Deluxe said:
I'd do it. Although I think Chas or Meyers should be used as trade pieces in a potential Reynolds deal, since we wouldn't need both anymore.
I'd do it if I knew for sure Hunter Brown would excel as a starter as he would essentially replace JV's absence (of course not the same way).
You would have as a rotation:
Framber
LMJ
Javier
Urquidy
Brown
I still think that's a salty rotation as Javier is a 1/2 on 90% of other clubs and if Hunter progresses he's a sneaky good 5 - Urquidy is about a #4 as you can get.
If we do encounter injuries it gets a bit rough and who knows, maybe we do experiment with Abreu as a starter or bring up another arm. If we experiment with Abreu our bully obviously takes a hit.
However, by adding Reynolds to center and Abreu to 1st you have SIGNFICANTLY upgraded our two biggest areas of need. Our LOD would be incredible, also still might be able to add Contrares. You add him and you could start a 1-9 without a single weakness, basically a pitcher having to face an all-star team each time through the order.