Texas A&M Football
Sponsored by

N.C. State's leading tackler plans to sit out Gator Bowl against Texas A&M

11,053 Views | 81 Replies | Last: 7 yr ago by PineywoodsAg
TexasRebel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Maybe the NCAA should stop being a farm for the NFL.

If these academics were allowed one more game before graduation and productive work I'm sure they'd take it.
permabull
How long do you want to ignore this user?
88jrt06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
gocobra said:

Wow. That says a lot when the other team's best players are afraid we might hurt them in a bowl game.

"Yeah, and mostly they have this Louisiana safety-dude. And he will not have to miss the 1st half. -OUT-"
StruttinWolf
How long do you want to ignore this user?
MassAggie97 said:

I had no idea NC State was so overflowing with NFL-caliber talent!

7 players were drafted last year including what will probably be the NFL defensive rookie of the year in Bradley Chubb
Our-turn-to-rule
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ACC don't play to the same smash mouth degree as SEC
Lateralus Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
jxs40 said:

Maybe the bowls should provide a free Lloyd's of London insurance policy to players identified with NFL talent.

(half serious half joking)


So you want the bowls to pay the premium? I am okay with that.
Agsuffering@bulaw
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Assuming no preexisting conditions, Anybody know the cost of a loss of value policy for a projected mid 1st round player? mid 2nd round player?

How much would it cost to insure a player for a bowl game?
94chem
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kozmozag said:

Has any player bailed on a championship game yet?


Colt McCoy
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Agsuffering@bulaw said:

These situations should be evaluated case-by case. I agreed with the WR, b/c he is projected mid 1st round.

Unless there is some undisclosed reason, I disagree with Spratt's (the LB) decision. Most projections have him in rounds 2-3. He probably received a round 2 draft grade. In other words, he is looking at $0.5-4 mil guaranteed.

But if he has a big bowl game against a good SEC rushing team, he could play his way into the 1st round and be guaranteed $10 mil or more. The scouting reports all seem to say he has NFL tools, but he needs to get more physical against blockers.




I know nothing about Spratt, but most of the NFL comes from dirt poor families. I'm sure many would sit out for a guaranteed 500k. If he's gonna play his way into the first round, it won't be in this game. It'll be at the combine.
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Agsuffering@bulaw said:

Assuming no preexisting conditions, Anybody know the cost of a loss of value policy for a projected mid 1st round player? mid 2nd round player?

How much would it cost to insure a player for a bowl game?


I know these policies are crazy high over a season, but if it's just one game? It would seem much more affordable.
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Little Rock Ag said:

This is a bad trend in my opinion. I understand why players feel that way, but, c'mon, you're still a vital part of the NC State team until the game is over.


It's a meaningless game with a lot of money at stake for some of these players, I would make the same decision as long as it wasn't a playoff game
Agsuffering@bulaw
How long do you want to ignore this user?
According to a salesman quoted by ESiP'N

Quote:

"It's very important to remember that the threshold is 40 percent below their projected earnings,"

The risk is so high, that the insurer requires a 40% margin of error. That tells all. I take back what I said about the LB. Anybody with a draft grade* is stupid to play in a non-playoff bowl.


Trayveon- IF you get a draft grade, hang it up and get paid. You deserve it.



*The league used to issue draft grades for rounds 1-5. Now they only issue grades for 1&2 and

http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/20592832/how-college-football-players-get-insurance

https://operations.nfl.com/the-players/development-pipeline/college-advisory-committee/
Mateo84
How long do you want to ignore this user?
How is a bowl game any more or less meaningless than any other game other than a playoff game? If these players are skipping a bowl game, why not skip the last game of the season? Why not just skip the whole year and wait for the NFL?
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Mateo84 said:

How is a bowl game any more or less meaningless than any other game other than a playoff game? If these players are skipping a bowl game, why not skip the last game of the season? Why not just skip the whole year and wait for the NFL?


Because during the regular season you are playing meaningful conference games and also to try and make the playoffs.

Winning or losing against LSU the last game of the season is infinitely more meaningful than winning the gator bowl.
Signel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We've had guys in the past play for us and have insurance to protect their draft status. I like how this works. It gives them a chance to experience the final game with their teammates AND reap the rewards of their hard work.
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Signel said:

We've had guys in the past play for us and have insurance to protect their draft status. I like how this works. It gives them a chance to experience the final game with their teammates AND reap the rewards of their hard work.


Not everyone can afford that kind of insurance though
30wedge
How long do you want to ignore this user?
decent looking Ag said:

30wedge said:

They need some skin in the game so to speak. If they sit out and do make it to the NFL, they should have to pay back some of their scholarship.


How many millions of dollars do universities make off of these kids without them ever seeing a penny?
Four years of a pampered lifestyle, room and board and books, special accommodations, tutoring, and more, all for a limited amount of effort is more than enough pennies.
30wedge
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PacifistAg said:

30wedge said:

They need some skin in the game so to speak. If they sit out and do make it to the NFL, they should have to pay back some of their scholarship.

Then you'll just get players claiming muscle tightness and they don't feel comfortable playing.

Should coaches pay back part of their salary if they accept another job and don't coach the bowl game?
Yes the coaches should. But that would never happen because you have universities that come up with stupid contracts where they get paid even if they don't coach for several years on their remaining contract. Like Sumlin.
Little Rock Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoustonAg2106 said:

Little Rock Ag said:

This is a bad trend in my opinion. I understand why players feel that way, but, c'mon, you're still a vital part of the NC State team until the game is over.


It's a meaningless game with a lot of money at stake for some of these players, I would make the same decision as long as it wasn't a playoff game


Glad to know you're okay with NC State winning. Since it's a meaningless game and all.
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
30wedge said:

decent looking Ag said:

30wedge said:

They need some skin in the game so to speak. If they sit out and do make it to the NFL, they should have to pay back some of their scholarship.


How many millions of dollars do universities make off of these kids without them ever seeing a penny?
Four years of a pampered lifestyle, room and board and books, special accommodations, tutoring, and more, all for a limited amount of effort is more than enough pennies.


Know how I know you didn't play D1 football? I'm not saying they aren't taken care of on average, but for the true studs, it's pennies compared to what they are earning for the university and what that same "limited amount of effort" will make them when they leave.
decent looking Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
30wedge said:

decent looking Ag said:

30wedge said:

They need some skin in the game so to speak. If they sit out and do make it to the NFL, they should have to pay back some of their scholarship.


How many millions of dollars do universities make off of these kids without them ever seeing a penny?
Four years of a pampered lifestyle, room and board and books, special accommodations, tutoring, and more, all for a limited amount of effort is more than enough pennies.


You must be 10 years old.
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Mateo84 said:

How is a bowl game any more or less meaningless than any other game other than a playoff game? If these players are skipping a bowl game, why not skip the last game of the season? Why not just skip the whole year and wait for the NFL?


I think you will start to see people, especially at RB, skipping entire seasons. OL and DL would also be good candidates to sit out once their worth has been proven, but they aren't necessarily sexy enough to be remembered after a year off.
HoustonAg2106
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Little Rock Ag said:

HoustonAg2106 said:

Little Rock Ag said:

This is a bad trend in my opinion. I understand why players feel that way, but, c'mon, you're still a vital part of the NC State team until the game is over.


It's a meaningless game with a lot of money at stake for some of these players, I would make the same decision as long as it wasn't a playoff game


Glad to know you're okay with NC State winning. Since it's a meaningless game and all.


Im just a fan, we're talking about the players aren't we? If it was your son would you want him to risk millions of dollars over the Gator Bowl or the Alamo Bowl?
Bockaneer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bowls are like extra practice- early spring if you will... Let them sit and see what the new talent can do
91G 'EM 94GGIES!
Onionman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wbt5845 said:

decent looking Ag said:

30wedge said:

They need some skin in the game so to speak. If they sit out and do make it to the NFL, they should have to pay back some of their scholarship.


How many millions of dollars do universities make off of these kids without them ever seeing a penny?
When you look at the benefits the kid receives from the school vs. the number of hours of work the kid puts in to play his sport - he would do better flipping burgers at McDonalds.

So yeah the kid has no incentive to play in a glorified exhibition game that might endanger his ability to support his family for years to come. It's a no brainer, actually.
Totally disagree.

You are only valuing the free education but players also get free coaching that often makes them better (unless under Sumlin), much needed practice and game time, workout facility and get free publicity when they go to a big school.

Also, why do you keep saying these players make millions and millions for the University? When a single player goes down with an unfortunate injury most often attendance does not drop off at all. Where do you get your figures that a single player is making millions and millions for the University?

Also according to your logic why even play football in the first place...players have died, been paralyzed and had brain injuries. Too risky for someone like you who is scared of an injury in 1 game and seem to have no means of buying insurance And why would the bowl game be any less of a 'real' game (exhibition as you call it) than all the other games in the regular season?


Onionman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bockaneer said:

Bowls are like extra practice- early spring if you will... Let them sit and see what the new talent can do
That's ridiculous.

Why even play any game in the season then???

Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Onionman said:

Bockaneer said:

Bowls are like extra practice- early spring if you will... Let them sit and see what the new talent can do
That's ridiculous.

Why even play any game in the season then???




The season is obviously a different beast. The bowl game will not increase your draft stock and doesn't matter one bit towards a conference championship, playoff berth or anything meaningful at all. It is not smart for these guys to put themselves at risk for literally no gain.

And we are already starting to see more guys sit out seasons, or half seasons. It will increase as the years go along and I don't blame them one bit. No one is playing for love of their university. They are playing for a payday, as they should.
Crocker
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Players are free to walk at any time. I don't begrudge any individual who makes that personal choice. Not sure what I'd do balancing loyalty, commitment and risk. I do think it's worse to leave a team before a season is up than to forgo an entire season.

Games without key players lose entertainment appeal accordingly. This is the issue for me. I do think our bowl has lost some atteactiveness with a weakened side and my level of interest has been lessened. Sucks to play anyone who can make excuses for a loss. Also it just kind of sucks investing time following a sport where the players walk away before busniness is concluded.
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Crocker said:

Players are free to walk at any time. I don't begrudge any individual who makes that personal choice. Not sure what I'd do balancing loyalty, commitment and risk. I do think it's worse to leave a team before a season is up than to forgo an entire season.

Games without key players lose entertainment appeal accordingly. This is the issue for me. I do think our bowl has lost some atteactiveness with a weakened side and my level of interest has been lessened. Sucks to play anyone who can make excuses for a loss. Also it just kind of sucks investing time following a sport where the players walk away before busniness is concluded.


I don't like the 24 team playoff, but you can bet your ass every player who has chosen to sit out (aside from OSU's RB) are suiting up for another game. Maybe it's 8. Maybe it's 16. But for pure entertainment purposes, there should be an expansion.
Z
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Throughout history, when have bowl games ever been anything but a "glorified exhibition game" with the exception of a few each year......please tell me how the cotton bowl played into the national championship race in 1986? It didn't, but it sure was a hell of a game to watch
PineywoodsAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag4coal said:

Onionman said:

Bockaneer said:

Bowls are like extra practice- early spring if you will... Let them sit and see what the new talent can do
That's ridiculous.

Why even play any game in the season then???





Quote:

The season is obviously a different beast.
Apparently not.


Quote:

And we are already starting to see more guys sit out seasons, or half seasons. It will increase as the years go along and I don't blame them one bit.

Drewmeister
How long do you want to ignore this user?
HoustonAg2106 said:

Signel said:

We've had guys in the past play for us and have insurance to protect their draft status. I like how this works. It gives them a chance to experience the final game with their teammates AND reap the rewards of their hard work.


Not everyone can afford that kind of insurance though
The university can pay for it if they want. Amazingly enough, not only does the NCAA allow this, despite being backwards and wrong-headed in so many other ways, they actually give each school "student assistance" money! From the ESPN article linked above:
Quote:

The student assistance fund is money provided to every university by the NCAA that can be used for a variety of scenarios to help student-athletes financially for everything from travel for funerals to formula for babies. The NCAA allows universities to pay for the insurance policies out of this fund, but not every university chooses to do so. Texas A&M, for example, paid $50,000 from this fund to help offensive lineman Cedric Ogbuehi secure insurance. Butt and his family secured loans to pay for the premium instead of using the student assistance fund at Michigan.
I didn't know this before, but good bull!

I agree that it would be good for the Bowls to pay for this insurance, e.g. for anyone with a 1st- or 2nd-round grade. Not just a good gesture, but good for business, to see the star players of the chosen schools actually compete in your game!
jt16
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Ag4coal said:

Mateo84 said:

How is a bowl game any more or less meaningless than any other game other than a playoff game? If these players are skipping a bowl game, why not skip the last game of the season? Why not just skip the whole year and wait for the NFL?


I think you will start to see people, especially at RB, skipping entire seasons. OL and DL would also be good candidates to sit out once their worth has been proven, but they aren't necessarily sexy enough to be remembered after a year off.


That's ironic since the first to try that was a RB that was a monumental bust after a year away from a college football program
Scotty88
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Spineless millennial puskies!

Be men and stand with your team...

Much is wrong with our world and sports in general
Ag4coal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
jt16 said:

Ag4coal said:

Mateo84 said:

How is a bowl game any more or less meaningless than any other game other than a playoff game? If these players are skipping a bowl game, why not skip the last game of the season? Why not just skip the whole year and wait for the NFL?


I think you will start to see people, especially at RB, skipping entire seasons. OL and DL would also be good candidates to sit out once their worth has been proven, but they aren't necessarily sexy enough to be remembered after a year off.


That's ironic since the first to try that was a RB that was a monumental bust after a year away from a college football program


Please tell me you aren't talking about Maurice Clarett.
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.