Is there anyone on here that prefers Trump over Desantis? [see staff note]

8,208 Views | 125 Replies | Last: 2 yr ago by Earth Rider
Waltonloads08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
[Taking OP's question at face value. If you post simply to be disrespectful or attack, don't bother unless you want a ban. Serious responses are encouraged. This is after all, the politics board -- Staff]

Honest question, and could you explain why? Not looking for a fight, I just want to understand.

Thanks.
Franklin Comes Alive!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan
SamjamAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I used to think a successful governorship meant experience and demonstrated policy. Times have changed.
AgDev01
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Franklin Comes Alive! said:


Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….

Im guessing you were a Hillary voter? If not, then what was your reason for supporting you to support Trump in 2016?
Waltonloads08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Franklin Comes Alive! said:

Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan


Fair answer, thanks. It sounds like you would like to hear specific policy positions and goals before you change you mind, and that makes sense.
Waltonloads08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
SamjamAg said:

I used to think a successful governorship meant experience and demonstrated policy. Times have changed.


can you explain what you mean?
jrdaustin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Franklin Comes Alive! said:

Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan
This is interesting. But would you concede that pretty much every candidate for office outside of Biden, GHWB, or any other VP would have limited foreign policy or federal tax experience.

Carter - Former Governor - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
Reagan - Former Governor - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
GHWB - VP & former CIA Director - Meets your criteria
Clinton - Former Governor - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
GWB - Former Governor - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
Obama - Former Senator - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
Trump 2016 - Former Businessman - Limited FP or Federal Tax policy experience.
Biden - Former VP - Meets your criteria (But look what that got us)

It is important criteria, to be sure, but the intangibles of the ability to govern will be vital for Trump to be successful if elected. And I'm not sure many in Washington will be willing to work with him. He'll be labeled a lame duck on Day 1 and be mired in controversy - deserved or not. I'm afraid an elected Trump would be a chaotic 4 years.

But like the OP, I appreciate and respect your position.
Earth Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trump.

Trump can inspire the people. People will drive hundred of miles to a Trump campaign rally. I just don't see deSantis bringing that same level of enthusiasm.

I don't think DeSantis will be some great leader like Ronald Reagan was, or anywhere close. DeSantis is also a little young, and Trump has a ton more life experience and of course experience in the White House.

I think Trump is going to blow him out in the debates too

having said all that, I think DeSantis is more electable in the general election, just not in the primary.
JohnLA762
How long do you want to ignore this user?


Trump in 2024 and DeSantis in 2028/2032 would lock up the WH long enough to fix the **** storm we find ourselves in.
IMnAg79
How long do you want to ignore this user?

Waltonloads08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wyoming said:

Trump.

Trump can inspire the people. People will drive hundred of miles to a Trump campaign rally. I just don't see deSantis bringing that same level of enthusiasm.

I don't think DeSantis will be some great leader like Ronald Reagan was, or anywhere close. DeSantis is also a little young, and Trump has a ton more life experience and of course experience in the White House.

I think Trump is going to blow him out in the debates too

having said all that, I think DeSantis is more electable in the general election, just not in the primary.


Interesting, I am curious why you think Trump "blows him out" in debates? RD seems like a sharp guy that would be well prepared. Have to disagree on 44 being too young, frankly I think Trump and Biden both have an age problem- neither is as sharp as they were at 44. Thanks for the comments.
Waltonloads08
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Can we refrain from campaign / fan propaganda, unless you would explain more in an edit?
Martin Cash
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wyoming said:

DeSantis is also a little young, and Trump has a ton more life experience and of course experience in the White House.


You do realize that Trump is the exact same age as Biden was four years ago? When we all said he was too old?
The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left. Ecclesiastes 10:2
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Franklin Comes Alive! said:

Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan
While in the House, DeSantis Chaired the Subcommittee on National Security as a part of the Oversight Committee and he served on the Foreign Affairs Committee. He also sponsored multiple tax bills and had pretty deep budget experience for not actually serving on the Committee. He also served on Judiciary.

He's insanely well rounded and experienced for being 44, all of that was before he was Governor and after he served in the military including a tour in Afghanistan (which would also seem to be Foreign Policy experience).
"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."

Ronald Reagan
Funky Winkerbean
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes..

I want a second term Trump wreaking havoc on the ass clowns that have used government agencies as political weapons against him. It's a precedent that must be confronted and controlled.

I don't like how old he is and I don't like that he, like so many, seem to have forgotten the train that's been run on this country from the left. I figure his narrative will heat up as we near primaries and I'll decide from there. I believe DeSantis is a phenomenal candidate, but think Trump is better suited to do what I want done.

I know, **** in one hand..
J. Walter Weatherman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Waltonloads08 said:

Wyoming said:

Trump.

Trump can inspire the people. People will drive hundred of miles to a Trump campaign rally. I just don't see deSantis bringing that same level of enthusiasm.

I don't think DeSantis will be some great leader like Ronald Reagan was, or anywhere close. DeSantis is also a little young, and Trump has a ton more life experience and of course experience in the White House.

I think Trump is going to blow him out in the debates too

having said all that, I think DeSantis is more electable in the general election, just not in the primary.


Interesting, I am curious why you think Trump "blows him out" in debates? RD seems like a sharp guy that would be well prepared. Have to disagree on 44 being too young, frankly I think Trump and Biden both have an age problem- neither is as sharp as they were at 44. Thanks for the comments.


Hoping this doesn't turn into a flame fest because I'm genuinely curious about this too. How can you watch how trump performed against biden in a debate and think he would do well against a Harvard educated Navy lawyer half his age?
Funky Winkerbean
How long do you want to ignore this user?
His base doesn't care one iota about his style. Only results.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aggie93 said:

Franklin Comes Alive! said:

Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan
While in the House, DeSantis Chaired the Subcommittee on National Security as a part of the Oversight Committee and he served on the Foreign Affairs Committee. He also sponsored multiple tax bills and had pretty deep budget experience for not actually serving on the Committee. He also served on Judiciary.

He's insanely well rounded and experienced for being 44, all of that was before he was Governor and after he served in the military including a tour in Afghanistan (which would also seem to be Foreign Policy experience).
A bit more just from his Wiki that is edited by liberals, he accomplished about as much as you will find for a 3 term Congressman and he is deeply principled, he followed his own term limits guidelines and refused a Congressional Pension:

Quote:

DeSantis signed a 2013 pledge sponsored by Americans for Prosperity vowing to vote against any global warming legislation that would raise taxes. He introduced the Faithful Execution of the Law Act of 2014, which did not become law but would have required the United States Department of Justice to report to Congress whenever any federal agency refrains from enforcing laws for any reason. In 2015, DeSantis was a founding member of the Freedom Caucus, a group of congressional conservatives and libertarians.

DeSantis opposes gun control. He received an A+ rating from the National Rifle Association. He generally opposes firearm regulation, saying, "Very rarely do firearms restrictions affect criminals. They really only affect law-abiding citizens.

DeSantis was a critic of Obama's immigration policies; he opposed Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and Deferred Action for Parents of Americans (DAPA) and accused Obama of failing to enforce immigration laws. He co-sponsored the Establishing Mandatory Minimums for Illegal Reentry Act of 2015, also known as Kate's Law, which would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to increase penalties applicable to aliens who unlawfully reenter the U.S. after being removed. DeSantis encouraged Florida sheriffs to cooperate with the federal government on immigration-related issues.

In 2016, DeSantis introduced the Higher Education Reform and Opportunity Act, which would allow states to create their own accreditation systems. In an op-ed for National Review, he said his legislation would give students "access to federal loan money to put towards non-traditional educational opportunities, such as online learning courses, vocational schools, and apprenticeships in skilled trades".

In 2016, DeSantis received a "0" rating from the Human Rights Campaign for his voting record on LGBT-related issues and legislation.[url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_DeSantis#cite_note-59][58][/url][url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_DeSantis#cite_note-60][59][/url] Two years later, he told the Sun-Sentinel that he "doesn't want any discrimination in Florida, I want people to be able to live their life, whether you're gay or whether you're religious."

DeSantis was present before the June 2017 congressional baseball shooting, and the perpetrator asked him whether the players were Republicans Later that summer, DeSantis proposed legislation to end funding by November of that year for the Mueller investigation of President Trump. He said that the DOJ order dated May 17, 2017, "didn't identify a crime to be investigated" and was likely to start a fishing expedition. House Republican leaders did not allow DeSantis's amendment to proceed to the floor for a vote.

Fiscal policy

DeSantis has said that the debate over how to reduce the federal deficit should shift emphasis from tax increases to curtailing spending and triggering economic growth. He supports a "no budget no pay" policy for Congress to encourage the passage of a budget. He believes the Federal Reserve System should be audited.

In the wake of the alleged IRS targeting controversy, DeSantis called for IRS commissioner John Koskinen's resignation for having "failed the American people by frustrating Congress's attempts to ascertain the truth". He co-sponsored a bill to impeach Koskinen for violating the public's trust. Citizens Against Government Waste, a conservative think tank, named DeSantis a "Taxpayer Superhero" in 2015.

He supported the Regulations from the Executive in Need of Scrutiny (REINS) Act, which would require that regulations that have a significant economic impact be subject to a vote of Congress prior to taking effect.

DeSantis introduced the Let Seniors Work Act, which would repeal the Retirement Earnings Test and exempt senior citizens from the 12.4% Social Security payroll tax, and co-sponsored a measure to eliminate taxes on Social Security benefits.

He sponsored the Transportation Empowerment Act, which would transfer much of the responsibility for transportation projects to the states and sharply reduce the federal gas tax.

DeSantis has opposed legislation to require online retailers to collect and pay state sales tax.
He voted for the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. He said the bill would bring a "dramatically lower tax rate", "full expensing of capital investments", and more jobs to America.

Congressional pensions and term limits

DeSantis opted not to receive his congressional pension, and filed a measure that would eliminate pensions for members of Congress. After introducing the End Pensions in Congress Act, DeSantis said, "The Founding Fathers envisioned elected officials as part of a servant class, yet Washington has evolved into a ruling class culture."

DeSantis supports a constitutional amendment to impose term limits on members of Congress, so that U.S. representatives would be limited to three terms and senators to two. As of 2022, he has serve three terms as a U.S. representative.

"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."

Ronald Reagan
ProgN
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Waltonloads08 said:

[Taking OP's question at face value. If you post simply to be disrespectful or attack, don't bother unless you want a ban. Serious responses are encouraged. This is after all, the politics board -- Staff]

Honest question, and could you explain why? Not looking for a fight, I just want to understand.

Thanks.
I'm not saying who I'm voting for in the primary because this feud is dividing conservatives into separate tribes and creating a chasm between the two camps. As both sides attack each other instead of Biden and the dems, then people will become more entrenched and will refuse to vote for the other guy should he be the nominee, which is exactly what the dems want.

That said, I'll vote for my preference in the primaries, but I will vote for whomever is the Republican nominee in the general because salvaging our country is more important than being right and my pride. If dems win again, then I honestly believe our country will be done.
taterchip
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Trump. Not a policy that I don't like. Apparently, Trump is a bigger threat to the Deep State or they would be trying to derail him at every turn. They are are scared of Trump, but I believe, and they do as well, buy Desantis over time.
WestTexasAg04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's clear that most people of F16 and TD prefer President Trump over RD. The answer to why a minority prefer RD is because of OMB, tweets, fauci, lockdowns, cabinet picks. President Trump is a fighter. More so than anyone in my lifetime. As an outsider it is understandable to me that some of his cabinet picks were really out to sabotage his administration. I've always considered myself a Rush Limbaugh Conservative / Dr. Ron Paul Libertarian. No current politician is in President Trumps league when it comes to fighting for America. When I saw how the Dems. Rinos, drive by media, fbi, cia, doj, UN, nato, nafta, davos, eu, bilderbergs, tlc, fb, chyna, gates, Twitter, clinton, bush, romney, mccain, obama did everything they could illegal and legal to stop and sabotage President Trump and his Make America Great Again agenda I knew that finally we had an American in the White House that was not afraid to fight the establishment and deep state. As of today I don't see anyone able to take on the globalist like President Trump.
Casual Cynic
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Funky Winkerbean said:

Yes..

I want a second term Trump wreaking havoc on the ass clowns that have used government agencies as political weapons against him. It's a precedent that must be confronted and controlled.

I don't like how old he is and I don't like that he, like so many, seem to have forgotten the train that's been run on this country from the left. I figure his narrative will heat up as we near primaries and I'll decide from there. I believe DeSantis is a phenomenal candidate, but think Trump is better suited to do what I want done.

I know, **** in one hand..
It would certainly be entertaining. Democrats would probably impeach him 2 or 3 more times just out of pure spite.
Slyfox07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Desantis is a 44 year old, more refined version of trump with none of the baggage.

So yeah...Texags will probably go with the 80 year old orange guy.

SLYFOX NOTE: This staff note is unnecessary.
Post removed:
by user
J. Walter Weatherman
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Funky Winkerbean said:

His base doesn't care one iota about his style. Only results.


I definitely agree overall, was referring to the comment about trump "blowing DeSantis out" in the debates, which seems extremely unrealistic. Unless they have a really different opinion of what wins a debate.
texagbeliever
How long do you want to ignore this user?
J. Walter Weatherman said:

Funky Winkerbean said:

His base doesn't care one iota about his style. Only results.


I definitely agree overall, was referring to the comment about trump "blowing DeSantis out" in the debates, which seems extremely unrealistic. Unless they have a really different opinion of what wins a debate.

I think Trump will have more memorable moments and receive more attention. Id agree that Trump won't out policy talk DeSantis.
aggie93
How long do you want to ignore this user?
texagbeliever said:

J. Walter Weatherman said:

Funky Winkerbean said:

His base doesn't care one iota about his style. Only results.


I definitely agree overall, was referring to the comment about trump "blowing DeSantis out" in the debates, which seems extremely unrealistic. Unless they have a really different opinion of what wins a debate.

I think Trump will have more memorable moments and receive more attention. Id agree that Trump won't out policy talk DeSantis.
Trump's gift in debating is he talks to the audience and not the stage. He's very good at projecting his personality and landing a zinger. His actual debate discussion skills are mediocre and he can get flustered and get irritated. If he stays calm and relaxed though his entertainer persona comes out and that is him at his best.

I really wanted to see him in a 1v1 against Cruz in '16 but he ducked out because he was starting to pull away, Cruz did very well against him but the crowded debate stage favored Trump. Trump v Hillary was almost unwatchable as it was just snarky and nastiness but Trump landed a few great zingers as Hillary wasn't really prepared for his style.

Trump's performance against Biden in the 1st Debate was just horrible, he clearly wasn't prepared and thought he would just wipe the floor with him and Wallace and Biden tag teamed him into some huge blunders. He did well in the other debates but after the 1st Debate but Biden basically just played defense at that point and the 1st Debate is always the most important in a General. It's why HW Bush lost to Clinton even though he mopped the floor with him in the final debate in '92.

Setting definitely matters. For instance if you have a large debate stage and someone like Vivek decides to go after DeSantis along with Trump that's going to be tough for DeSantis. Haley is very solid but I doubt she really attacks anyone fiercely. Pence may be interesting, he's likely to go after Trump and he is a solid and disciplined debater that destroyed Kamala. DeSantis has serious brainpower just like Vivek, those guys can pull out deep details on issues and communicate them effectively.

Still Trump has that gift of talking to the audience and putting on a show and debates aren't really won on points they are won on how people feel at the end. You cannot underestimate him.
"The most terrifying words in the English language are: I'm from the government and I'm here to help."

Ronald Reagan
beanbean
How long do you want to ignore this user?
WestTexasAg04 said:

It's clear that most people of F16 and TD prefer President Trump over RD.
This thread doesn't reflect that at all.

https://texags.com/forums/16/topics/3375111
Earth Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I shouldn't have said blow him out, but in my opinion Trump stood out in the republican primaries in 2016.

DeSantis might have a strong showing in the debates, but Trump will show his depth and charisma and again will win the debates in the primaries. Trump may be in his 70s, but he is still as sharp as can be. And the whole Harvard educated Navy lawyer doesn't carry a lot of weight to me.

Just my opinion. Not looking to flame anyone, I just think the ex president will be very hard if not impossible to beat in the primaries, but in the general DeSantis might get more independents than Trump could.

aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is it allowed if I say I haven't decided yet?

I need to see what DeSantis thinks he can do.
Earth Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Very well analyzed and thought out. I think based on Trumps past performances he will be hard to beat in the primaries on a debate stage with 8 others.

And Pence is the wildcard, I think he might make a run at Trump, but Trump clowned plenty of challengers in the past.
CharlieBrown17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Franklin Comes Alive! said:

Yep

I currently prefer Trump based on his proven track record

Desantis seems like a viable future candidate, but with no foreign policy, no tax policy, etc it's kinda hard to throw full support at a candidate w so many unknowns…. It'd be like blindly following a cult leader at this point to throw full support at Desantis….


But we'll see soon enough if Desantis chooses to present his game plan







Earth Rider
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yeah but Biden was never really all there, and his decline in mental capacity has only accelerated over time.

Trump is as sharp as ever,
Deputy Travis Junior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Can't believe any poster believes Trump will out debate anybody. He lost a debate to a fossil 3 years ago and today sounds embarrassingly close your chain email-forwarding 80 year old grandpa. Then, in his rare moments of clarity, he spends his time gaslighting TF out of everybody who actually listens.

What TF do you think will happen in a debate when Trump accuses Ron of locking down Florida? Do you think DeSantis will stammer amd stumble or do you think he will mercilessly list every stupid action Trump took and compare them to his own? Wouldn't surprise me if DeSantis read some of Trump's tweets aloud to really complete the on-stage beheading.

He is a narcissistic, mentally declining geezer who has fired every non yes man who used to work for him. He will be horribly prepared for every debate, ramble nonsense for 90 minutes, and then take to his social network that nobody uses to claim victory.
Sublette County
How long do you want to ignore this user?
taterchip said:

Trump. Not a policy that I don't like. Apparently, Trump is a bigger threat to the Deep State or they would be trying to derail him at every turn. They are are scared of Trump, but I believe, and they do as well, buy Desantis over time.


Fan of the bumpstock ban, eh?
Last Page
Page 1 of 4
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.