Like everyone else my rates are going up this year after holding pretty steady last year. I was going to shop around some but I don't want to fill out multiple online questionnaires. Any recommendations on someone/a company that can shop rates for me?

Call your regular agent. They have access to other companies.
I thought my Germania agent only sold Germania policies......turns out he has access to Progressive, Allstate, etc.

I have seen the Liere Agency mentioned on here for years. Farmers finally broke me with their rate increases this year and I gave Liere a call. Quick, painless and saved me over a grand/year between my home and auto.

I would say in a normal market, you' should see a good savings if you've been a long time customer with a good claims history and make a move. They're basically buying a dividend stock.

If you bounce around every year or so, I think you're less likely to see much savings.

classicdoug said:

---

I have been with Liere (Safeco) for about 10 years. I called Service Insurance Group in Bryan last week. Between my 4 cars and house, I'm looking at saving about $3600/year by switching to them and Mercury insurance. This is comparing apples to apples, except SIG is actually valuing my house higher. I emailed Liere yesterday to give them a chance to meet their quote, but I'm not holding my breath.

---

This is interesting. I've been with the same insurance broker for many years. I assumed brokers mostly have access to the same markets and pricing - so what's the deal? I would love an update on this.

I relocated out of Texas a year ago. Pleasantly surprised by the cost of insurance. Got my renewal yesterday and it went down.

Was pleasantly surprised to find out my homeowners insurance is up only around 5% this year.

Been with them for over 10 years. Not sure if they are shopping around as much these days.

Service Insurance Group (SIG)
Owner Brad Hurt

They've always taken care of our personal and commercial needs. Quick to respond and the best rates. Definitely give them a shot.

I own an Independent Agency and more than happy to take a crack at it. Auto isn't much of an issue right now, rates are up but nothing crazy.

Home is the problem. If your home/roof is old, you are in trouble. And DFW Houston areas 10x worse.

Feel free to reach out anytime

Matt@Dimitexas.com

So did Liere show up and compete or did you make a change? I'm at that point.

Liere just quoted a policy for me yesterday with Mercury, interesting there would be a difference in price with a different broker

I've also been with Liere for about 10 years. I shopped them against another broker last fall and Liere still had the best deal.

I am very curious about the Mercury quote as they've quoted Mercury for me in the past. I'll give SIB a shot when my auto comes up in July.

Comeby! said:

---

So did Liere show up and compete or did you make a change? I'm at that point.

---

They are working on it.

Here's an interesting thing. Liere had my wife listed first on the Mercury quote. They reran the quote with me listed first on the policy and the price came down by a little more than $3000/yr. Same 2 kids, same 4 cars, same 4 drivers, same discounts. We have no accidents or tickets and my wife's credit score is actually higher than mine. Liere even says it doesn't make sense, We're waiting on the Mercury home insurance quote

So, get your quotes run both ways just to see what happens if you have a spouse on the policy.

This is good feedback. Thanks for the out of the box advice.

Shot you a note.

classicdoug said:

---

Comeby! said:

---

So did Liere show up and compete or did you make a change? I'm at that point.

---

They are working on it.

Here's an interesting thing. Liere had my wife listed first on the Mercury quote. They reran the quote with me listed first on the policy and the price came down by a little more than $3000/yr. Same 2 kids, same 4 cars, same 4 drivers, same discounts. We have no accidents or tickets and my wife's credit score is actually higher than mine. Liere even says it doesn't make sense, We're waiting on the Mercury home insurance quote

So, get your quotes run both ways just to see what happens if you have a spouse on the policy.

---

This is common and the case with every carrier. Demographics and credit are a factor in all personal insurance. So always good to check both husband and wife to see who gets the better rate.

Been with Liere for about a decade and have referred many folks who wind up saying tons. Customer service always seems good.

State Farm was surprisingly competitive for me

That's what's happening to me. Easily found better rates with the same carrier and when I asked them why they said tough sheet. Won't be recommending them again. I should've known there was trouble when they quoted my parents some obscene rates.

Maybe this will be helpful….i am with a broker in Austin area, I've been with them a long time and have been happy. I am paying about $2400 a year on 2 vehicles (large suv and truck), 2 drivers in 40s - clean driving record. Good coverage. This is through progressive - I shopped around a could not beat this with either a new broker or through usaa or zebra (which is as pretty useless). Called a new broker who said progressive had consistent the best rate.

I am paying around .80% of the insured amount per year on my homeowners. 2% hail claim deductible, 1% otherwise I believe. This is through allied trust. Shopped these out and couldn't find anyone to beat it.

Maybe this data point will help someone.

I had Nationwide for 10 years until today. Switched to Progressive, added a car to the policy, kept all deductibles and coverages the same, and still lowered premiums from $8600 to $4700.

ETA- home and auto combined

Wow! Who did you use?

went direct through the Progressive website.

I tried using PolicyGenius to shop it, but none of their partners would write a policy...I assume based on the age of the roof (15+ years). I tried shopping Allstate, but again, they would not quote a homeowner's policy after spending 15 minutes or more entering personal and property information.

EvenPar said:

---

Service Insurance Group (SIG)
Owner Brad Hurt

They've always taken care of our personal and commercial needs. Quick to respond and the best rates. Definitely give them a shot.

---

His communication (or lack thereof) has been pretty bad.

both auto and home doubled. on auto i have a 17yr who had a wreck, but for 3 cars, it is around 7200.

I am with Liere now. They have me with progressive with auto and foremost.

I checked USAA on auto and they were 7500.

Check some other companies on your own outside of Liere and see if you can get a better deal. And report back!

USAA seems good on homeowners. Overall, GEICO was a ton less on auto. Half the others.

AgsMyDude said:

---

Been with Liere for about a decade and have referred many folks who wind up saying tons. Customer service always seems good.

---

I might have to walk this back some.....

Home just came back 57% and auto is up 33% with no claims on either and no new drivers. Roof is only 4 years old.

If they can't help out by shopping around, I'm definitely taking some of the advice on this thread.