MRB10 said:
You're saying you're OK giving Coinbase the ability to dictate how quickly you can withdraw, censor which addresses you can send to, and trust that they're fully reserved? That's a HARD pass for me.
The issues people have discussed online, when it comes to hardware wallets, pale in comparison. Also, show me the last time a Ledger, Coldcard, or Trezor "vulnerability" resulted in a large number of their customers losing their Bitcoin. I'll wait.
You can start by just realizing a fair amount of people over time just lose track of their wallets, keys, and therefore all of their crypto. People die and leave no trace of it. There was a thread on here last week with the guy losing track of his wallet. Happens all the time.
Then there is security of the keys themselves. You have to write it down, put it somewhere right? That is a significant security vulnerability.
Then there are just untold instances of people sending crypto to and from the wrong address. Also happens all the time.
These three things alone are the reason 99% of people in 1st world countries should be using on-chain storage.
Specifically to ledger/trezor whatever, I own one and they had a data breach and everyone that bought one got hit with phishing attacks. There was an attack years ago people manage to spoof the user interface into sending to the wrong address. People buying wallets that already been compromised, etc.
7 years ago I'd agree with you but present day, no way.