Gigemags382 said:
Pumpkinhead said:
Gigemags382 said:
Ulrich said:
I can't speak about other teams and there's a lot of history to play out before we can do a real ranking, but as a Spurs fan I've got two to consider:
Kawhi's leg against GSW a couple years ago is at least as impactful as Durants injury, because we know it changed the course of two franchises. One was no longer a title contender when he left, one is a title contender now that he's there.
Robinson's back in '96-97 turned into Tim Duncan, Gregg Popovich, and 5 NBA titles. As of now this is way, way out ahead of Durant hurting his leg and dropping a championship team to a top 2-3 team.
1) This happened in the NBA finals
2) It happened to arguably the best player in the league (unarguably top 5)
3) He's right in the middle of his peak prime years
4) It's one of the worst injuries that an athlete can suffer, and one that is almost impossible to recover from back to pre-injury talent level
5) He's days from entering free agency
6) Teams have been trading players and clearing cap space just for the opportunity for a chance to sign Durant
All that is not even mentioning the back story of all the discussion about what will his legacy be after joining the Warriors (he'll never be the "man", etc). Now we'll likely never see what he's like in his peak prime on his own team. His legacy is shot in my opinion.
This isn't about dropping a championship team to top 2-3 in the league. In fact, this has nothing to do with that. The timing, severity, far-reaching impact across the entire league is monumental.
I think his legacy at Golden State, actually probably will now be looked at in a more appreciative light because he put his career on the line for them last Monday night. Based on the media conversations thus far, this injury has probably enhanced his Warriors legacy. Not saying your own opinion will change, but in general it seems many folks at least in the media are expressing those kind of opinions right now. And the Warriors teammates and coaches are saying 'We are playing for K' and so forth, for the first time particularly this season, you get the feeling Durant is being truly considered 'one of the Warriors'.
Sure, as far as a reflection of his competitive spirit. And his legacy gets a sentimental boost. But as far as staking a claim as one of the best of all time, he doesn't have much to show for the record books (barring an incredible comeback from this Achilles injury). In my opinion.
He is almost certainly going to be considered a top-15 ish player All-Time regardless of how the remainder of his career finishes out.
Remember that he already has an extensive resume with 12 seasons in the NBA under his belt, was NBA Rookie of the Year in 2008, NBA MVP in 2014 at Oklahoma State, 10 All-Star appearances, 6 times on All NBA First Team, was the leading scorer in the NBA for four seasons (2010, 2011, 2012, 2014), 2 NBA titles, 2 NBA Finals MVPs, etc. etc.
He'll probably still, even if only like 75% of what he was after he comes back, knock out a few more years of probably being at least a good (maybe even All-Star level) player....because he is so damn skilled including being a great near 7' shooter. Like Dirk at Dallas, Durant even if a relative statue, could be dangerous just draining shots.
He isn't going to pass Jordan or LeBron in the conversation of 'Greatest of All Time', but he'll certainly be known as one of the 'best of all time'.