We just got back yesterday from a 7 shows in 4 days trip to NYC. Here's what we saw:
Come From Away - Good show. I won't rush out and see it again but I enjoyed it. The energy and enthusiasm of the cast and the inventive staging carried what I thought was a mediocre book and music. I completely understand why Christopher Ashley got the Tony for Direction. In my opinion this one won't tour long but will make the rounds being produced by regional and community theatres looking for solid shows with large casts. Synopsis for those that want it - set during the events of 9-11 in Newfoundland. A lot of planes got diverted there and it ended up becoming a refugee camp for 5 or 6 days. The show is about those events, the people of the town, the 'refugees' and the relationships that were built. Was about an hour and a half no intermission.
Dolls House 2 - Laurie Metcalf was phenomenal. Definitely deserving of a Tony. The play was actually pretty solid as well. It helps to know Dolls House but isn't a must. Read the Cliff Notes or Wikipedia beforehand and you're more than fine. Chris Cooper was really good. I wasn't sure what to expect from him on stage and thought he more than held his own with Laurie. The other two actresses were quite good. This one was my favorite that we saw from an acting standpoint. They leave the show pretty soon so if you have the chance see it.
Drunk Shakespeare Society - this one was fun. They are doing the Scottish play right now. Not sure if that's always what they do. Look for cheap tickets though and drink before you go. That will help. It's more of a "aren't we clever" kind of thing than actually telling the story but it made me laugh.
Dear Evan Hansen - I went in trying to temper my expectations on this one given all the hype. I thought we were watching the Beatles for a minute there with the reaction that Ben Platt got the entire time. The teenagers love him. As for the show it is quite good. I understand completely why people are reacting to it the way they are. I think it had a chance to be great to phenomenal and for me it falls a bit short of that. It was a little long and I wasn't completely happy with the ending. I think with some cuts and a few adjustments it might have landed that phenomenal punch. But having said that, it's got really great performances, the music is really strong, and it definitely got me misty eyed in a couple spots. Absolutely worth the price of admission and deserved the Tony awards it got. It deals with issues you wouldn't normally think of right off in a musical and tries to look at them in a contemporary way. I'm not sure how it plays with someone besides Platt in the roll and will be interested to see what it does when his contract runs out if he leaves. But again, absolutely see this if you're headed to NYC.
1984 - new adaptation with Olivia Wilde and Tom Sturridge. My least favorite show of the weekend. I was really looking forward to this one given some of the things I had heard about the production. Visually it was fantastic and some of the effects and staging were really inventive. It was slow as molasses and I wasn't really impressed with the performances of the cast. This one had potential and really fell flat. I would say skip it unless you're really just itching to see one of them on stage.
War Paint - My wife and I had only seen Patti Lupone in concert and performing on the Tony's or recordings. We wanted to see her live. She did not disappoint. The accent she used was a little harsh and took a long time to understand. I wish she had eased up on that a bit but damn can that woman sing and is a great actress. Christine Ebersole was fantastic too. I'm so glad that we got to see them both perform in person. The show was visually stunning. The costumes were phenomenal . The music and book weren't that great but the story was really interesting. I hated that you only got a real scene between the two of them right at the very end of the show. Definitely worth watching if you want to see the two of them. I'm not sure how much longer this one is slated to run.
Sweeney Todd - down at Barrow Street. This show was my favorite of the weekend. We always try and see something at Barrow Street if we can. This production started in England in a pie shop and they've replicated the interior of the pie shop inside the Barrow Street space. This is a minimalist production - 3 musicians accompanying the 8 (I think it was) actors. Norm Lewis and Carolee Carmello are the two main characters. Getting to hear them in that small space singing such a great score was really a treat. The entire cast could were phenomenal singers and it was quite beautifully done. They even have an option to show up early and eat a meat pie (or veg pie) before the show. If you've not ever seen this show live, try and see this one. Norm Lewis isn't the greatest actor but his voice is so amazing you easily forgive him that.
Hopefully that helps if anyone is headed to NYC any time in the next few weeks.