Orthodox Greece and Islamic Turkey persecute evangelical Christians? Good to know.
Quote:

Since 2020, more than 350 foreign Christian workers and their family members have been expelled from Turkey, including at least 35 cases between December 2024 and January 2025, reported the ADF.

According to the international watchdog, Turkey's Ministry of Interior has assigned the individuals targeted by Ankara "security codes," like as N-82 and G-87, which effectively bars them from ever re-entering the country as it classifies them as a national security threat.

Rieder also reminded the OSCE conference of the "landmark case" Wiest v. Turkey, which is currently before the European Court of Human Rights, and is "expected to set a crucial precedent for the protection of religious freedom in Europe and beyond."

Kenneth Wiest, a U.S. citizen and a Protestant, was born, raised and then resided legally in Turkey with his wife and three children for over 30 years before he was banned from the country in 2019 upon returning from a trip "without evidence of wrongdoing."

His case is just the latest in what is increasingly viewed as discriminatory policies that persecute religious minorities since President Recep Tayyip Erdoan took office more than a decade ago.
https://www.foxnews.com/world/turkey-deports-peaceful-christians-under-guise-national-security-claims-watchdog

Of course, Turkey is also cracking down on Orthodox Christians:
Quote:

11/18/2022 Turkey (International Christian Concern) On 11/15/2022, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) declared that Turkey had violated the human right of the Greek Orthodox Taksiarhis church after denying them the ability to register for property. The church has a long history in Turkey and is one of the foundations under Turkey's law of the Greek Orthodox Community of Istanbul. As a result, the ECHR declared this as discrimination and ordered Turkey to pay a fine of 5,000 euros.
The stark contrast between the previous population of over 1.8 million Greeks just over a century ago, to today's population of a few thousand shows the level of persecution and discrimination they have faced over the years. The foundational churches began their struggle to stay active in today's modern political climate of Turkey. The Greek Orthodox Taksiarhis church's inability to register their church is a prime example of the hardships these communities face here.
According to the Report: Turkey Challenges facing Christians 2016-2020 published by ICC, states the following:
"Turkey has an obligation under national and international law to uphold Freedom of Religion or Belief (FoRB). The authorities must provide a legal framework to accommodate religious minorities and develop a national narrative that promotes social cohesion. Given the new executive powers of Turkey's president, the position holds the necessary authority to make needed changes to the legal framework which protects religious minorities. This obligation for religious freedom extends to those territories under Turkish military control."
https://www.foxnews.com/world/turkey-deports-peaceful-christians-under-guise-national-security-claims-watchdog

So that treaty is not working out very well. Of course, Greece has turned to Israel to help meet some of its legitimate security concerns and need for advanced anti-missile weaponry.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"i want freedom of religion so my society can spiral into secularism"
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"I want to convert Orthodox Christians so they support homosexuality, female pastors, Trinitarian and Christological heresies, and most importantly American cultural norms"
Featured Video Previews
CrackerJackAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
So now you have moved the goal post to Turkey and Israel.

As a Dispensationalist shouldn't you be happy to see Christian Countries ally with Israel?

You make no sense…

You can't be a real person.
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

"i want freedom of religion so my society can spiral into secularism"

So you prefer a mandated religion? That's always worked out well.
Vox Clamantis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
UTExan said:

Vox Clamantis said:

CrackerJackAg said:

UTExan said:

And we know that the Eastern Orthodox persecute evangelicals, Baptists and Pentecostals in some Eastern European countries:
https://www.christianitytoday.com/2024/12/divided-balkans-evangelicals-tiny-number-mighty/

But in the end, it doesn't matter:



No one but you is trying to convince any one contrary to that.

ALL PEOPLE OF ALL FAITHS have historically persecuted people for all sorts of reasons

You're the only one trying to hype your sides people as the paragon of virtue and victims.

My faith and members of my Church is full of sinners and all the things that come with it. I'm not sure that rejecting or not accepting American heresies is persecution.

Have they been executing people? I didn't read your propaganda article from the site you linked. It's not journalism.



That said:

American Evangelicals often go uninvited into historic Orthodox lands with Western donor money, treat nations that held the faith through centuries of Ottoman subjugation and Communist firing squads like unevangelized pagan territory, and then cry "persecution" when local communities reject goofy American born foreign proselytizers with a belief system they only recognize as marginally Christian
.


This x a million. The level of patronizing is off the chart, Grace Cowboy Church will take a mission trip to distribute Sportsman's bibles in a region that has been practicing Christianity since 37 AD.



Then why does the government of Orthodox Greece make it a crime to proselytize?


Because they've seen the fruits of Protestantism.
Vox Clamantis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

"i want freedom of religion so my society can spiral into secularism"

So you prefer a mandated religion? That's always worked out well.


Mandated? No. Promoted and Protected? Yes
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
No, but I think a state religion is fine. You don't have to follow it, but others don't get preference and can potentially be outlawed because dangerous.

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.

You think we had a "state religion" when our country was founded?

And you really want it to be Protestantism? I have to admit, I'm surprised.
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
In ten of the 13 colonies, yes.
CrackerJackAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.

You think we had a "state religion" when our country was founded?

And you really want it to be Protestantism? I have to admit, I'm surprised.


I'm holding out for a Byzantine Emperor;-)
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Man our founding fathers were so unfathomably based I'd be down with that version of Anglicanism.
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

Man our founding fathers were so unfathomably based I'd be down with that version of Anglicanism.

We'd welcome you!
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Vox Clamantis said:

UTExan said:

Vox Clamantis said:

CrackerJackAg said:

UTExan said:

And we know that the Eastern Orthodox persecute evangelicals, Baptists and Pentecostals in some Eastern European countries:
https://www.christianitytoday.com/2024/12/divided-balkans-evangelicals-tiny-number-mighty/

But in the end, it doesn't matter:



No one but you is trying to convince any one contrary to that.

ALL PEOPLE OF ALL FAITHS have historically persecuted people for all sorts of reasons

You're the only one trying to hype your sides people as the paragon of virtue and victims.

My faith and members of my Church is full of sinners and all the things that come with it. I'm not sure that rejecting or not accepting American heresies is persecution.

Have they been executing people? I didn't read your propaganda article from the site you linked. It's not journalism.



That said:

American Evangelicals often go uninvited into historic Orthodox lands with Western donor money, treat nations that held the faith through centuries of Ottoman subjugation and Communist firing squads like unevangelized pagan territory, and then cry "persecution" when local communities reject goofy American born foreign proselytizers with a belief system they only recognize as marginally Christian
.


This x a million. The level of patronizing is off the chart, Grace Cowboy Church will take a mission trip to distribute Sportsman's bibles in a region that has been practicing Christianity since 37 AD.



Then why does the government of Orthodox Greece make it a crime to proselytize?


Because they've seen the fruits of Protestantism.

The horror!
The most prosperous, powerful nation on earth ( the US ) mostly formed by Protestants, governed by Protestants and made wealthy by Protestant businessfolk. 60-65% Protestant from 1865 to 1900, with 80-85% of regular churchgoers identifying as Protestant. https://www.vpm.org/npr-news/2006-03-21/excerpt-american-theocracy/
We are happy to be that safe haven for the refugees from Catholic and Orthodox lands riven by ethnic and religious strife where they may thrive and live peacefully.
Even today, the misgovernance of and lack of opportunity in predominantly Catholic countries is indicated by the high illegal immigration rates from those countries.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
No thanks, modern Anglicanism is like the poster child for the problem, full on globohomo.
Vox Clamantis
How long do you want to ignore this user?
UTExan said:

Vox Clamantis said:

UTExan said:

Vox Clamantis said:

CrackerJackAg said:

UTExan said:

And we know that the Eastern Orthodox persecute evangelicals, Baptists and Pentecostals in some Eastern European countries:
https://www.christianitytoday.com/2024/12/divided-balkans-evangelicals-tiny-number-mighty/

But in the end, it doesn't matter:



No one but you is trying to convince any one contrary to that.

ALL PEOPLE OF ALL FAITHS have historically persecuted people for all sorts of reasons

You're the only one trying to hype your sides people as the paragon of virtue and victims.

My faith and members of my Church is full of sinners and all the things that come with it. I'm not sure that rejecting or not accepting American heresies is persecution.

Have they been executing people? I didn't read your propaganda article from the site you linked. It's not journalism.



That said:

American Evangelicals often go uninvited into historic Orthodox lands with Western donor money, treat nations that held the faith through centuries of Ottoman subjugation and Communist firing squads like unevangelized pagan territory, and then cry "persecution" when local communities reject goofy American born foreign proselytizers with a belief system they only recognize as marginally Christian
.


This x a million. The level of patronizing is off the chart, Grace Cowboy Church will take a mission trip to distribute Sportsman's bibles in a region that has been practicing Christianity since 37 AD.



Then why does the government of Orthodox Greece make it a crime to proselytize?


Because they've seen the fruits of Protestantism.

The horror!
The most prosperous, powerful nation on earth ( the US ) mostly formed by Protestants, governed by Protestants and made wealthy by Protestant businessfolk. 60-65% Protestant from 1865 to 1900, with 80-85% of regular churchgoers identifying as Protestant. https://www.vpm.org/npr-news/2006-03-21/excerpt-american-theocracy/
We are happy to be that safe haven for the refugees from Catholic and Orthodox lands riven by ethnic and religious strife where they may thrive and live peacefully.
Even today, the misgovernance of and lack of opportunity in predominantly Catholic countries is indicated by the high illegal immigration rates from those countries.


Congrats, you're made up of mostly white people who exceed in practically anything. We actually made disciples of all nations and that includes every corner of the world and ever socioeconomic class, not just SEC country.

Western civilization is the apostolic church. You guys rode their coattails for a while and then piloted the ship into the ground.
Serotonin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
As shipping technology opened up the world, northwest Europe did exceptionally well by pivoting into merchant capital economies. They re-oriented their political and social systems to basically turn into economic trade zones.

This led to a simultaneous explosion in wealth and annihilation of of their societies.

Irish, Greeks and Italians still have remnants of their culture; the English and Dutch have no culture. They were the first to push the "anywhere-ization' of the world.

Was Protestantism a cause or effect?
Serotonin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Northwest Europe reminds me of the parable of monoculture forestry:

A wild, natural forest is transformed into an artificial ecosystem designed to do one thing: maximize economic output (by growing a single type of tree).

At first the harvests are impressive, but those yields exceed the capacity of the underlying system. The very things that made the forest resilient in the first place have been stripped away. Over time the soil degrades and eventually the forest itself collapses.

Protestantism took part in this effort to "monoculture" northwest Europe into a trading society. Life had previously been based on the liturgical year with scores of saint days and other holy days. But the new life centered on continuous commercial and industrial production. So the reformation stripped away the liturgical year with all of the old days off and all the feasting and fasting. Instead theological life centered around privatizing religious life into quiet reading of scripture and a six day week without fasting or feasting and one rest day (Sunday). A perfect fit for maximizing economic output
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

No thanks, modern Anglicanism is like the poster child for the problem, full on globohomo.

You're demonstrating your lack of knowledge. Most of American Anglicanism is the opposite.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CrackerJackAg said:

KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.

You think we had a "state religion" when our country was founded?

And you really want it to be Protestantism? I have to admit, I'm surprised.


I'm holding out for a Byzantine Emperor;-)


Why? To call on Western Europe for help?
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Serotonin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
There's also a weird dynamic where, from 1500s onward, there was a ton of selection bias against the dumb, lazy, old, weak, untrustworthy, etc in those hyper-market societies, which propelled them to become more and more competitive.

Protestant Christianity is all about literacy (read your personal Bible!) and intellectual understanding to be saved, but how does this work with old people who are confused, young kids who can't read, or people who are too dumb to grasp even basic concepts?

And on a societal level those nations became economic and geopolitical powerhouses, but they forgot that those other categories of people even exist or how to deal with them. Despite the wealth of northwest Europe or America we've promoted abortion (what economic value do the unborn have?), we have no idea what to do with the elderly, or the lazy, or the low IQ, and we assume that the rest of the world is trustworthy like our populations. And that if someone is a criminal it must be because society did something bad to him and he just needs a fair chance.
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"most" is the key word there, and the problem.
CrackerJackAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
UTExan said:

CrackerJackAg said:

KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.

You think we had a "state religion" when our country was founded?

And you really want it to be Protestantism? I have to admit, I'm surprised.


I'm holding out for a Byzantine Emperor;-)


Why? To call on Western Europe for help?


Dumb….

Not engaging with you anymore.
TeddyAg0422
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just for clarification, are you separating American Anglicanism from Episcopalianism?
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
CrackerJackAg said:

UTExan said:

CrackerJackAg said:

KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

You know like we had for the vast majority of Christendom and when our nation was founded.

You think we had a "state religion" when our country was founded?

And you really want it to be Protestantism? I have to admit, I'm surprised.


I'm holding out for a Byzantine Emperor;-)


Why? To call on Western Europe for help?


Dumb….

Not engaging with you anymore.

Well, as St. Cleopa of Sihastria would say, "May Heaven consume you!" as a parting benediction to this discussion.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TeddyAg0422 said:

Just for clarification, are you separating American Anglicanism from Episcopalianism?

Absolutely.

Much of current American Anglicanism is theologically conservative Episcopalians who grew disgusted with the Episcopal church and left. Another big bunch of current Anglicans are people who spent years in evangelical mega-Churches and wanted something more and deeper.

My Anglican church is a mix of both, with a few refugees from liberal Methodist churches thrown in.
TeddyAg0422
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Got it, good deal. Thanks for the response
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Protestant Christianity is all about literacy (read your personal Bible!) and intellectual understanding to be saved, but how does this work with old people who are confused, young kids who can't read, or people who are too dumb to grasp even basic concepts?

That sounds like a liberal Democrat wrote that. "Everybody is stupid so they need me or people like me to make decisions for them."

Your caricature of Protestant Christianity is wrong, dead wrong. You ignore all of the Protestants and Protestant leaders who have focused on a deep spiritual walk with God. As an example, it is simply silly to describe Protestants such as Wesley or Whitfield as being "all about . . . intellectual understanding". To the contrary, the lack of focus on intellectual matters has been a failing of Protestantism.

Why do you think that literacy exploded in NW Europe and England immediately after the Reformation? It was so that people could read their Bibles. It was Protestant churches that pioneered Sunday Schools for the explicit purpose of teaching the illiterate, especially children, to read.

Ya'll complain about the inaccurate caricatures of the RCC and the EO by Protestants, but then immediately turn around and do the same to Protestants.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KingofHazor said:

Quote:

Protestant Christianity is all about literacy (read your personal Bible!) and intellectual understanding to be saved, but how does this work with old people who are confused, young kids who can't read, or people who are too dumb to grasp even basic concepts?

That sounds like a liberal Democrat wrote that. "Everybody is stupid so they need me or people like me to make decisions for them."

Your caricature of Protestant Christianity is wrong, dead wrong. You ignore all of the Protestants and Protestant leaders who have focused on a deep spiritual walk with God. As an example, it is simply silly to describe Protestants such as Wesley or Whitfield as being "all about . . . intellectual understanding". To the contrary, the lack of focus on intellectual matters has been a failing of Protestantism.

Why do you think that literacy exploded in NW Europe and England immediately after the Reformation? It was so that people could read their Bibles. It was Protestant churches that pioneered Sunday Schools for the explicit purpose of teaching the illiterate, especially children, to read.

Ya'll complain about the inaccurate caricatures of the RCC and the EO by Protestants, but then immediately turn around and do the same to Protestants.


Which was the entire point of my starting this thread. The unexamined, unchallenged assumptions of Protestants in general by RCC and EO forum folks is astounding to me.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Zobel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Yes, the RCC and Orthodox people on this forum who have spent their entire lives in a deeply culturally Protestant society, and many of whom were raised in various Protestant sects have completely unfounded opinions about the topic. This seems entirely plausible.
KingofHazor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

Yes, the RCC and Orthodox people on this forum who have spent their entire lives in a deeply culturally Protestant society, and many of whom were raised in various Protestant sects have completely unfounded opinions about the topic. This seems entirely plausible.

But y'all seem to extrapolate from your limited experiences in a Southern Baptist Church in a small Texas town to all of Protestantism.

Y'all's points about Protestantism frequently display a lack of knowledge of its breadth and depth.
UTExan
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Zobel said:

Yes, the RCC and Orthodox people on this forum who have spent their entire lives in a deeply culturally Protestant society, and many of whom were raised in various Protestant sects have completely unfounded opinions about the topic. This seems entirely plausible.


Then those sects must have failed to teach about the evangelicals in the Church of England being responsible for ending the slave trade. Or the second Great Awakening in this country.
“If you’re going to have crime it should at least be organized crime”
-Havelock Vetinari
Captain Pablo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
KingofHazor said:

Zobel said:

No thanks, modern Anglicanism is like the poster child for the problem, full on globohomo.

You're demonstrating your lack of knowledge. Most of American Anglicanism is the opposite.


Only because of how you define "American Anglicanism"

If you are conveniently limiting that definition to the ACNA, sure. You can call it what you want, but the ACNA is not part of the Anglican community.

But you know who is? The ECUSA. And when you add them, the ACNA (even if you included them in the definition of "Anglicanism") is a fraction of total American Anglican membership

You may not "claim" the ECUSA, but they're the real deal in global Anglicanism

Serotonin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
KingofHazor said:

Quote:

Protestant Christianity is all about literacy (read your personal Bible!) and intellectual understanding to be saved, but how does this work with old people who are confused, young kids who can't read, or people who are too dumb to grasp even basic concepts?

That sounds like a liberal Democrat wrote that. "Everybody is stupid so they need me or people like me to make decisions for them."

Your caricature of Protestant Christianity is wrong, dead wrong. You ignore all of the Protestants and Protestant leaders who have focused on a deep spiritual walk with God. As an example, it is simply silly to describe Protestants such as Wesley or Whitfield as being "all about . . . intellectual understanding". To the contrary, the lack of focus on intellectual matters has been a failing of Protestantism.

Why do you think that literacy exploded in NW Europe and England immediately after the Reformation? It was so that people could read their Bibles. It was Protestant churches that pioneered Sunday Schools for the explicit purpose of teaching the illiterate, especially children, to read.

Ya'll complain about the inaccurate caricatures of the RCC and the EO by Protestants, but then immediately turn around and do the same to Protestants.

I think "intellectual" is being used in two different ways here...

In my original point, "intellectual" means something like textual/cognitive. So this would be spirituality mediated mainly thru reading, hearing, interpreting, and thinking about words and texts.

You use "intellectual" to mean theologically sophisticated which is fine (and I agree with you) but that's a different discussion. I don't want to get caught up in semantics so for clarity I'll rename my use of intellectual as 'textual/cognitive'.

My point isn't that Protestants believe that unintelligent people can't be saved or that Protestants aren't spiritual. The point is that the spirituality is funneled through a much narrower channel which is heavily textual/cognitive: The service itself is centered on the sermon, and in personal life the spiritual focus is more heavily on reading of scripture, Bible studies, reading commentaries, etc. I don't think this is controversial.

In Catholicism and Orthodoxy, those things also exist and are good but there's a much wider range of practices that are bodily, material, communal, ascetic, and ritual: fasting together, feast days, processions, visiting monasteries and meeting monks/nuns, having spiritual elders and prayer rules, pilgrimage to holy sites, venerating icons or the Cross, lighting candles, using prayer ropes or rosaries, receiving holy water, house blessings, relics, prostrations, daily services, communal meals connected to the liturgical calendar, and so forth.

We have a mentally *disabled* young man in our parish who can participate in all of these things. He'll never be reading scripture or Bible commentaries, and in a chruch setting where those things are the main spiritual path, he is left out.

So that's the actual comparison. It isn't "Protestants think too much" and "Catholics and Orthodox don't think." It's that Protestantism has discarded most of the the non-textual forms of devotion and concentrated Christian practice more heavily into textual and cognitive channels. Is this even debatable??

Your point about Protestant literacy is the exact point I'm making. There had to be an enormous effort to teach people to read because of how central the textual mode had become.

And before you say it, yes, high church Anglicans and Lutherans are the exception and are kind of halfway between RCC and Protestant. But they help clarify the pattern. As Protestant denominations moved further away from the RCC they retained less and less of that inheritance.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.