rbtexan said:
We just won the WS without Ohtani. I'm not sure why we would pay $500M for a 31 yr old DH. Keep in mind he won't be pitching next season.
I just don't see the need. There are other areas I would rather see the team spend money (bullpen arms). Our outfield is set, our infield is set, we're good at catcher. If Langford continues his fast trajectory, you have 4 starting OFers, you can rotate the DH ABs between them. Ohtani just seems like a waste of resources to me at this point. If he hadn't blown out his arm, maybe so. But again, he won't be pitching next season, so....
You're asking the wrong question. You are asking "why?" The question is "why not?!"
Baseball is about margins and risk.
We could improve in a few areas, but are our weak spots could be DH, backup C, LH RP, RH RP... maybe a SP.
What we don't know is what the injury outlook will be in 2024. We lost Seager, Jung, and Heim all at the same time during the season.
If you have the chance to put the 2023 MVP and presumably the #1 Hitter in MLB... a guy considered a generational talent in the DH role... or put a guy you drafted less than a year ago who was hitting College pitchers as DH. I think you go with the guy that went .304, 44 HRs, 20 SB, .412 OBP, 1.066 OPS.