Maybe Crane just enjoys and is driven by public/media scorn. Now that we've won and the sign stealing stuff is further behind us, he needs a refresh of material.
***Official Houston Astros 2022-23 Offseason Thread***
1,082,678 Views |
12340 Replies |
Last: 1 yr ago by Beat40
Sign Luhnow to a one year deal
Ags #1 said:
Maybe publicly to other GMs?
I guess. What he said to reporters wasn't anything bad at all.
It's his team and he can run it how he wants but it sure feels like he's teetering on the edge of screwing this up. It feels like he's about to be Jerry Jones.
Agreed. Asssume he was talking to others. His interviews were fine imo
digging tunnels said:
What did Click really do in terms of personnel?
Luhnow was the one who built the farm system and team.
I did like him bringing in Graveman in 2021, but it was a rent-a-player
Didn't sign correa
Locked up yordan
Brought in Vasquez and Mancini for very little, yes mancini didn't do much but the move was right
We still have hunter brown
His moves seem to be the lack of moves as of now.
I'm just making the argument for him. I don't know
I know its highly unlikely we would hire luhnow, im just saying it would feel sooooo good and would be the biggest middle finger we could give.
That said we should hire Sig.
That said we should hire Sig.
Mathguy64 said:
It's his team and he can run it how he wants but it sure feels like he's teetering on the edge of screwing this up. It feels like he's about to be Jerry Jones.
Well I like it being his team.
Jeff lives in Spain and is running a Spanish soccer team, also owns a Mexican team and an analytics company.
What do you boys want for breakfast BBQ ?.....OK Chili.
Farmer1906 said:Yup.Deluxe said:Agree with the structure and that Stearns takes over the day he's available, but I don't think we'll miss a beat this year.Farmer1906 said:
My guess is, Crane holds on to the rest of the team to run baseball operations. Then hires someone in after the 2023 season. No long term deals are done. Only 1-2 year deals in FA with guys Crane is more familar with. Not ideal when trying to repeat.
But you know me. I am a guy who cares about the margins. Crane and his team of Dusty, Reggie Jackson, Jeff Bagwell are not who I want to make decisions about who low-key reliever we can sign and have a major impact on. They're not the ones who can evaluate internal prospects for a deadline trade. There are ton of little things that could be missed now. I like having the edge and being ahead of the curve. This aint it.
Crane is not changing the make up of our player development organization after all this success
I said it was highly unlikely, what do you want from me?MAROON said:
Jeff lives in Spain and is running a Spanish soccer team, also owns a Mexican team and an analytics company.
You can't fire someone that's not under contract. Sounds like Crane rescinded the offer but that's not the same thing.
HarryRocket said:digging tunnels said:
What did Click really do in terms of personnel?
Luhnow was the one who built the farm system and team.
I did like him bringing in Graveman in 2021, but it was a rent-a-player
Didn't sign correa
Locked up yordan
Brought in Vasquez and Mancini for very little, yes mancini didn't do much but the move was right
We still have hunter brown
His moves seem to be the lack of moves as of now.
I'm just making the argument for him. I don't know
Click built the BP we have now, made the call to bring up guys like Framber, Javier, Luis, made the call to ride with Pena.
The notion that Click hadn't done much is BS.
This will sting especially if Crane wants to do patchwork in house GM by committee crap until Stearns is available next year.
Mathguy64 said:
It's his team and he can run it how he wants but it sure feels like he's teetering on the edge of screwing this up. It feels like he's about to be Jerry Jones.
Eh, I feel Crane is the best owner in MLB.
He took over a franchise that had to deal with a lot of bull**** (loss of historic rivalries/roots), set the stage for Luhnow and the analytics folks, hired Dusty/managed the cheating scandal fallout, won 2 World Series, and kept the Astros at the peak of the sport through a constant shuffling of baseball management personnel.
HarryRocket said:digging tunnels said:
What did Click really do in terms of personnel?
Luhnow was the one who built the farm system and team.
I did like him bringing in Graveman in 2021, but it was a rent-a-player
Didn't sign correa
Locked up yordan
Brought in Vasquez and Mancini for very little, yes mancini didn't do much but the move was right
We still have hunter brown
His moves seem to be the lack of moves as of now.
I'm just making the argument for him. I don't know
Montero, stanek, Nerris. Without those guys the season could've turned out much differently.
Just say it's not happening period. 
What do you boys want for breakfast BBQ ?.....OK Chili.
MAROON said:
Just say it's not happening period.
I know Milwaukee said Stearns is under employment for a year and not available but I wonder if Crane is going to ask them what compensation they would accept?
Crane better not take up GM duties himself. We don't need a Jerry Jones here.
Nobody's that stupid.Mathguy64 said:
It's his team and he can run it how he wants but it sure feels like he's teetering on the edge of screwing this up. It feels like he's about to be Jerry Jones.
Other than Jerry Jones.
Life is better with a beagle
Sure he is. No Click, no Pete Putila (Now Giants GM), Oz Ocampo (Marlins Assistant GM). Most of the top guys developed under Jeff left already too (Sterns, Elias, Mejdal, Taubman). Who's to say everyone else who worked under Click stays? He could vs the next GM in Det and bring his people with him.astros4545 said:Farmer1906 said:Yup.Deluxe said:Agree with the structure and that Stearns takes over the day he's available, but I don't think we'll miss a beat this year.Farmer1906 said:
My guess is, Crane holds on to the rest of the team to run baseball operations. Then hires someone in after the 2023 season. No long term deals are done. Only 1-2 year deals in FA with guys Crane is more familar with. Not ideal when trying to repeat.
But you know me. I am a guy who cares about the margins. Crane and his team of Dusty, Reggie Jackson, Jeff Bagwell are not who I want to make decisions about who low-key reliever we can sign and have a major impact on. They're not the ones who can evaluate internal prospects for a deadline trade. There are ton of little things that could be missed now. I like having the edge and being ahead of the curve. This aint it.
Crane is not changing the make up of our player development organization after all this success
I called this after hearing Crane speak at Dusty's presser. I am gunna have to wait and hold judgement on this decision. Lots of stories out there on Crane trumping him on decisions, and butting heads.
My guess is a lot of the decisions that went down over the last few years Click opposed and Crane/crew went against him and things worked out still. With the success Crane decided he wants someone different??
With that said Crane doesn't need to hire a "yes" man. That's what I am scared of.
My guess is a lot of the decisions that went down over the last few years Click opposed and Crane/crew went against him and things worked out still. With the success Crane decided he wants someone different??
With that said Crane doesn't need to hire a "yes" man. That's what I am scared of.
Brought back Brantly, picked up Yuli's extension, Goodrum, Dubon, Odo, Castro, all the draft picks. He's done plenty. I'd grade him a solid B.MosesHallRAB04 said:HarryRocket said:digging tunnels said:
What did Click really do in terms of personnel?
Luhnow was the one who built the farm system and team.
I did like him bringing in Graveman in 2021, but it was a rent-a-player
Didn't sign correa
Locked up yordan
Brought in Vasquez and Mancini for very little, yes mancini didn't do much but the move was right
We still have hunter brown
His moves seem to be the lack of moves as of now.
I'm just making the argument for him. I don't know
Montero, stanek, Nerris. Without those guys the season could've turned out much differently.
I'm not sure why anyone would want correa with the dodgers or yankees. Thinking it will cause conflict and destroy the team from within is wishful thinking imo.
This is about right. I think Click is probably good, not great. If Crane is making a move like this, he needs to have a plan. Alienating and then firing Click without something lined up is just his ego getting in the way and not a good sign.Farmer1906 said:Brought back Brantly, picked up Yuli's extension, Goodrum, Dubon, Odo, Castro, all the draft picks. He's done plenty. I'd grade him a solid B.MosesHallRAB04 said:HarryRocket said:digging tunnels said:
What did Click really do in terms of personnel?
Luhnow was the one who built the farm system and team.
I did like him bringing in Graveman in 2021, but it was a rent-a-player
Didn't sign correa
Locked up yordan
Brought in Vasquez and Mancini for very little, yes mancini didn't do much but the move was right
We still have hunter brown
His moves seem to be the lack of moves as of now.
I'm just making the argument for him. I don't know
Montero, stanek, Nerris. Without those guys the season could've turned out much differently.
whoever the next gm is better not take more than 5 games to win the WS, or your ass is fired too
Live shot of Crane calling Luhnow.MAROON said:
Jeff lives in Spain and is running a Spanish soccer team, also owns a Mexican team and an analytics company.
Life is better with a beagle
mAgnoliAg
Joined:
Jan 9, 2013
Posts:
36,618
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I posted yesterday I don't think Crane liked having to step in anytime something big was happening (ie JV resigning, Yordan extension).
Just my gut but I think Click was used to operating on a tB budget and would get cold feet on some of these big deals and Crane would step in.
I'm guessing Crane wants someone who can do this without having to babysit.
Just my gut but I think Click was used to operating on a tB budget and would get cold feet on some of these big deals and Crane would step in.
I'm guessing Crane wants someone who can do this without having to babysit.
I don't think it will cause conflict or destroy the team at all. It would be funny to watch the fans though.Jet Black said:
I'm not sure why anyone would want correa with the dodgers or yankees. Thinking it will cause conflict and destroy the team from within is wishful thinking imo.
Let's also not forget our GM had to trade not 1 but 2 CFs so our manager would stop platooning them. Last year specifically with straw that was flat out moneyball, "no art you can't play Peña bc he plays for Philadelphia now" type move.
If click wouldn't have moved Siri this year we would probably have seen platooning all the way through the playoffs.
It's hard to criticize anybody since we just won it all but I still think Dusty hamstrings whatever GM you put in place to a small degree by doing it his old school way
If click wouldn't have moved Siri this year we would probably have seen platooning all the way through the playoffs.
It's hard to criticize anybody since we just won it all but I still think Dusty hamstrings whatever GM you put in place to a small degree by doing it his old school way
I wonder if its just the opposite. He let Lunhow do that and it burned him bad so he's decided to oversee it much more closely.Ag_07 said:
I posted yesterday I don't think Crane liked having to step in anytime something big was happening (ie JV resigning, Yordan extension).
Just my gut but I think Click was used to operating on a tB budget and would get cold feet on some of these big deals and Crane would step in.
I'm guessing Crane wants someone who can do this without having to babysit.
Maybe Luhnow can be our shadow GM
Hell. No.zgood10 said:
Get Luhnow on the horn
I appreciate what Lunhow built, but you cannot, cannot cost your team because of poor ethics. It's not just the cheating, it's the moves like Osuna. Brought uncessary heat all in the name of winning.
As Click proved, you can bring good guys in who are just as good, or in many cases better in the pursuit of wining.
Lunhow certainly can find talent in the guys to build an organization, but I don't trust him not to turn a blind eye.
Featured Stories
See All
2026 Lakewood (CA) tight end Caleb Tafua commits to Texas A&M
by Jason Howell
Presenting Texas Aggies United's 'Battle At Reed' Sweepstakes!
by Texas Aggies United
22:08
2d ago
5.1k
Hefner scores 19 as No. 12 A&M overpowers HCU in Friday matinee
by Olin Buchanan
Ar'maj Reed-Adams announces his return to Texas A&M for 2025
by Richard Zane