*Hype Meter Intensifies* pic.twitter.com/mbyBaZBcDA
— Josh (@theMcSwag) February 10, 2026
*Hype Meter Intensifies* pic.twitter.com/mbyBaZBcDA
— Josh (@theMcSwag) February 10, 2026
The Blue Goose said:500,000ags said:
Dunk must have been a busy man if in 90 years he's got descendants all over the place and of high- and low- birth.
Especially since we know from the Joffrey / Jaime book conversation that Ser Duncan the Tall becomes a member of the Kings Guard. Aren't they sworn to celibacy?
canadiaggie said:
Side note, I think they absolutely nailed the casting for Baelor and Maekar. The perfect heir and the pri.ckly, stern warrior.
T dizl televizl said:
Could also be that he is weary of knighting someone who will most likely die in the battle (in his mind)
Nagler said:T dizl televizl said:
Could also be that he is weary of knighting someone who will most likely die in the battle (in his mind)
This was my first thought. He's worried he's going to get killed.
AgHawkeye said:Nagler said:T dizl televizl said:
Could also be that he is weary of knighting someone who will most likely die in the battle (in his mind)
This was my first thought. He's worried he's going to get killed.
I thought that at first but he didn't hesitate to let Ser Lyonel knight him.
Prosperdick said:AgHawkeye said:Nagler said:T dizl televizl said:
Could also be that he is weary of knighting someone who will most likely die in the battle (in his mind)
This was my first thought. He's worried he's going to get killed.
I thought that at first but he didn't hesitate to let Ser Lyonel knight him.
I agree...when he first meets Raymun sparring with Ser Steffon he's impressed with his skill and is surprised to learn he's a squire. I think he's reluctant because he knows he's never been knighted and doesn't want to "spoil" the act.
Brian Earl Spilner said:
So here's a question for discussion. (Once again, not interested in book spoilers.)
Baelor and his Kingsguards will be fighting on opposite sides. Given that their sworn duty is to protect the crown prince, would they be forced to protect him during the combat?
I wonder if this already crossed his mind and he essentially weighted the trial heavily in Dunk's favor by joining his side.
500,000ags said:
I don't even understand the goal of this trial by combat. Obviously it's over if Dunk is killed, but short of that does every last one of your 7 have to be killed. Not mad at the uncertainty, but idk if we're looking at 2 deaths or 10.
What's at stake is different for both sides. If the accuser (Aerion) dies, the accused (Dunc) is exonerated. Nobody else has to die. The reverse is true, of course. But the fight also ends if either Aerion or Dunc yields. The problem for Dunc is that yielding means his sentence will still be carried out because yielding is an admission of guilt. Aerion can yield without penalty; he is the accuser. Dunc is the only one on trial.500,000ags said:
I don't even understand the goal of this trial by combat. Obviously it's over if Dunk is killed, but short of that does every last one of your 7 have to be killed. Not mad at the uncertainty, but idk if we're looking at 2 deaths or 10.
G Martin 87 said:What's at stake is different for both sides. If the accuser (Aerion) dies, the accused (Dunc) is exonerated. Nobody else has to die. The reverse is true, of course. But the fight also ends if either Aerion or Dunc yields. The problem for Dunc is that yielding means his sentence will still be carried out because yielding is an admission of guilt. Aerion can yield without penalty; he is the accuser. Dunc is the only one on trial.500,000ags said:
I don't even understand the goal of this trial by combat. Obviously it's over if Dunk is killed, but short of that does every last one of your 7 have to be killed. Not mad at the uncertainty, but idk if we're looking at 2 deaths or 10.
G Martin 87 said:
Don't get me started.
G Martin 87 said:
Don't get me started.
redline248 said:
If this were to happen for real, I can only imagine that the Kingsguard would stay away from Baelor and might even intervene to protect him from some of the non-Targaryen knights on Aerion's side. Baelor and Maeker seem to get along well enough that I don't see them going toe-to-toe with any real intent. Nor do I think Baelor would really try to kill Aerion. The Baratheon is also "cousin" to Targaryens, right? What a complicated mess.
For sure one of the Fossoways is dead.
500,000ags said:
I'm curious what individual fights we see. Obviously, Dunk will want Aeron for this entire mess. Steffon and Raymun definitely want to fight one another. The guy who broke his leg will also want Aeron (if on horse). I want to see the Baratheon take on essentially anyone. Maeker and Dunk have the absolute most on the line, I guess. Maeker has sons at risk and technically he could be heir if Baelor is out of the picture, although answering for the heir's death might cost him his own life. I would add Baelor to that list, but there is zero way those Kingsguard touch him and such a small chance his own family will push things too far. I saw the trailer for Ep5 and if they play a flashback for most of the episode and we don't see much of the fight, I might boycott until the season's over and I can binge it!
I can't really remember the episode, but wasn't one of the Kingsguard a jerk to Dunk or the locals when they showed up in Ashford?Prosperdick said:500,000ags said:
I'm curious what individual fights we see. Obviously, Dunk will want Aeron for this entire mess. Steffon and Raymun definitely want to fight one another. The guy who broke his leg will also want Aeron (if on horse). I want to see the Baratheon take on essentially anyone. Maeker and Dunk have the absolute most on the line, I guess. Maeker has sons at risk and technically he could be heir if Baelor is out of the picture, although answering for the heir's death might cost him his own life. I would add Baelor to that list, but there is zero way those Kingsguard touch him and such a small chance his own family will push things too far. I saw the trailer for Ep5 and if they play a flashback for most of the episode and we don't see much of the fight, I might boycott until the season's over and I can binge it!
I think Baratheon will bloody up one of the kingsguard since he already made mention of it to Dunc.