We didn't have ages available for the pick time, it was functionally blind outside of barrel number and proof.
I wouldn't say we had consensus on anything outside of eliminating one of the 5 they sent. The other 4 were all in contention for a while and we ended up blinding 3 against each other. The final vote was 3/6 on this one, with the other 2 barrels splitting votes.
The winner was a good all-rounder. My opinion on it specifically was that the palate was a little less complex than the others, but the nose and finish were more enjoyable. This barrel wouldn't qualify as one that has some crazy unique characteristic or taste, although some of the others had distinct notes like bubblegum or heavy barrel char. Other pickers may chime in with their own opinions, as we all had some slight differences in preference.
Nose: syrupy butterscotch and maple, some light grains on the front. Light oak without being tannic
Palate: classic vanilla/caramel, turning to honey & bright cherry. Some barrel char, but not overbearing. Some cinnamon as it moves toward the finish.
Finish: light fruits (pear/peach), medium-long finish, some cinnamon spice but not "hot"
At least one other picker described this as one that you could drink more than one pour of without feeling like it was too heavy or intense.