iBrad said:
Beat40 said:
Beau Holder said:
I don't even think managers have that much impact over 162 unless they're outliers like Dusty who intentionally kneecap the team. I feel like as long as someone listens to the FO and has some decent sense as far as managing pitching, that's enough.
That salary for a manager is absolutely insane.
I heartily disagree.
Buck Showalter has had extremely talented teams and they have all ended in disaster.
Bochy is a great example of a manager helping to directly change the direction of a team with the Rangers this year. Yes, they moves they made at the deadline for pitching were awesome, he had that team balling up to the deadline.
Just two off the top of my head.
You could argue that Bochy let his team cough up the division and almost let his team collapse to the point of missing the playoffs altogether. If he gets credit for the players performing in the playoffs, he has to also bear the responsibility of struggling down the stretch.
Because we had Dusty ****ing up the lineup card day in and day out, I think we overvalue the impact a manager can have, especially for a team that has team leadership like we have.
I mean they lost Jung, Garcia and Eovaldi for large stretches towards the end of the season. Once those 3 were all back at the end they played at the level they did in the first half
The Astros had their injury woes as well the problem is once they were back to full health around July 27th they had a worse winning percentage to finish out the year than they did up until that point.
So Dusty got Yordan and Altuve back in the lineup...and did worse...lol