Yup. Don't get comfortable. Go get help.
Here are the teams with ~10% or less chance to make the playoffs per FanGraphs:
- Pirates (10.6%)
- Cubs
- Rays
- Rangers
- Blue Jays
- Tigers
- Nationals
- Angels
- White Sox
- Athletics
- Rockies
- Marlins
From that list here are the top 10 arms per xFIP (min 30 IP)
- Mason Miller - too pricey and Hader wouldn't take the demotion well.
- Paul Skenes - not even close to being available
- David Robertson - Rangers would be dumb not to move him. Older, but he's been great. 11.5 M this year, mutual option next.
- Jack Flaherty - He's having a career year. 14 M this year, free agent next. Probably the #1 target for all playoff teams.
- Garrett Crochet - Young, nasty, and under control for '25, '26, & '27. Going to cost more than Miller. I hope we're willing to go all in here. He's the top of the rotation arm we need for the next 3 years.
- Kevin Kelly - Rays are a pitching factory. Not available since he's so cheap, but his emergence makes others available potentially.
- Tarik Skubal - not available. Stud.
- Hunter Harvey - Don't let the 4+ ERA fool you. He's good. Probably the exact type of arm we need to add to the bullpen.
- Will Vest - Not available & not great stuff.
- Kyle Finnegan - The opposite of Harvey on the Nats. Low 2 ERA. Probably regressing soon.
I think Flaherty & Crochet end up being too expensive for us. I would target the Rays. They're not making the postseason. They are so stacked with arms. In 2025, they will be 9 deep in the rotation between Eflin, Civale, Bradley, Littell, Pepiot, McClanahan, Rasmussen, Springs, & Baz.
- McClanahan, Rasmussen, Bardley, Pepiot, & Baz will be back too late & have too much cheap control.
- Eflin is the most expensive and thus most likely to be available (11 M in '24, 18 M in '25). He's also good, not great. He just refuses to walk anyone & gets you a ton of ground balls.
- Springs is who I want the most. He flashed a true breakout in shorten '23 after a strong '22. He's back on rehab assignments and looking good again. He's got 2.5 years left @ 5.25 M, 10.5 M, & 10.5 M. Less than market value but not free. He'd cost a ton in prospects but could be worth it. A less hyped Crochet.
- Littell & Civale are just guys. Both should be attainable without breaking the bank, but they're more back-end starts.
A couple other SP names that may work Eovaldi, Blackburn, Sandoval, & Mize.