I love the films of both, but if I'm trapped on a desert island I'm bringing the Cameron DVD collection over the Fincher collection every time. Just more Rewatchables and still very solid films.
SJEAg said:
"The Game" getting no love, and it's one of my favorite Fincher movies. And I know "Panic Room" is not his most well regarded, but I find it thoroughly entertaining.
These are probably the only two directors that I'll see the movie on their name alone (although Avatar 2+ might test this). Not even Spielberg or Scorcese make that list for me.