Story Poster
Photo by Lindsay Caudle, TexAgs
Texas A&M Football

Thoughts on the hate-filled letter sent to Kevin Sumlin

September 8, 2017
40,382

So the Aggies lost a football game on Sunday night and it's been a busy week of writing articles and talking on radio for yours truly since returning from L.A. The first week back on the grind is always tough and it's especially tough when you're trying to break down what happened during a truly inexplicable loss like the one we all saw unfold at the Rose Bowl. Emotions run high and, suddenly, for some reason folks begin to think it's okay for Aggies to attack Aggies all over message boards and on social media. It's rough out there on Aggie Twitter, in The Zoo and even inside the Premium forums. No one is safe and even I knew on the long flight home that there would be plenty of folks coming for their pound of e-flesh for me or anyone else who dared compliment this team or its coaches and players at any point during the six-month off-season. 

Guess what? As far as I'm concerned, that comes with the territory. Doesn't mean I have to like it, but I feel like we at TexAgs have created a pretty nice gig, we receive a lot of positive attention and the community is usually an amazing place to convene to talk Aggie sports. It's comprised of not good but truly great people. All you need to do is look at the rich history of folks on this site helping others in time of need for proof of that. That's also the case when it comes to the Texas A&M fan and alumni base from coast to coast. From the Red, White and Blue Out to the Maroon Wall to this weekend's BTHO Harvey fundraiser and countless smaller acts of group and individual kindness in between, Aggies are always there to lend a helping hand.

Despite that, the fact of the matter is that frustration occasionally gets the best of some of us. It happens. You lost your mind on Sunday night and got banned from TexAgs? Take to Twitter and say that I'm a thin-skinned jerk, more power to you. The Aggies blow a 34-point lead and drop a game to UCLA that they had no business losing? Take to the TexAgs forums, call into the Finebaum Show and criticize Kevin Sumlin on Twitter until you get it all out. As far as I'm concerned, that too comes with the territory. 

For Sumlin and college football coaches from coast to coast, thick skin and the ability to walk through life (especially when it comes to social media) with blinders on is virtually a job requirement. Like many college coaches, Kevin is testy and defensive with the media at times, but he understands that being second-guessed and even ripped for any failures (real or perceived) following losses like Sunday night's incredibly frustrating setback are part of what you sign up for when you put your John Hancock on a $5MM/yr contract.

What you don't sign up for, however, is for your family to be harassed by an angry fan at any point along the way, no matter how bad a game or season goes. And you damned sure don't sign up to be targeted by an card-carrying racist pig. Ever.

On Thursday night, Charlene Sumlin posted a picture of a hate-filled, racially-charged letter — complete with an utterly disgusting slur — that was either mailed or placed in the mailbox of the Sumlin home. My first feeling when I read the note was complete and utter disgust. "Who in their right mind could ever write that, send it and walk away feeling good about themselves?" Then came anger. "What I wouldn't give to be able to literally break the hand that wrote that letter..."

Now? I'm just saddened by it. Truth is, we may never know the monster who put those words — and THAT word — to paper. What I do know, however, is this: Kevin Sumlin is a friend of mine and has been since sometime around 2000, long before he or I ever imagined he'd be the head football coach at Texas A&M. That's also the time I got to know Char and their family, which at the time included their two daughters, Courtney and Shelby, and didn't quite yet include Jackson and Joey. We lit a cigar when he was promoted to offensive coordinator by R.C. Slocum back in 2002 and I spent the afternoon with Kevin and his parents when he was coaching in Norman following 77-0. Since he took over in College Station, it hasn't always been easy ... especially with me covering his team through some tough times of late. We certainly don't always see eye to eye and have had our differences but the friendship will survive his time at A&M whether he's ultimately fired (something I'd cover as extensively and in-depth as I did his hiring in 2012), leaves Aggieland on his own accord or retires in the Maroon & White several years from now.

So last night, a friend and his family had to experience all of the anger, rage, unimaginable frustration, probably even a slight loss of faith in humanity that comes with a racially-motivated attack (and that's exactly what this was) and that makes me sick. And for what? Because he's not winning enough football games for this cowardly racists taste? Because a fan of another school went out of their way to give Texas A&M a very public black eye? To kick a man when he's down? 

Well, even though the thought of Char or Kevin (or God forbid one of their children) opening that letter makes me cringe, I do know this much: The Aggie head coach won't let this outwardly phase him. I spoke to him this evening not to talk about the UCLA loss but simply to let him know how disgusted I was to see that letter and I could hear the disappointment in his voice. Then again, I know that Sumlin will do the same thing that his late father, Bill, did when he dealt with racism every day while growing up and later serving as a high school coach in the segregated South. He'll persevere. He'll also focus on the task at hand, which is figuring out how to get his team to bounce back from a bitterly-disappointing season-opening loss, setting the same example for his players that his father set for him as a young man, which is to not allow hate or prejudice derail your day, your drive or your dream.

That's especially true when the message comes from a single, cowardly and (shocker) anonymous source. Make no mistake, this racist toad in no way represents the Aggie fan as a whole. That's another part of this story that saddens me. Like most of you, I wear my Aggie Ring proudly and I live in this community. Just like the jackass who left a particularly hateful note on then-A&M quarterback Corey Pullig's car 20 years ago following a big-game loss, the author of the Sumlin note does not accurately represent the 12th Man and the spirit of what being an Aggie is about (assuming the culprit actually attended the university). Unfortunately, most who pick up this story won't include that disclaimer and our school takes the hit and the sad thing is there are rival recruiters, both white and black alike mind you, who will attempt to use this story to their advantage without conscience. Don't fault Char Sumlin for letting that note go public and quickly go viral, however, because it's important for us to get the occasional, disturbing reminder that this type of crap hasn't gone away simply because there are more coaches of color today than there were 10, 15 or 20 years ago.

Sumlin likely felt as if he was fighting for his job this week and I'm sure he was. He may well be doing so between now and November, feeling the pressure and riding the wave of each win or loss. That's what he signed up for when he took over in Aggieland and parlayed a white-hot start into a big, SEC-caliber financial windfall. What he didn't think he'd be fighting this week was unabashed racism and I wish I knew who the scumbag was that woke up Monday and thought a football game gave them a license to be a bigoted animal.

Consider this my letter and feel free to include your own on this thread. This doesn't have anything to do with wins or losses and won't have any bearing whatsoever on Sumlin's future in Aggieland. As far as the present is concerned, I'm of the opinion that it would be nice to give the head coach and his family something to smile about today in light of what happened yesterday.

And if you disagree and think language such as the one in that letter is acceptable, please cancel your subscription because you and your money aren't wanted on the site or this community that we've worked so hard to build.

Discussion from...

Thoughts on the hate-filled letter sent to Kevin Sumlin

27,974 Views | 86 Replies | Last: 6 yr ago by Texan1976
NightHawk150
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Right! I completely agree.

But that doesn't mean that the Sumlins wrote this as many in the board were claiming last night.

If if comes out that they were the ones responsible for this from the beginning, I'll gladly eat crow. Until that comes out, I will take their side and believe they received the letter, and are not the source of it.
tamucorpsguy05
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Regardless of where this season finishes, the Sumlins are a part of our Aggie family and always will be. Someone attacked our family. In this moment, it is important we set aside opinions on football and stand up for an attack on our family.
RangerRick9211
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

Wife sharing the letter on social media was horribly irresponsible. I can't emphasize this enough.
Proud of her for sharing it. Can't emphasize that enough.


So you're okay with the damage inflicted on the reputation of the entire A&M family because of the idiocy of one person who may not even be affiliated with said family.

Seems logical to me. You win.
Post the quote where she contributes it to A&M or our fans. You can fault the media, but not her.
.

She does not.
Awesome. Didn't read the rest because it doesn't matter: human beings > universities > football. She get's that and people not in the echo-chambers of the Zoo or Politics board do as well.
Olesalt@sbcglobal.net
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
I first stood with the 12th Man as a fish in 1955. I have had some wonderful moments watching the Ags and some terrible ones. But nothing in all of these years was more agonizing then the letter to our coach. It goes against everything that Aggies believe. I just wish they could catch him and turn him over to the piss heads that taught me what this Aggie thing is all about. They would give him a good old fashion class of 1959 red ass.
Deputy Travis Junior
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You're completely right. I misunderstood your point. Edited
NightHawk150
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Husky Boy Jr.
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
olesallt@sbcglobal.net said:

I first stood with the 12th Man as a fish in 1955. I have had some wonderful moments watching the Ags and some terrible ones. But nothing in all of these years was more agonizing then the letter to our coach. It goes against everything that Aggies believe. I just wish they could catch him and turn him over to the piss heads that taught me what this Aggie thing is all about. They would give him a good old fashion class of 1959 red ass.
BanderaAg956
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Racist crap is unnecessary, leave it at poor coaching!
offenseguru
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Amazing Moves
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quote:

Author should be disassociated with our university (if they are associated w/TAMU).
Since we have no proof that this was an Aggie, the situation should've not been perpetuated. Obviously, the disgust is warranted but, the assumed backlash toward Aggies on social media is outrageous. This should have been considered before posting the letter on twitter.
kblake
How long do you want to ignore this user?
RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

Wife sharing the letter on social media was horribly irresponsible. I can't emphasize this enough.
Proud of her for sharing it. Can't emphasize that enough.


So you're okay with the damage inflicted on the reputation of the entire A&M family because of the idiocy of one person who may not even be affiliated with said family.

Seems logical to me. You win.
Post the quote where she contributes it to A&M or our fans. You can fault the media, but not her.
.

She does not.
Awesome. Didn't read the rest because it doesn't matter: human beings > universities > football. She get's that and people not in the echo-chambers of the Zoo or Politics board do as well.


So you're gonna argue until you decide it's easier to not read "the rest". Whatever.


And thanks for deleting my original response, ******bag.

"She does not. But I doubt she is so naive to think that she could post on the heels of Sunday's meltdown without social media connecting the two. Give me a break!"
duffelpud
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Tap the brakes there on the "monster" talk. Hitler was a monster. Stalin was a monster. Jeffery Dahmer was a monster.

Whoever wrote 'the letter' is just an idiot. Living life inside their own head is just the beginning of their punishment.
"What's this button do?"
RangerRick9211
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

RangerRick9211 said:

kblake said:

Wife sharing the letter on social media was horribly irresponsible. I can't emphasize this enough.
Proud of her for sharing it. Can't emphasize that enough.


So you're okay with the damage inflicted on the reputation of the entire A&M family because of the idiocy of one person who may not even be affiliated with said family.

Seems logical to me. You win.
Post the quote where she contributes it to A&M or our fans. You can fault the media, but not her.
.

She does not.
Awesome. Didn't read the rest because it doesn't matter: human beings > universities > football. She get's that and people not in the echo-chambers of the Zoo or Politics board do as well.


So you're gonna argue until you decide it's easier to not read "the rest". Whatever.

And thanks for deleting my stupid response, you beautiful MFer. I owe you one!

It's almost like deleting it was a metaphor of not reading it. /mindblown.gif

Oops, metaphored again. This time with a little flair.
LatinAggie1997
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
soso33 said:

I'm glad she shared the letter. Racism can not survive in the light of day. It doesn't matter who sent it or what their motivation was. And I don't prescribe any other motive to her sharing the letter than letting the sunlight do its disinfecting work and to possibly share a sense of what it's like in the fishbowl.

She has every right to do so. I appreciate her actions.




Not condoning anything.

It is a little irresponsible to assume the author is a racist. "It doesn't matter who sent it or what their motivation was."
It certainly does matter as it pertains to this story and the timing.
Foxo
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
How childish of the writer.
AGinHI
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
"...your family to be harassed by an angry fan?"

How do you know it's a fan? What if it is someone that has no affiliation or interest in A&M at all, and maybe is not even racist, but someone who wants to cause irreparable harm to our university and football program?

Your article is biased and represents the emotional overreactions and turmoil the country is going through without first obtaining any objective information.
AnalogyAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
if i let some letter go public that was unfairly doing tremendous damage to a family i loved (or at least respected in any way) and i had the ability to make it go away by publicly supporting my family and making it clear that letter IN NO WAY WHATSOEVER reflects what i know and have experienced of my family, I'D BE OUT THERE DOING THAT!

where the hell is Ms Sumlin and Mr. Sumlin now that this family needs them more than ever???

the silence of the Sumlins is deafening!
Chester
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Do not assume this letter is from an Aggie or Aggie fan.This letter is just the kind of stuff some tu sip would do to make A&M look bad.
OverSeas AG
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Every knee shall bow and every tongue shall confess
FishingAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Amazing Moves said:

Quote:

Author should be disassociated with our university (if they are associated w/TAMU).
Since we have no proof that this was an Aggie, the situation should've not been perpetuated. Obviously, the disgust is warranted but, the assumed backlash toward Aggies on social media is outrageous. This should have been considered before posting the letter on twitter.


You took the part of that post you wanted

I've said all along the letter should never have been posted on twitter. It did exactly what mrs s. Didn't want to happen. It showed the kids. In fact it showed kids everywhere. That speaks volumes right there.

I don't agree with the letter or the posting.
Her posting it was anger I believe from the scrutiny kds is under. It's going to greatly hinder his job options. Imo. Letter should have gone to police if she's truly worried.

Sex Panther
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Quote:

Her posting it was anger I believe from the scrutiny kds is under. It's going to greatly hinder his job options. Imo. Letter should have gone to police if she's truly worried.

I don't believe that Sumlin plans on coaching again... but I do think he plans on being an analyst/on tv.

Wonder how the letter affected his chances at that role?
FishingAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sex Panther said:

Quote:

Her posting it was anger I believe from the scrutiny kds is under. It's going to greatly hinder his job options. Imo. Letter should have gone to police if she's truly worried.

I don't believe that Sumlin plans on coaching again... but I do think he plans on being an analyst/on tv.

Wonder how the letter affected his chances at that role?


Never thought about that. Won't help for sure. This is a bad deal all the way around.

She should never had mentioned kids seeing it...
then her post would not be as bad. It's hurting TAMU. She had to know that was going to happen. Had to be posted in anger. Hurting your employer isn't a good thing.
PikesPeakAg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
To me this all bolis down to a simple fact, the Sumlins, members of our family, were the recipients of a racist letter from either an A&M "fan" or someone else. No matter I stand with them. I don't know them, I don't have too. I have long believed that at Texas A&M we stand for something. Something good . This runs contrary to that. It doesn't matter what she did with the letter. I have no idea what I would do if I received a racistist hate letter. It's sick that anyone would suggest that they created the whole thing. Most things are much more important than football. If Texas A&M were to win the national championship for the next 10 straight years if would have zero effect on my or familes life other than some whooping it up. Similarly losing has zero effect on daily life. Being a graduate of Texas A&M, a Christian, etc demands that we stand up for whats right. If you feel that attacking them outside of critizing coach for poor coaching is acceptable you need to find another family to be a part of.
No material on this site is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See full Medical Disclaimer.
Amazing Moves
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FishingAggie said:

Amazing Moves said:

Quote:

Author should be disassociated with our university (if they are associated w/TAMU).
Since we have no proof that this was an Aggie, the situation should've not been perpetuated. Obviously, the disgust is warranted but, the assumed backlash toward Aggies on social media is outrageous. This should have been considered before posting the letter on twitter.


You took the part of that post you wanted

I've said all along the letter should never have been posted on twitter. It did exactly what mrs s. Didn't want to happen. It showed the kids. In fact it showed kids everywhere. That speaks volumes right there.

I don't agree with the letter or the posting.
Her posting it was anger I believe from the scrutiny kds is under. It's going to greatly hinder his job options. Imo. Letter should have gone to police if she's truly worried.


I understood all of that in your post and liked it.

It's my fault for not making my post clear. I took that quote as a general example to make a point about the social media backlash I've been seeing. How things can easily get out of hand these days. It wasn't meant to be a direct reply, assumption, or, scrutiny toward your post. My apologies for not tactfully conveying that.

The quote struck me as a good simple example of how people need to see this situation and, frankly how it should be responsibly reported. However, we know in today's society that tabloid journalism and click bait social media accounts will fan the flames as far as they will go. That's a big problem in our country that some how needs to be addressed.
FishingAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I'm sorry. Texas A&M football is a littke crazy right now.

MWeg86Agg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
In a converstion with RC Slocum over two decades ago, he told me that quaterbacks and coaches get too much priase when things are going great and they catch too much grief when they are not going well at all.

Furthermore, he said he was thick skinned but the players are often 18, 19 and 20 year old kids. I have shared this conversation with many over the years. Anyone that would send a threat to a student player or send a racist letter or remark to anyone is a discrace to our society. I am an Aggie, father and a citizen and we know that these bigots walk the streets every day. I suggest you treat this like someone you would pass on the street that was not representing morality. Talk to your family, do the right thing and these people will have their day. That day will be worse than the best day they would have ever had on a field. Gig em!!
Michael Wegner
LatinAggie1997
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Why is it a foregone conclusion that the author is a true racist? It could be a ploy. Personally, I think it is unwise to make definitive declarations with little knowledge. The content of the letter is terrible but the author and the motive are unknown.
C4D
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Great Letter

Good Bull Billy

aggiehawg
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
Mr. Liucci,

I wish to applaud your eloquence in expressing your (and the Sumlin's) shock and dismay at this despicable action by a person unknown. I respect your long association and friendship with them.

Please convey the horror and outrage, we former students feel, to the Sumlin Family as well. Whomever wrote that and sent it deserves whatever bad that comes their way.

My prayers to the kids that they reach an understanding with it and not let this affect them going forward with their lives. Stuff happens and it isn't always pleasant nor fair. Regrets and grudges are the purview of older adults, not young adults just beginning to feel their way into full adulthood. This doesn't have to become a self-limiting experience but a self-empowerment experience. Choosing to ignore the bad and not allowing the fact that life isn't always fair nor the way you wish it would be, is just a reality to which adults must adapt.

Coach Sumlin and Mrs. Sumlin, thank you both for your endless work and support during a treacherous transition from the Big XII to the SEC. I understand that you both kind of came late to that party, yet embraced it and took the program to great heights that oh-so-iffy first year. For that, many Ags will be eternally grateful. Most prognisticators had us completely bombing in the SEC. (And taking the perennial Cheshire Cat smile off of Deloss Dodd's face was pure icing on the cake.)

So, thank you for that inexplicable feeling of long overdue schadenfreude. (Helluva ride, beat Bama and a Heisman! Fun stuff for us oldsters.)

If the time has come for us to part ways, such will be revealed when it is. Until then, please embrace and accept the good sentiments and prayers sent in your direction by the Aggie faithful.

Best wishes for all of your futures, whatever happens.
No Ag Tag Ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
What if a black dude wrote it? Would hand breaking still be in order?
Cfhh
How long do you want to ignore this user?
As the adult child of a retired high school football coach, my heart goes out to the Sumlin family. Unless you are in their shoes, you have no clue how downright cruel people can be toward coaches and their families over a GAME! Sports can bring out the absolute worst in people. I'm sure this is not the first time they have dealt with this. And it won't be the last either because some people think that coaches and their families are fair game to direct all emotional vitriol.
AggieAL1
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It now makes no difference whether it was an Aggie (alum or supporter) who wrote the letter. It has made the national news and it will be viewed as a letter from a racist Aggie fan. Even if proved otherwise, that information won't be distributed near as widely as the initial reports.

Occasional reading of posts on TexAgs could sure lead a casual observer to believe it was written by an Aggie who dislikes Sumlin, and not solely because of his coaching skills. News related to A&M in the past year (Ladies Day, Spencer) enhance the bias view.

Yes, free speech affords anyone with any opinion to post it, support it or protest for it, and that is as it should be. But A&M has fallen on the dark side of several bias-related issues in the past year and it has sullied the university's national reputation. You can blame leftists nuts, liberal ideologues or the fake-news media as you choose, but in much of the nation we haven't been making a lot of friends lately.


FishingAggie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
You guys won't believe this but most people don't know anything about this

It's true. I've talked to two tu friends and neither knew a thing about any of this. One had "heard" something but didn't bother to check it out.

Checked with another friend and he had no idea what I was talking about

I think mainstream America is busy. Busy working and trying to live. Don't have time for Aggie sports.

You know a lot of people don't even know we blew a lead. This will pass is my point. Pass for TAMU but the ****** that wrote that letter will be getting really nervous about now.

They'll find the person. How it's dealt with. Idk. Justice seems to find a way to the top. May take some time, but it comes calling.

Don't worry Aggies. People know us. They know we are good people. This one letter will not change the minds of the people that matter. Your co-workers know you. Your friends know you. We are not racists. Our school is not racists. Kevin Sumlin knows our school. He knows this is not us. It's one dirt bag. He knows that.

It'll be Ok.
bv86ag
How long do you want to ignore this user?
AG
It would sure be nice if the letter was tested for prints and handled by the FBI crime lab to check for DNA, fibers, saliva,origin of envelope. Any handwriting experts, camera shots of the street Sumlin lives on...list goes on of proper forensic analysis that could be done. Would be interesting. But I don't trust the Brazos County Sheriff's Dept to have those resources or to do what it takes. Needs to be handled by the Texas Rangers and FBI. And yes, a threat should be taken that seriously and the coward caught and thrown into prison.
Eagle78
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Nice letter, Billy. I completely agree that the racist letter is disgusting and does not reflect the A&M community in the slightest.


That said, let me add this: Ms. Sumlin has been the spouse of a head coach of a major college football program for many years. She knows or should know that competing programs look for things to use to negatively recruit against A&M. She knew or should have known that this letter would be used as fodder by our competitors. They'll say things like this reflects the culture at A&M, even though that is an outright falsehood. She knows that head coaches and their families are held to a certain standard to always think before they act because their actions can hurt recruiting or the university. That just goes with the territory of being a head coach or the spouse of a head coach. Thus, there is only one reason that would justify her publishing the letter and that would be if A&M or law enforcement were not vigorously addressing the Sumlins' concerns. I do not believe that is the case. For these reasons, I'm sorry but she just should not have published that letter. She should have publicly just taken it in stride and understood that there are always going to be hateful nut jobs out in the world. I'd like to believe that those types are a tiny tiny tiny percentage of people in America, but regardless, there are always going to be a few. This is true whether you are talking the fanbase of Harvard, Yale, t.u., Duke, us, UCLA, TSU, OU ... you name it. There are always going to be a few because we live in a fallen world and that is just life, and surely she knows that or should know that. One just has to look at our 2 million plus prison population to know that there are a minority of people in this world who lack common decency. To expect otherwise would be to be unrealistic.
Page 2 of 3
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.