I think that was 10,000 years after, not beforehunter2012 said:
Looks interesting, I hope they do Mile Teg proud with this one. Please just don't make the heroines stoic and masculine(the overdone strong-woman trope of the last decade). The Bene Gesserit Frank's books are great examples on how to write female characters. Stick to the formula.
If it does pull from any books it's the son's books(Brian Herbert). Frank never wrote any of the prequels.
AgHawkeye said:
10,000 years in the past …… with identical technology and political systems.
Oh and I will definitely watch.
Based on everything I've heard about Messiah and beyond, this is actually a good thing.Al Bula said:
Yikes. Brian Herbert fan fiction.
I'll be sure to bring the excoriating commentary.
DrEvazanPhD said:I think that was 10,000 years after, not beforehunter2012 said:
Looks interesting, I hope they do Mile Teg proud with this one. Please just don't make the heroines stoic and masculine(the overdone strong-woman trope of the last decade). The Bene Gesserit Frank's books are great examples on how to write female characters. Stick to the formula.
If it does pull from any books it's the son's books(Brian Herbert). Frank never wrote any of the prequels.
Quote:
10,000 years in the past …… with identical technology and political systems.
)Let us all hope they can finish it as well as they start it, if the start is as good as the movies.zap said:
It's HBO, so that is a good thing. Looks interesting...
No, it's MAX because their dumbass CMO thinks there is more equity in the Cinemax name than the HBO name.zap said:
It's HBO, so that is a good thing. Looks interesting...
YouBet said:
I just don't get the hate of Brian Herbert's prequels. No, they do not approach the intellectualness of his dad's stuff, but what could?
I read most of them back in the day and thought they were mostly fun sci-fi.
And if this is 10k years in the past then it's probably before the Butlerian Jihad happened.
Yep. Considering the current rise of AI in real life I can't imagine they won't take advantage of that plot line here.Atreides Ornithopter said:YouBet said:
I just don't get the hate of Brian Herbert's prequels. No, they do not approach the intellectualness of his dad's stuff, but what could?
I read most of them back in the day and thought they were mostly fun sci-fi.
And if this is 10k years in the past then it's probably before the Butlerian Jihad happened.
It's either right before it or right after it. The Butlerian Jihad was always claimed "over 10,000 " years ago. Which is what got rid of AI.
Did you watch Game of Thrones? They've been stuck with Middle Ages-tech for 10,000 years which is much, much worse.Quote:
And the nerd in me still can't buy the technology stagnating for 10000 years
This guy doesn't stoneburner.Madmarttigan said:
Other than planet destroying lasers, did technology in Star Wars evolve much?
Madmarttigan said:
Other than planet destroying lasers, did technology in Star Wars evolve much?
I can appreciate this point of view. The novel God Emperor of Dune is out there for sure but Frank Herbert does very well with this book in my opinion. Herbert really pigeonholed himself with the first three Dune novels since he created an all powerful super-being. Not a whole lot of places to go with Paul Atreides unless it was the Kwisatz Haderach ripping into a multiverse or something which is the overdone trope all the rage with film studios today.Brian Earl Spilner said:
Based on everything I've heard about Messiah and beyond, this is actually a good thing.
Apache said:Quote:
10,000 years in the past …… with identical technology and political systems.
It's not out of the realm of possibility
.
If you ban AI & higher computing, technology will no doubt get to a certain point & then stagnate.
(Honestly at this point if the tech people never made a new Iphone or bigger TV I'd survive
In terms of political systems, there are only so many ways to govern. Plus it is highly plausible that other systems of governments popped up here & there in the intervening years 10K years between this show & the events of Dune.
"meh" can mean slightly different things, I suppose. Is it worth even a watch? Anything redeeming about it at all?swc93 said:
Episode One…meh
