Band of Brothers

15,837 Views | 117 Replies | Last: 3 mo ago by aTmAg
Jugstore Cowboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
ja86 said:

I have watched BOB countless times and never realized the Simon Pegg played William Evans
Doesn't look (or probably sound) anything like him, so it's an easy thing to miss unless you're looking at the cast credits.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Claude! said:

13B said:

Looking forward to the 8th AF version too. I thought it was supposed to already be done.

It's called Masters of the Air, based on the wonderful book by Donald Miller. Latest I'm seeing suggests a spring 2023 release, but who knows if that will happen.
My paternal grandfather was a B-24 copilot in the 15th AF flying out of Roggio Italy

shot down over Yugoslavia. Not good for an American Jew

somehow he made it back. never kept his medals!

I did find a member of his squadron ten years ago who was still alive and sent me a ton of real pictures from their time in training and flying in Europe
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
country said:

BoB and Pacific are equally awesome productions. Everyone should watch Pacific as many times as it takes to see the series for what it is. It is the greatest thing on film to demonstrate the misery of war. You can watch all the 2 hour movies you want that show the misery of war, but nothing like 10 hours of screen time to make you realize just how miserable the Pacific theater was. All war is hell. The Pacific was just on a level that I cannot comprehend. I watch both every year with my boys.
there was not much worse than spending months on New Guinea in 1942-43 battling snakes, monsoons, malaria, heat and the Japanese.

when it seemed we would likely lose the war.
TresPuertas
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Stive said:

The last episode of The Pacific is the most emotional I've ever gotten watching a movie/TV show. The scene where he walks in and his mother is in the kitchen gets me a little but during his first night home when his dad sits down outside his bedroom door, and the hunting scene tear me up completely. They got me bad the first time I watched it and I wasn't sure I could ever fight through those again. I then rewatched the whole thing during Covid and thought for sure I'd be fine on a second watch…but I wasn't.

Those scenes are flat out painful and give you an amazing feel for how returning vets struggle, and how their parents and loved ones feel.


Same here. and it kind of helps me understand and forgive my Grandfather for his behavior after he made it home. Long story short, he married my Grandmother and had my mom and left them both, when my grandmother was 6 months pregnant with my uncle and my mom was 3.

I never met him, but he moved from Olney to Lake Jackson and was just never the same after the war. Major alcohol problems, rage, etc. Apparently what he experienced and saw was just too much to get over.

There is a scene in the last episode where Leckie gets out of a cab and the driver wouldn't take his money, saying something about him being in Europe and being able to get liberty and the Pacific boys only got swamp rot and dysentery.

The pacific isn't supposed to be enjoyed… it's supposed to be experienced. It took me the second time watching to figure this out and not fall into the mistake of comparing it to BoB. Like i said, all of the misery and hopelessness made me at least see why my Grandfather may have acted the way he did
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TresPuertas said:

Stive said:

The last episode of The Pacific is the most emotional I've ever gotten watching a movie/TV show. The scene where he walks in and his mother is in the kitchen gets me a little but during his first night home when his dad sits down outside his bedroom door, and the hunting scene tear me up completely. They got me bad the first time I watched it and I wasn't sure I could ever fight through those again. I then rewatched the whole thing during Covid and thought for sure I'd be fine on a second watch…but I wasn't.

Those scenes are flat out painful and give you an amazing feel for how returning vets struggle, and how their parents and loved ones feel.


Same here. and it kind of helps me understand and forgive my Grandfather for his behavior after he made it home. Long story short, he married my Grandmother and had my mom and left them both, when my grandmother was 6 months pregnant with my uncle and my mom was 3.

I never met him, but he moved from Olney to Lake Jackson and was just never the same after the war. Major alcohol problems, rage, etc. Apparently what he experienced and saw was just too much to get over.

There is a scene in the last episode where Leckie gets out of a cab and the driver wouldn't take his money, saying something about him being in Europe and being able to get liberty and the Pacific boys only got swamp rot and dysentery.

The pacific isn't supposed to be enjoyed… it's supposed to be experienced. It took me the second time watching to figure this out and not fall into the mistake of comparing it to BoB. Like i said, all of the misery and hopelessness made me at least see why my Grandfather may have acted the way he did

very interesting!!

supposedly my paternal grandfather ALSO left my grandmother and was not a good father to my birth father

my mom wanted nothing to do with that family after my birth father was killed when I was 6 years old

interesting I never considered the war as being a cause
aggiedata
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just a small blurb about BoB made in 2001. It holds up quite remarkably. We are so very fortunate it was made in HD film. The image is clear and sharp, with limited CGI.

The cinematography, sound and visual effects still hold up quite well today. I think that matters a great deal.
jeffk
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Just to piggyback and compound your point - it was released in 2001 but shot the previous year in 2000. Holds up incredibly well considering. It's 23 years old.
aggiedata
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I didn't even own a HD TV until 2005.
KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
On the Band of Brothers topic... I strongly recommend reading Stephen Ambrose's books. Just read the Band of Brothers book in January and my goodness it is moving. I have seen the show probably 2-3 times through but had yet to read the book and the book just makes it so much more real to me.

There is also a HBO Band of Brothers Podcast hosted by Roger Bennett that interviews all the actors from the show and it is top stuff as well. Most of the actors met and formed relationships with the men of Easy Company. One of my favorite stories from the podcast has to do with Wild Bill after the war. Don't want to spoil the story for y'all but the summary is the man could handle his liquor.

Lastly, my all time favorite book is Wild Blue. The stories of B-24 pilots and crew in the European theater. Reminds me of my days growing up living near Ellington Field watching the WOH air show seeing P-51's, P-47's, B-24s, P-38's and B-17s. Loved hearing stories of the men who lived and died in those War Birds.

Truly, truly the greatest generation to ever have lived.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KCup17 said:

On the Band of Brothers topic... I strongly recommend reading Stephen Ambrose's books. Just read the Band of Brothers book in January and my goodness it is moving. I have seen the show probably 2-3 times through but had yet to read the book and the book just makes it so much more real to me.

There is also a HBO Band of Brothers Podcast hosted by Roger Bennett that interviews all the actors from the show and it is top stuff as well. Most of the actors met and formed relationships with the men of Easy Company. One of my favorite stories from the podcast has to do with Wild Bill after the war. Don't want to spoil the story for y'all but the summary is the man could handle his liquor.

Lastly, my all time favorite book is Wild Blue. The stories of B-24 pilots and crew in the European theater. Reminds me of my days growing up living near Ellington Field watching the WOH air show seeing P-51's, P-47's, B-24s, P-38's and B-17s. Loved hearing stories of the men who lived and died in those War Birds.

Truly, truly the greatest generation to ever have lived.
My paternal Grandfather was a co-pilot on B-24 Liberators of the 15th Air Force flying out of Foggia Italy

I am pretty sure he was part of the raid on Ploesti

he told me he was shot down over yugoslavia but that's all he said.
AgRyan04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I thought the book gave to a lot more insight on some of the gentlemen who were in the show but didn't get featured as prominently
13B
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KCup17 said:

On the Band of Brothers topic... I strongly recommend reading Stephen Ambrose's books. Just read the Band of Brothers book in January and my goodness it is moving. I have seen the show probably 2-3 times through but had yet to read the book and the book just makes it so much more real to me.

There is also a HBO Band of Brothers Podcast hosted by Roger Bennett that interviews all the actors from the show and it is top stuff as well. Most of the actors met and formed relationships with the men of Easy Company. One of my favorite stories from the podcast has to do with Wild Bill after the war. Don't want to spoil the story for y'all but the summary is the man could handle his liquor.

Lastly, my all time favorite book is Wild Blue. The stories of B-24 pilots and crew in the European theater. Reminds me of my days growing up living near Ellington Field watching the WOH air show seeing P-51's, P-47's, B-24s, P-38's and B-17s. Loved hearing stories of the men who lived and died in those War Birds.

Truly, truly the greatest generation to ever have lived.
Jimmy Stewart: Bomber Pilot is also an interesting read.
Aggie Infantry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Band Of Brothers
Bridge Too Far
Longest Day
Saving Private Ryan

Also... more men died flying in the AAC over Europe than Marines did fighting in all of the Pacific campaigns. 70K Army Air Corps vs 30K USMC.
JABQ04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
While not American but also a Stephen Ambrose book, check out "Pegasus Bridge". That's a whole story that deserves its own movie. It's a book about the some first Allied troops to land on June 6th in gliders to capture a bridge and prevent German counterattacks on the beaches, all the whole not knowing if the landings will even be successful and there's only two companies of you.
*Fun fact. The man who played Major Howard in The Longest Day which covers this, was a member of the British airborne who jumped in to reinforce the glider troops at the bridge on June 6th .
double aught
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My grandfather was a glider pilot. He didn't fly on D-Day, but he did successfully land his glider in Germany during Operation Varsity.

Years ago, my father was able to locate the report that his copilot filed after the mission. It's a trip reading something that describes how close you came to never existing.

KCup17
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I have that on my list. I am working through Undaunted Courage at the moment. But would gladly take any good WWII books similar in style to any of Ambrose's works.
aznaggiegirl07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
aznaggiegirl07
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
i heard that the mini series was shown to the Corps before the series aired.

Was anyone here when they did that? Does anyone remember it?

JABQ04
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
My pisshead year. But I only remember them showing a series preview and episode 2 "Day of Days". It was awesome on the big screen. It was sometime fall semester. What was also cool was they had a big WWII conference/symposium thing at Bush Library that same semester and I was taking some American military history course and got to attend a bunch of the speakers. Also met stephen Ambrose and got my copy of BoB autographed by him.
Claude!
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KCup17 said:

I have that on my list. I am working through Undaunted Courage at the moment. But would gladly take any good WWII books similar in style to any of Ambrose's works.
Masters of the Air, about the 8th Air Force in Europe, is very good and in a similar style. Rick Atkinson's Liberation Trilogy is also worth a read, though it focuses a little less on the lives of the men on the front lines and more on the big picture.
Carioca Corredor
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Here is the link from the Texas A&M Foundation for more info on the scholarship memorializing Al Mamfre from Band of Brothers


Veteran's scholarship
JoeAggie1010
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I enjoyed Band of Brothers. The story was told in such a way, that allowed the audience to become intimate with the characters from the beginning. It's truly astonishing from the training to actual combat. What these soldiers faced throughout the campaign to liberate France, and and ultimately defeat Germany, is difficult to wrap my brain around.

As far as The Pacific, it took a few episodes to fully become engaged. But when you see them defend Guadalcanal against the Japanese, the sheer volume of Japanese is sobering. Then I ask myself how I would perform in those conditions?

Related to BoB, I received a treasured gift when I was in CGSC, which was a print from Dietz, commemorating the 75th Anniversary of Airborne operations. It was signed by Dietz and by Jim "Pee Wee" Martin G/506th Parachute Infantry Regiment. Pee Wee was also an advisor for the movie of Band of Brothers, who has recently passed.
Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
This thread is fantastic and expresses so many of my thoughts on BoB. My son and I watched it the first time when he was a sophmore in high school. He is 30 years old now and we have made it a tradition to watch it every Memorial Day for the past 15 years.

IMO, it is the finest TV program ever made. From the opening scene on the airstrip with Winters and Nixon, to the flashback at Camp Tacoa, to the Atlantic crossing and training in England, to flight over the channel, the drop, regathering, and their first action at Brecout Manor, the first two episodes are absolutely stunning. Breaking Point is also a favorite. There are too many fantastic scents to recount here, but the acting throughout is some of the best ever.

The short interviews at the beginning of every episode are so well done and add such a human touch to the episodes. Of course now I know who these men are, but the first time you watch you don't find out their names until the montage at the end of Episode Ten. I get tears in my eyes every time it gets to the baseball game at the end and Winters tells where each of the men are and where they live, some still alive, some passed on - followed by the interviews that reveal the identity of each man.

I am thankful these heroes told their story and that Spielberg and Hanks put it on film. Someone mentioned the segments on the making of BoB and I highly recommend watching it. The boot camp the actors went through and the training they had helped them make it seem real on the screen. They became their own Band of Brothers during the filming.

One of my favorite moments -



DB Coach
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I couldn't agree more! And I love that it has become a tradition with your son...so special.
Lathspell
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
You do know the interviews are actually from a separate documentary about Easy company called We Stand Alone Together?

Ag87H2O
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I think I saw this years ago but thanks for posting. I'm going to watch it again.
CoolaidWade
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I need to watch Bob again. Prob the 4th or 5th time. I have a hard time watching The Pacific. I only saw it once as it aired.
Max Power
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
CoolaidWade said:

I need to watch Bob again. Prob the 4th or 5th time. I have a hard time watching The Pacific. I only saw it once as it aired.
You should rewatch The Pacific. It didn't really hit me the first time I watched it either. I rewatched after reading With The Old Breed, which is one of the two books it's based on. The Pacific theater was a much different kind of conflict than what the soldiers engaged in Europe faced. I think it did a great job illustrating that fact. I think they are each great for what they are but BoB is my favorite piece of WWII based show of any kind, including movies. It's my favorite book about WWII experiences as well.
StinkyPinky
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Wife and I watches BoB again last month (was her first time). She normally doesn't like war stories, but loved this. A testament to the quality and execution.
RangerRick9211
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Is this new on Netflix? It just popped up on my feed.

I instantly jumped to Episode 2 for my daily, wtf, omg, holy ****, fix.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
TresPuertas said:

Stive said:

The last episode of The Pacific is the most emotional I've ever gotten watching a movie/TV show. The scene where he walks in and his mother is in the kitchen gets me a little but during his first night home when his dad sits down outside his bedroom door, and the hunting scene tear me up completely. They got me bad the first time I watched it and I wasn't sure I could ever fight through those again. I then rewatched the whole thing during Covid and thought for sure I'd be fine on a second watch…but I wasn't.

Those scenes are flat out painful and give you an amazing feel for how returning vets struggle, and how their parents and loved ones feel.


Same here. and it kind of helps me understand and forgive my Grandfather for his behavior after he made it home. Long story short, he married my Grandmother and had my mom and left them both, when my grandmother was 6 months pregnant with my uncle and my mom was 3.

I never met him, but he moved from Olney to Lake Jackson and was just never the same after the war. Major alcohol problems, rage, etc. Apparently what he experienced and saw was just too much to get over.

There is a scene in the last episode where Leckie gets out of a cab and the driver wouldn't take his money, saying something about him being in Europe and being able to get liberty and the Pacific boys only got swamp rot and dysentery.

The pacific isn't supposed to be enjoyed… it's supposed to be experienced. It took me the second time watching to figure this out and not fall into the mistake of comparing it to BoB. Like i said, all of the misery and hopelessness made me at least see why my Grandfather may have acted the way he did

not to get too morbid- but MY grandfather was the same way!

in fact I never had a relationship with him growing up because he had treated my birth father so badly and left my grandmother.

long story short, he got back in touch with me when I was in law school by finding me on the internet and we were able to see each other a few times before he passed away.
The Porkchop Express
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I finally got my wife to watch Band of Brothers starting last week. We finished episode 9, "Why We Fight" a few minute ago. I haven't watched it since it came out in 2001. In all this time I don't think i've seen anything else that compares to the emotional crescendo that those actors and crew carry out when they find the death camp. Incredible TV.
JDUB08AG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
The Porkchop Express said:

I finally got my wife to watch Band of Brothers starting last week. We finished episode 9, "Why We Fight" a few minute ago. I haven't watched it since it came out in 2001. In all this time I don't think i've seen anything else that compares to the emotional crescendo that those actors and crew carry out when they find the death camp. Incredible TV.


Definitely the most powerful episode for me.
LMCane
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Aggie Infantry said:

Band Of Brothers
Bridge Too Far
Longest Day
Saving Private Ryan

Also... more men died flying in the AAC over Europe than Marines did fighting in all of the Pacific campaigns. 70K Army Air Corps vs 30K USMC.
are you including all the Army soldiers killed at Guadalcanal, Leyte Gulf/Manila, Okinawa?
Lathspell
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
He said Marines, not Army.
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.