quote:
Yeah, you'd rather trade a prospect for something that helps your team, but in this case you'd be trading your prospect for a shutdown reliever,
Agreed.
quote:
upgrading your catching situation, clearing out a logjam at 1B, gaining about $25m over the next 4 years (and it's actually closer to $60m+ when you consider what the amount of negative trade value Prince has) and (I believe) gaining a draft pick when Chapman declines the off-season QO.
I don't think it upgrades things significantly. Marginally, at best this season and an anchor long-term.
It does clear the logjam at 1B, assuming McCann doesn't end up becoming a 1B\DH. He is old with lots of miles for a catcher. I think this is speculation on both opinions.
At 1B, the logjam goes away when Moreland ends this season. Next season we only have Fielder (1B\DH) and Gallo. Rua and Profar as options.
I don't see the benefit on the financial side. We owe Fielder $18X4 = $72M. McCann is owed $17X2 + $15M. So the net:
2017: $1M
2018: $1M
2019: $3M
2020: $18M
So almost all of that benefit is in 2020. Four years from now. $1-3M is Cesar Ramos money.
I thought he had to be on the roster by the start of the season to get the QO benefit.
quote:
It's not sexy, but it improves the team in multiple areas and helps correct a significant long-term mistake.
I disagree on both accounts. It helps neither the team, nor financial side of things.
quote:
Would never happen, but fun to scattershoot trade ideas.
It is always fun to scattershoot.
Personally, I have more hope about a Fielder turnaround, than I have confidence McCann will be an upgrade 2... 3... 4 years from now. Fielder hit .305 last year.