Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
ahpetty33 said:
Cinco Ranch Aggie said:
Quote:
if they didn't pay you, would you go to work?
Playing college football is a job?
40+ hours a week to generate billions in revenue for a corporation? Sounds like a job to me
It's not a job.
Pie in the sky - these are students who are playing a game. They have always been paid, sometimes above the table through things like scholarships/room & board, etc, and other times under the table (our own job scandal in the early 90s, OU's car dealership thing, etc).
Prior to NIL, there were limitations on these kids' earning potential that were ridiculous. But now we've gone in the opposite direction where kids are getting millions (apparently). We might as well just start referring to college football as NFL Minor League.
What you're saying is that it's always been a job, they were just underpaid.
To a certain extent that has some accuracy. But not toally.
I agree that players and coaches should be under the same constraint for contractual obligation. A scholarship is a one year contract, so that makes the portal legally understandable.
However... It's the dollars and the egos that drive all of this. Half a billion dollar stadia, Billion+ dollar TV contracts, 10 million dollar coaches are what change the collegiate game - the players were just late to get their share.
* "They were always paid" - to a certain extent, but it had a more "paying for your loyalty" than "paying you for the job" to the understandings.
* "A few hours a week" - BS it's many hours per week, pretty much all year.
And yes, it does suck, and much of it is because of the egos of those unsatisfied with winning your conference, beating your rival, and playing in your bowl game to be the goals of collegiate football.
The money and egos wanted a Jr NFL and got precisely that. My magic wand would have it all as DIII football with student athletes playing for getting laid Saturday night, $20 tickets, $4 hot dogs, and coaches making whatever other PE teachers at the school make and only playing schools that you have a natural reason to play, geography or situation.