free_mhayden said:
Moore has upside next year.
Cashner doesn't.
You guys will all feel a lot better if/when you finally realize this year wasn't about putting the best team out there, but instead putting the best team out there that didn't tie-up money long-term.
I already know that, but it doesn't make me feel a lot better.
Cashner has upside this year. Moore does not. And where is this belief that Moore has value next year? The value is Moore has a Team Option at only $750K.
Maybe you missed this:
Quote:
Cashner (31)
2016: 5.98 ERA
2017: 3.40 ERA
2018: $6.5M
2019: $9.5M
2020: $10M Team Option.
Moore (29)
2016: 4.08 ERA
2017: 5.52 ERA
2018: $9.0M
2019: $10M Team Option/$750K buyout
Cashner is making $2.5M less this year.
If he Rangers are looking towards 2019... they could have paid Cashner $9.0M in 2018 and only $6.5M for 2019. Who knows... maybe they could have paid him enough in 2018, to make the 2019 an Option structured like Moore's.
As it is, right now we have:
Mike Minor @$9.833Then OptionsHamels (34): $20M/$6M
Perez (27): $7.5M/$750K
Moore (30): $10M/$750K
Fister (35): $4.5M/$500K
I think it is generally accepted that if Hamels does well, he'll be traded. If he doesn't do well, he may be traded (for less) or his Option won't be picked up (Basically is he worth $14M to pitch for the Rangers in 2019).
Moore seemed to lose command. He got two quick outs in the 1st, then walked the next 2 guys and hit a 3rd. It is the same problem we've all had with Perez. He'll be doing fine, then fall apart.
JD does not seem to have a plan for 2019, although it doesn't keep anyone from thinking he does.
I think he went all-in for Ohtani. I think he thought it was a done deal and he was planning 2019 around him. When that didn't happen, I don't think JD had a Plan "B."
A strategy of getting as may retreads as possible with Option years has purpose, if you are looking to fill a #4/5... if you are needing to supplement a gap in your upper levels of SP to help keep from having to push younger guys.
Maybe JD is going old-Rangers-School of focusing on just trying to score more runs than the other team.
JD's strategy has to be for 2020, not 2019. He will have more holes to fill in 2019, than he had to fill in 2018.