***Russian - Ukraine War Tactical and Strategic Updates*** [Warning on OP]

7,637,917 Views | 47867 Replies | Last: 1 hr ago by 74OA
TRM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RebelE Infantry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.
neAGle96
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
Bad bull on Shell. Once one western buys the others will begin to as well
Charpie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I smell a true uprising in Russia. You've blocked the youths way of communicating to the outside world.
TRM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Beat40
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wangus12 said:

Mule said:

aggiehawg said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.
Or there is further fractioning into more independent sovereign states like what happened the last time?

We (the West) missed our opportunity when Gorbachev did the right thing and brought the communist experiment to an end. We did not support (get involved enough) to ensure that democratic rule was being established on as many levels as possible. The old cronies and Putin stepped into the power vacuum and the rest is history.

We may get a second chance. Let's see how this plays out and demand more from our leaders. The world may not survive Putin 2.0 let alone Putin 1.0.
I will say I think the younger Russian has much more exposure to to the West via technology. We do have a chance if Putin is ousted


Part of the problem is Microsoft just pulled out of Russia. Other tech companies have as well. Soon that tech we could each out to the younger generation will stop working and you lose that avenue or communication.
aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
BusterAg said:

Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
The American people need to boycott Shell gasoline stations.
Actually, this is a good thing. Forcing them to sell at steep discounts (losing the large profit they were expecting) leads to less production from Russia if the profit margin isn't there. Costs more to extract that they can get on the market.

When we were energy independent the prices went way down but ours was by oversupply. Their discounts are necessary to move any product at all. Big difference.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Google maps shows a fairly significant fighter base just east of Mykolaiv. I wonder how it's doing
jabberwalkie09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RebelE Infantry said:

rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.
Im sure I don't have to say this but anything that Russia demands in return for a surrender/peace agreement will almost certainly be outrageous and l likely unpalatable to most Ukrainians.
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RebelE Infantry said:

rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.
There aren't any negotiations though. Its very much, we want everything and you get nothing.
deddog
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
PJYoung said:



"we are shocked by how dumb their behavior is"

I grew up in a pro-Warsaw Pact country, so followed a lot of their wars closely. I can't tell you how many times i've read a variation of this statement. I distinctly remember UNITA saying the same thing about the Russians and Cubans in freaking Angola, maybe about 50 years ago.
On how easy it is to ambush the Russians"
- "The Russians are like elephants, following the same path everyday, except elephants are intelligent"
AgsMyDude
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
JobSecurity said:




Reddit, telegram, Whatsapp next? They are going full North Korea and isolating populace from all outside information.
Ag In Ok
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Has the eastern Uke army pushed to cross to the western bank of the DNeiper river?
BusterAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggiehawg said:

BusterAg said:

Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
The American people need to boycott Shell gasoline stations.
Actually, this is a good thing. Forcing them to sell at steep discounts (losing the large profit they were expecting) leads to less production from Russia if the profit margin isn't there. Costs more to extract that they can get on the market.

When we were energy independent the prices went way down but ours was by oversupply. Their discounts are necessary to move any product at all. Big difference.
Sadly, selling at a $28 discount when Brent is at >$100 will not lead to less Russian production.

Brent averaged $70 in 2021, and $40 in 2020.

Plenty of profit to be had there.
bangobango
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This is probably a stupid question for you guys who really know this stuff, but I was wondering with how effective these Javalins seem to be in fighting tanks, are tanks basically obsolete now?
ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/02/russian-soldiers-mothers-committee-ukraine

Quote:

Throughout the morning, Golub received calls from relatives saying their loved ones were unwilling to fight in Ukraine.

In one, a mother from the southern region of Dagestan said her son, who was on the frontline, had told his officers that he didn't want to participate in the conflict. They told him he had no choice.

"This really shouldn't be going on," Golub said.


Easy solution is to shoot the officers.
B-1 83
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Kenneth_2003 said:

TheEternalPessimist said:

ABATTBQ11 said:

GAC06 said:

I don't necessarily doubt they've killed 7,000 Russians but I definitely doubt they took real pictures of 7,000 dead Russian soldiers


7000 pictures of dead Russian soldiers <> pictures of 7000 dead Russian soldiers

Could be many pictures of the sane scene from different angles.
Great point.

But it's quite clear Russia military is paying a heavy price in casualties.

I think minimum 5000+ casualties on low side. < 10,000 high side.

Will be catastrophic to morale and public support back home --- assuming the truth is revealed and made known to Russian people.

How do you silence 10,000 mammas?
The count isn't done going up either
It's quiet in Siberia
Being in TexAgs jail changes a man……..no, not really
Eso si, Que es
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RebelE Infantry said:

PJYoung said:




>18 year olds with 3 days training, haphazard gear, and no uniform

>Ukraine is winning, or even doing all that well.

Pick one
There were 2 kids that were 16, 3 kids that were 17, 2 kids that were 18, and 5 that were 19 that died defending the Alamo, along with numerous others of unknown age.

While I am fully aware of the outcome of the Alamo, you fight for what you believe in, no matter your age. It is a hard way to have to grow up quick, but battle knows no age limits. That kid is sleeping on a yoga mat at this very moment, he has my respect.
PJYoung
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG


Quote:

Fragilities in systems,combined with remarkable Ukrainian resistance,has shocked Russian commanders, western officials say, and is having a psychological impact on Russian troops because of ferocity of the fight. But for all the problems, they are likely to adapt,say w. officials

Just as Russia's military plans have faltered, so have some of the FSB's plans for covert action and political change. And just as military is moving to more indiscriminate attacks, there are concerns that occupation of cities will see heavier repression.
ABATTBQ11
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RebelE Infantry said:

rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.


He's at the table. Russia is the one making untenable demands.
jabberwalkie09
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bangobango said:

This is probably a stupid question for you guys who really know this stuff, but I was wondering with how effective these Javalins seem to be in fighting tanks, are tanks basically obsolete now?
Short answer: Extremely.

There's enough video and images on Twitter, Reddit, and Telegram showing the aftermath of Javelins and NLAWS decimating Russian columns.
BlackGoldAg2011
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bangobango said:

This is probably a stupid question for you guys who really know this stuff, but I was wondering with how effective these Javalins seem to be in fighting tanks, are tanks basically obsolete now?
I don't have any first hand knowledge so i'm open to correction, but from keeping up with all of these discussions and reading from those who do, my takeaway is that it wouldn't seem that tanks are necessarily obsolete now, its more that the addition of these highly portable and effective anti armor weapons to the battle field in mass really steps up the importance of armored columns having proper infantry protection.
Bag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bangobango said:

This is probably a stupid question for you guys who really know this stuff, but I was wondering with how effective these Javalins seem to be in fighting tanks, is symmetrical warfare basically obsolete now?
fify
bangobango
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
RebelE Infantry said:

rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.
And how do you do that? How do you apply more pressure on him than what he is dealing with already? That man is ready to die to defend his country and its freedom.
The Debt
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Is this just throwing stuff on the wall time? You are seeing a war in real time, where Russia is unprepared. Please tell me an instance where human nature you throw in the "B" team.

As for DOD logistics, the Russian's couldn't hold our jock.

I guess it's not common knowledge, so let me explain it to you. During the cold war the west had intel on the quality of equipment in case things got hot. All the satellite states had 3rd and 4rh rate equipment, and tons of it. They saved their best equipment (tanks/jets) for Russia proper.

The idea behind this is that when nato invades, nato will send their best, just like you suggest. The best will grind through substandard equipment. They will put thousands of miles and hours on the shiny new equipment, causing erosion and maintenance, and by the time the allies get to Russia, the Soviets unleash fresh equipment that was tactically comparable, but with less wear.

I was not surprised when we saw 30year old tanks and trucks with half a tank of gas being thrown at Ukraine. Its consistent with their m.o.

Plus you have to remember Russians play chess from age 5. Do you lead with a rook, or with a pawn? Pawns, in this war, probe enemy positions, flush them out, Ukrainians throw the kitchen sink at the pawns, then a queen shows up and they are all fked.
hbtheduce
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
aggiehawg said:

BusterAg said:

Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
The American people need to boycott Shell gasoline stations.
Actually, this is a good thing. Forcing them to sell at steep discounts (losing the large profit they were expecting) leads to less production from Russia if the profit margin isn't there. Costs more to extract that they can get on the market.

When we were energy independent the prices went way down but ours was by oversupply. Their discounts are necessary to move any product at all. Big difference.

A $23 deduct at $110 does not dent their profits at all. Russia's break evens are probably well below $30/bbl, They are just fine at $80.

Now it is less money than would be expected for the possible war machine. But compared prices pre-conflict, the deduct isn't even that heavy.
TRM
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieLit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BusterAg said:

Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
The American people need to boycott Shell gasoline stations.
Most of them aren't owned by Shell, they're owned by a local mom and pop and only the pumps are leased to a supplier that may have licensing to use the Shell brand name, but actual financial connection to Shell is little or none. Few things in real estate are more complex than gas stations and it is usually best to use whatever newer gas station (because newer ones have cleaner tanks) is most convenient and not think about it.
GAC06
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Debt said:

Quote:

Is this just throwing stuff on the wall time? You are seeing a war in real time, where Russia is unprepared. Please tell me an instance where human nature you throw in the "B" team.

As for DOD logistics, the Russian's couldn't hold our jock.

I guess it's not common knowledge, so let me explain it to you. During the cold war the west had intel on the quality of equipment in case things got hot. All the satellite states had 3rd and 4rh rate equipment, and tons of it. They saved their best equipment (tanks/jets) for Russia proper.

The idea behind this is that when nato invades, nato will send their best, just like you suggest. The best will grind through substandard equipment. They will put thousands of miles and hours on the shiny new equipment, causing erosion and maintenance, and by the time the allies get to Russia, the Soviets unleash fresh equipment that was tactically comparable, but with less wear.

I was not surprised when we saw 30year old tanks and trucks with half a tank of gas being thrown at Ukraine. Its consistent with their m.o.

Plus you have to remember Russians play chess from age 5. Do you lead with a rook, or with a pawn? Pawns, in this war, probe enemy positions, flush them out, Ukrainians throw the kitchen sink at the pawns, then a queen shows up and they are all fked.


Except they are using their newest stuff, and their elite units.
txags92
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
HarryJ33tamu said:

ATX_AG_08 said:

PJYoung said:




I've never seen anyone look so brave while wearing skinny jeans.


Good thing that one guy has his yoga mat
You can always tell the people that have never camped on cold ground before...
RebelE Infantry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
bangobango said:

RebelE Infantry said:

rathAG05 said:

RebelE Infantry said:

LostInLA07 said:

That's already happening. O&G is their last source of outside cash but the impact to everyday Russians from the current sanctions will be substantial, particularly in the cities where many of their citizens are accustomed to daily interaction with western people, products and tech.

The iPhone they are currently holding is likely the last one they will ever have. Most of their apps don't work anymore. Eventually the russian stock market will have to reopen and anyone with capital in that market is going to take crushing losses that they will likely never recover from.

Frankly, the biggest risk here is that we inadvertently re-create a post WW1 Germany and end up with a population in Russia that hates us because of the sanctions imposed by the west. They'll kick out Putin but who knows what the sentiment will be when they are figuring out who the replacement will be. It could be another militaristic nationalist who rallies a desperate and humiliated population.


I'm afraid this is exactly what we're hurtling headlong towards and no one seems to be interested in talking about it. Private corporations are going far beyond the official sanctions and only making this even more likely.


Yeah, but what choice does the global community have? If Putin is unwilling to relent and pull out, and we are unwilling to directly engage, I don't see another option. We can't blame ourselves for the actions of an evil dictator. This totally sucks, but what he is doing is devastating.


You pressure Zelensky to come to the table for a negotiated peace to end a war he can't possibly win.
And how do you do that? How do you apply more pressure on him than what he is dealing with already? That man is ready to die to defend his country and its freedom.


First of all you stop giving him truckloads of weapons so that he can stop feeding his people into a meat grinder. Then you find a way to structure a peace where Russians strategic interests are addressed in exchange for easing of sanctions. Otherwise it's just the west using Ukraine as cannon fodder for a proxy war against Russia and that's the last thing we should want.
wangus12
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Ag In Ok said:

Has the eastern Uke army pushed to cross to the western bank of the DNeiper river?
I don't think so. I think they're still trying to hold advances and there are one's behind the lines hitting supply routes.
sts7049
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
AggieLit said:

BusterAg said:

Irish 2.0 said:



Russia having to sell their oil at massive discount to get it out
The American people need to boycott Shell gasoline stations.
Most of them aren't owned by Shell, they're owned by a local mom and pop and only the pumps are leased to a supplier that may have licensing to use the Shell brand name, but actual financial connection to Shell is little or none. Few things in real estate are more complex than gas stations and it is usually best to use whatever newer gas station (because newer ones have cleaner tanks) is most convenient and not think about it.



Shell owns a pretty good retail footprint in the US actually
Irish 2.0
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I really hope the snipers are targeting officers
PJYoung
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
First Page Last Page
Page 233 of 1368
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.