1 said:

---

Not specifically addressing Saul's post, but, there needs to be a (friendly) debate sometime on why Phantom Menace is far superior to Attack of the Clones - even though it has lots of Jar Jar AND poor Jake. AotC is an abomination.

---

100% agree with this. The only good parts of AotC are Dooku and Across the Stars. The rest is bad.

It's close, but I still say TPM is worse. I can't look past Anakin and Jar Jar acccidentally winning a battle

Brian Earl Spilner said:

---

Sith
TPM
Clones

I don't dislike any of them, but, TPM is better than Clones for sure. Podrace and Darth Maul fight are just epic.

---

Pod racing is not wizard.

If you get JarJar out of there, the movies ain't half bad.

Incorrect. Amazing sound design.

WGAS? It was a complete waste of movie time

The sound on the pod race is amazing if you have a high end system that can run it.

I loved the pod race and the time Obi wan and Anakin are chasing the bounty Hunter through the city. I'll take those scenes over any scene in the current Last Jedi.

Random office poll of a half dozen 40-somethings and self-proclaimed Star Wars fans that all saw the movie this weekend results in "A"s across the board, save me. I gave it the lone "B". We all hated the Leia crap but agreed it was a really good movie.

K thanks for waiting. Write her off now.

I liked Fett's seismic chargers in AOTC

She isn't dead... She will be in Episode 9 and her role will be substantial! Just wait

Just like how the emperor is still alive....right?

Sigh. Yep.

The best things from AOTC are Across the Stars, and that sound.

aggiephoenix02 said:

---

Saul Goodman said:

---

Got out of my 2nd viewing. My updated rankings (I'm interested to see if this changes at all a year from now):

ESB
ANH
TLJ*
TFA
RotJ
RO
RoftS
AotC
TPM

---

R1 should be higher...

---

Agreed. Right now I'm thinking...

ESB
ANH
RO
TLJ
TFA
RotJ
RotS
AotC
TPM

With not much resolve as to where the last 2 fall.

Good work redline.

Just got to iPic to finally see TLJ!

My own ranking ...

The Empire Strikes Back
A New Hope
Rogue One
Revenge of the Sith
Return of the Jedi
The Force Awakens
The Last Jedi
Attack of the Clones
The Phantom Menace

It's interesting that most poster's rankings are similar in that the majority of each movie's rankings are within two or three spots of all other poster's rankings.

I wonder what the average is of each movie's rank is on this thread... Strongbadag, do you still post under that name? Do you have enough time to look into this, 'cus this seems right up your alley... stats, StarWars, maybe a spreadsheet or two...

I wish there was a Bat Signal for him, I played soccer on a team with both him and his brother (they were the two best players on the team, with a telepathic connection and a nose for scoring goals).

Apparently there will be 20 minutes of deleted scenes on the Blu-ray. I won't link it because there are lots of spoilers in the article, but this is coming from a Collider interview with Rian Johnson and the editor, Bob Ducsay.

They shot a ton of footage for this movie.

3rdGen2015 said:

---

Apparently there will be 20 minutes of deleted scenes on the Blu-ray. I won't link it because there are lots of spoilers in the article, but this is coming from a Collider interview with Rian Johnson and the editor, Bob Ducsay.

They shot a ton of footage for this movie.

---

Yet it is still horrible editing.

VanZandt92 said:

---

3rdGen2015 said:

---

Apparently there will be 20 minutes of deleted scenes on the Blu-ray. I won't link it because there are lots of spoilers in the article, but this is coming from a Collider interview with Rian Johnson and the editor, Bob Ducsay.

They shot a ton of footage for this movie.

---

Yet it is still horrible editing.

---

That's just... like... your opinion... man...

true enough

My ranking
Esb



Star wars
R1
Tfa
Jedi
Tlj


Troopers

Clone war movie






What I imagined splinter of the minds eye would have been






The holiday special







The ewok movie



Those ****astic movies that came out in the late 90's early 2000.

Anyone that puts ROTJ above ROTS is wrong.

Brian Earl Spilner said:

---

Anyone that puts ROTJ above ROTS is wrong.

---

They are close for me, but what elevates Sith over Jedi for me is George Lucas new invention for Jedi - the teddy bear.

"Some" of the Ewok stuff. Meaning the second half of the movie.