I really hate subjective math. Anyway. If we use the 1970 date, Texas is in their right to use 1995. which would make us 5-10 in the series. Also, I am sick of the all male argument as a negative. Have you looked at football history on how the service academies were prior to the 60s and actually up into the 70s for Navy. We have been good when we have hired good coaches. We have been bad when we have not. Under DX we won, under Jackie we won, under RC we won, under a lot of the others, we did not.
BTW, if the all male part was such a handicap, why did we win against most of our other opponents during those time periods. Sorry, this whole argument is based off someone looking at dates and find a date when we can say we are competitive or ahead in the series and then start finding a reason to validate it.
Heck if we are going to use fuzzy dates, then going sense 1970 we are 18-22 against tech.