Is the wedding at Cana an intersession by Mary to Jesus?
10andBOUNCE said:
Christ fulfilled the fullness of the law, and the wedding is a great picture of the 5th commandment.
To then turn that into intercession that can even be applied to us through his mother is quite the leap.
File5 said:
I don't understand this. It applied to the people at the wedding. She saw their need and interceded for them. If she's alive in heaven (and I believe all saints are) then she can do the same for us there. Jesus saves and has the power, she's just interceding exactly like the wedding here. How is this a stretch of logic?
Howdy, it is me! said:File5 said:
I don't understand this. It applied to the people at the wedding. She saw their need and interceded for them. If she's alive in heaven (and I believe all saints are) then she can do the same for us there. Jesus saves and has the power, she's just interceding exactly like the wedding here. How is this a stretch of logic?
But we don't need her to do that.
Frok said:
The Bible teaches that the Holy Spirit is our intercessor
Frok said:
True, Jesus is our mediator and the Holy Spirit intercedes for us.
Frok said:
That is not clear to me, you can theorize that but it doesn't line up with the rest of scripture IMO.
Nobody prays to anyone other than God. The incense is the prayers of the saints but I don't see any instruction for other saints to pray to the saints.
FTACo88-FDT24dad said:Frok said:
That is not clear to me, you can theorize that but it doesn't line up with the rest of scripture IMO.
Nobody prays to anyone other than God. The incense is the prayers of the saints but I don't see any instruction for other saints to pray to the saints.
It's not theory anymore than your theory that no one prays to anyone other than God. But of course, if it's just each of us and our Bible a la sola scriptura you don't have any principled way to contradict the biblical exegesis I just gave you, other than your subjective opinion. So, you do you.
Where are the instructions to use the Bible alone as the rule of faith? I'll hang up and listen.
FTACo88-FDT24dad said:Howdy, it is me! said:File5 said:
I don't understand this. It applied to the people at the wedding. She saw their need and interceded for them. If she's alive in heaven (and I believe all saints are) then she can do the same for us there. Jesus saves and has the power, she's just interceding exactly like the wedding here. How is this a stretch of logic?
But we don't need her to do that.
Do you ask others to pray for you? You don't "need" them either.
FTACo88-FDT24dad said:FTACo88-FDT24dad said:Frok said:
That is not clear to me, you can theorize that but it doesn't line up with the rest of scripture IMO.
Nobody prays to anyone other than God. The incense is the prayers of the saints but I don't see any instruction for other saints to pray to the saints.
It's not theory anymore than your theory that no one prays to anyone other than God. But of course, if it's just each of us and our Bible a la sola scriptura you don't have any principled way to contradict the biblical exegesis I just gave you, other than your subjective opinion. So, you do you.
Where are the instructions to use the Bible alone as the rule of faith? I'll hang up and listen.
File5 said:
Says who? Scripture?
Frok said:FTACo88-FDT24dad said:FTACo88-FDT24dad said:Frok said:
That is not clear to me, you can theorize that but it doesn't line up with the rest of scripture IMO.
Nobody prays to anyone other than God. The incense is the prayers of the saints but I don't see any instruction for other saints to pray to the saints.
It's not theory anymore than your theory that no one prays to anyone other than God. But of course, if it's just each of us and our Bible a la sola scriptura you don't have any principled way to contradict the biblical exegesis I just gave you, other than your subjective opinion. So, you do you.
Where are the instructions to use the Bible alone as the rule of faith? I'll hang up and listen.
Quick note, I did a typo, I meant to say IN SCRIPTURE nobody prays to anyone other than God.
Scripture is the only infallible authority, all traditions and teachings come from what we know in scripture. It's THE authority that can't be argued with.
Srby said:
Question for the Protestants here:
We both agree demons are real and have personalized influence on us. They know us well enough to tempt at our weakest points (Matthew 4, Acts 5:3, 1 Peter 5:8), and some form of interaction across the spiritual divide is real (James 4:7, Ephesians 6). This doesn't grant them omniscience; they observe, exploit patterns, and use preternatural abilities under God's limits (Job 12).
If God sovereignly permits fallen spiritual beings this targeted awareness and harmful influence, why would it be inconsistent for Him to grant greater awareness and intercessory ability to the glorified saints in heaven that have been perfected in love, fully alive in Christ, and part of the same Body?
Death doesn't sever our union in Christ (Romans 8:38-39). We are one Body: Church militant on earth and triumphant in heaven. The rich man in Hades still cared about his brothers (Luke 16), how much more the saints in glory?
We already accept good angels interact with and assist humans throughout Scripture. If angels can do this, why withhold it from glorified humans, made in God's image, redeemed by Christ, and who are now crowned with glory?
The question isn't whether non-corporeal beings can be aware of and engaged with the living, we agree they can and do. It's whether God would grant this to saints who love us perfectly in Him. If He permits it to demons (for His purposes and our testing), why deny it to His closest friends?
Quote:
This claim falls flat every time. You're making an assumption, without any Scriptural support, that Mary and the Saints have any means of hearing each individual's prayer towards them.
That support does not exist.
Thaddeus73 said:Quote:
This claim falls flat every time. You're making an assumption, without any Scriptural support, that Mary and the Saints have any means of hearing each individual's prayer towards them.
That support does not exist.
It does exist if you read your bible, that says that those who are united to Jesus become ONE Spirit with him, that we become partakers of the divine nature, and that saints in heaven present our prayers to God in the form of incense.
Frok said:
Scripture is the only infallible authority, all traditions and teachings come from what we know in scripture. It's THE authority that can't be argued with.
Faithful Ag said:Frok said:
Scripture is the only infallible authority, all traditions and teachings come from what we know in scripture. It's THE authority that can't be argued with.
Respectfully, you have it precisely reversed. Holy Scripture came into existence through Sacred Tradition and Christ's chosen, authoritative and visible Church…His chosen and appointed teachers (namely His Apostles and their appointed successors). This complicated process took hundreds of years.
Scripture testifies to the Traditions and Apostolic Teachings and vice versa, but the Scriptures do not replace or make obsolete those teachings and their proper meaning. One does not replace the other and the two are inseparable.
Scripture is unique in that the text is fixed (although translations vary). The meaning of the text is what matters. It is not possible for a text or book to be THE infallible authority because the meaning or interpretation of the text requires human understanding and application to our lives.
Jesus established His church and chose his apostles and disciples and Jesus gave those MEN his authority. Through generations of those men the faith comes to use which includes Scripture and tradition. Read your Bible and what the text says…The AUTHORITY is placed with Jesus' appointed teachers who lead the Church, which is the pillar and ground of the truth. All authority is given to them including the power to forgive and retain sins. There is nothing in the Bible that shifts any authority away from the church in favor of scripture.
Scripture is literally fruit of the Sacred Tradition of the Church.
Quote:
To answer your question, though, I would think because no saint needs to be able to shepherd us from heaven, as Jesus is more than capable.