In the post above you discuss the price on the high side for adding an ace. Do you really think JD gets crucified for trading Profar? I don't. And I wouldn't crucify him. Their middle infield consist of a 27 yr old and 22 yr old. If he isn't playing every day then he's worth more as trade bait than a reserve.
Chris Davis needed a change of scenery. There was something mental about playing for the hometown ball club. I'm glad he found success, and I don't think the Rangers are really any worse for it. Theyve been to the WS twice and I don't think Crush alone wins the 2010 series with the way Cliff pitched, and we should have won the series in 2011 anyways (SCREW YOU NELLY!).
I might have reservations about trading a bunch of pieces to the A's for the simple fact that I don't want to be terrorized for years by guys like Profar and Gallo, or Luis Ortiz. But I'd be fine if they went out of division, or if you got Gray for relatively cheap. And I understand that is still pretty expensive. All three of those guys may be on the Rangers roster next year, but if they aren't producing and playing every day, or starting every fifth day then I think you're in a spot where you move them for the right piece(s).
Chris Davis needed a change of scenery. There was something mental about playing for the hometown ball club. I'm glad he found success, and I don't think the Rangers are really any worse for it. Theyve been to the WS twice and I don't think Crush alone wins the 2010 series with the way Cliff pitched, and we should have won the series in 2011 anyways (SCREW YOU NELLY!).
I might have reservations about trading a bunch of pieces to the A's for the simple fact that I don't want to be terrorized for years by guys like Profar and Gallo, or Luis Ortiz. But I'd be fine if they went out of division, or if you got Gray for relatively cheap. And I understand that is still pretty expensive. All three of those guys may be on the Rangers roster next year, but if they aren't producing and playing every day, or starting every fifth day then I think you're in a spot where you move them for the right piece(s).