Good Poster said:
Harry Dunne said:
OK Roger Ebert, why don't you do better?
Well first off, if James Harden were an "actor" then he would be up for the "Best Actor" award at the academy awards which would be the equivalent of the MVP, which he has already won.
Second, "Best Film" would be a team award and equivalent to an NBA Championship, which no he has not won yet.
Third, I get the bad ending but are we really saying he "can carry a niche movie" and that's it? He is going to go down in history as one of the most prolific scorers in NBA history.
"Well first off" I was just trying to have some fun - I didn't put a ton of thinking into it. I was just thinking about a fat cokehead who was really good but not well-rounded (figuratively), and that's the first guy that popped into my head...but thank you for the thoughtful analysis.
Yes, I think the Dantoni Rockets were a "niche" team. Set a lot of offensive records but not well-rounded and didn't win a championship and were bad when it mattered most. Harden can't carry a championship team and he knows that or he wouldn't have forced a trade to a team where he is the 2nd or 3rd best player.
How Harden goes down in history is TBD. He's certainly a HOFer. I would guess he ends up like Barkley. Got pretty close, tried to jump on a superteam that didn't work out, never got his ring.