Quad Dog said:
I think it's just that the Mando team has really put in the effort of figuring out what does and does not work in The Volume. Therefore they avoid the weaknesses of it. Other directors think it can handle all situations.
I think this is a big part of it, for sure. With Obi-Wan, you could just feel the limitations of The Volume in every frame. I don't know how to explain it technically, but it's like they shot The Volume itself, to where you could practically see the edges of it, and then they would just extend the set/background effects in post. But with The Mandalorian, they properly shoot *in* The Volume, to where you can never see or feel the edges of it, which makes all the difference. If that makes any sense.
That and, of course, it's also what jeffk said above, about this just looking and sounding like Star Wars, far more so than any of the other shows.